Khilafat-e-Rashidah

Page 1

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH by Hadrat Mirza Bashiruddin Mahmood Ahmad ra Khalifatul Masih II 2009 ISLAM INTERNATIONAL PUBLICATIONS LIMITED

Page 2

Khilafat-e-R a shidah by Hadrat Mirza Bashiruddin Mahmood Ahmad ra Khalifatul Masih II First Published in UK in 2009 © Islam International Publications Ltd Published by Islam International Publications Ltd Islamabad Sheephatch Lane Tilford, Surrey United Kingdom GU10 2AQ Printed in UK at Raqeem Press Tilford, Surrey ISBN: 1 85372 620 6

Page 3

About the Author The Promised son ra of the Promised Messiah as and Mahdi as ; the manifest Sign of Allah, the Almighty; the Word of God whose advent was prophesied by the Holy Prophet Muhammad sa and the Promised Messiah as as well as the past Prophets; a Star in the spiritual firmament for the like of which the world has to wait for hundreds of years to appear; the man of God, crowned with a spiritual halo from which radiated such scintillating rays of light as would instil spiritual life into his followers and captivate and enthral those who were not fortunate to follow him; an orator of such phenomenal quality that his speeches would make his audience stay put for hours on end, come rain or shine, deep into the late hours of the evenings while words flowed from his tongue like honey dripping into their ears to reach the depths of their soul to fill them with knowledge and invigorate their faith; the ocean of Divine and secular knowledge; the Voice Articulate of the age; without doubt the greatest genius of the 20 th century; a man of phenomenal intelligence and memory; an epitome of the qualities of leadership; the one whose versatility cannot be comprehended— Hadrat Mirza Bashiruddin Mahmood Ahmad ra (1889-1965), Mu s le h Ma‘ u d (the Promised Reformer) was the eldest son and the second successor (Khalifah) of the Promised Messiah as.He took charge of the Ahmadiyya Jam a ‘at at the young age of 24 when the Jam a ‘at was still in its infancy and nourished it to its maturity for more than 50 years with his spiritual guidance, prayers, tears, toil and blood.Not only did he fortify the foundations of the community laid down by the Promised Messiah as , but expanded the structure of the Jam a ‘at by initiating various

Page 4

schemes, organizations, and programmes taking his inspiration from the Promised Messiah as and under the Divine guidance.His foremost concern, to which he devoted all his life, was to accomplish the mission of the Promised Messiah as —the daunting task of spreading the message of true Islam in its pristine purity to the ends of the world.To achieve this, he initiated Ta h r i k-e-Jad i d through which spread, and continues to spread, the missionary work all over the globe.His acute intelligence, keen intellect, deep and extensive scholarship and above all his God-given knowledge enabled him to produce a vast corpus of writings, speeches etc.His oeuvre is so vast that it will take many years to see the light of publication.When the Promised Messiah as fervently prayed to God to grant him a Sign in support of Islam, Allah gave him the good tiding about this son of his and said: “…He will be extremely intelligent … and will be filled with secular and spiritual knowledge … Son, delight of the heart, high ranking, noble; a manifestation of the First and the Last, of the True and the High; as if Allah has descended from heaven.Behold a light cometh.We shall pour our spirit into him…” [Revelation of 20 th February 1886] * * Translation from Urdu by Sir Muhammad Zafrullah Khan in his English translation of Tadhkirah —the book containing dreams, visions and verbal revelations vouchsafed to the Promised Messiah as.The book containing dreams, visions and verbal revelations vouchsafed to the Promised Messiah as.[Publisher]

Page 5

V CONTENTS About the Author.........................................................III Publishers’ Note...........................................................XI Foreword...................................................................XIV Need to Expound Various Aspects of Khilafat................1 Attempt by Opponents of the Jam a ‘at to Find Fault with Khilafat....................................................2 Paramount Importance of the Issue of Khilafat in Islam.........................................................................2 Need to Link Organization of Muslim Ummah with Some Religious Precept.....................................3 A Pertinent Question.....................................................5 Existence of Politics without Government.....................6 An Objection on Religious Khilafat................................7 Combination of Organizations of State and Religion in Early Period of Islam................................7 Does Organization Developed by the Holy Prophet sa Have Religious Sanctity or Not?.................9 A Dangerous Outcome of the Denial of Khilafat..........12 Two Types of Religion..................................................13 Real Reason why sharia is called a Curse in Christianity.............................................................14 Involvement of Judaism in the Institution of Government............................................................18 What Kind of Religion Islam is?...................................19 Comprehensive Guidance of Islam about all Institutions of Government.....................................23 Detailed Instructions for Implementation of Law.........24 The Holy Prophet’s sa System of Government................30 Commandment to Expel Infidels from Arabia..............33 Essential Features of Government..............................36 Were Commands Related to Establishment of an Organization only for the Prophet sa ?........................38 Intense Love of Followers with their Prophet...............40 Issue of Consent upon Reaching Puberty....................42 Islam Ordains a National and Legal Organization.......43 Reasons for Mutiny of Arabian Tribes.........................45

Page 6

VI The Details of Issue of Khilafat....................................46 A Personal Experience................................................47 Condition of Companions ra on the Death of the Holy Prophet sa.........................................................49 No Consideration on Succession of a Prophet in his Lifetime.............................................................52 Every Prophet has Two Lives (I) Personal, (II) National..................................................................54 Prophet’s Personal Life is First Manifestation of Divine Power and his National Life is Second..........54 A Look in the Dispute of “ Qir ta s ” [Folio]......................55 Allah, the Almighty Starts National Life of a Prophet with Revelation..........................................58 Three Groups of Companions ra after the Demise of the Holy Prophet sa...............................................59 Dispute between Muh a jir i n and An sa r.........................60 Election of Hadrat Abu Bakr ra.....................................63 Election of Hadrat Umar ra...........................................65 Election of Hadrat Usman ra.........................................66 Election of Hadrat Ali ra................................................68 Declaration of Jihad by Hadrat Ayeshah ra...................69 Battle of S af i n.............................................................70 The Doctrine of Unelected Khilafat of Hadrat Ali ra.......73 Three Groups of Muslims in Reference to Khilafat.......74 Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya.................................................75 The Authority of the Khalifah......................................78 Some Questions Presented by M i r Muhammad Is ha q Sahib ra to Hadrat Khal i fatul Mas i h I ra............78 A Dream.....................................................................79 Assembly of Representatives of Outside Jam a ‘ats in Qadian................................................................81 Address of Hadrat Khal i fatul Mas i h I ra on the Issue of Khilafat......................................................82 Renewal of the Bai‘at of Khawaja Kamaluddin and Maulaw i Muhammad Ali..................................83 Proposal to Publish an Announcement during Illness of Hadrat Khal i fatul Mas i h I ra...........................................85 Attempt to Save the Jam a ‘at from Disunity.................87 Demise of Hadrat Khal i fatul Mas i h I ra.........................87

Page 7

VII Request for Prayers.....................................................88 Unanimous Decision of the Family of the Promised Messiah as.................................................88 My Meeting with Maulaw i Muhammad Ali...................89 A Tract of Maulaw i Muhammad Ali.............................90 The Consent of Ninety Percent of the Members of the Jam a ‘at on Khilafat by Election.........................91 Second Round of Discussions with Maulaw i Muhammad Ali.......................................................92 Establishment of the Second Khilafat.........................93 Real Meaning of Some Sayings of Hadrat Khal i fatul Mas i h I ra.................................................93 Quranic Injunctions about Khilafat.............................95 An Unfair Objection of Enemies of Islam on the phrase “Pure Spouses”..........................................101 Cooperation of Man and Woman is imperative for the creation of Paradise of this World and of the Hereafter.........................................................102 A Magnificent Point...................................................103 Explanation of Hadith that “Paradise is Under the Feet of Mothers”....................................................106 The Command to Entrust the Trusts to the Deserving..............................................................107 Quranic Principles of Islamic Organization...............111 Does Islam Acknowledge a Certain Type of Pure Worldly Government?............................................112 Interpretation of Purely Worldly Organization...........113 A Regrettable Mistake of Muslims.............................114 Second Mistake.........................................................115 Establishment of Purely Religious Organization when Differences Prevent Setting up an All- encompassing System...........................................116 Clarification of an Objection on “Authorities among You ”...........................................................119 Interpretation of “Refer to Allah and His Messenger in situations of Disagreement with Authority among You”...........................................120

Page 8

VIII The Verse “ Those who are in authority among You” is Applicable to Both the Worldly Authorities and Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n.....................123 Separate Commands for the Two Types of Authorities............................................................124 The Command to Follow Always Sunnah of Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n..............................................127 Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n are a Model for the Ummah.......129 Discussion of A yat-e-Istikhl a f...................................131 Performance of Prayer, in its True Sense, is not Possible without Khilafat.......................................132 True Obedience to the Messenger is also not Possible without Khilafat.......................................136 Summary of the Subject Matter of A yat-e-Istikhl a f....138 Signs of True Khulaf a ’...............................................140 Earlier Khilafats were either Khilafats of Prophethood or Khilafats of Kingship....................144 Why has the Resemblance been Ascribed to Khilafat of Prophethood and Not the Khilafat of Kingship?..............................................................146 Promise of Khilafat Conditional upon Faith and Acts of Goodness...................................................148 Loss of Khilafat is Due to the Shortcoming of a Jam a ‘at, not because of a Shortcoming in the Khalifah................................................................150 Sign of the Establishment of Religion........................151 Transforming Fear into Security...............................154 Hadrat Umar ra was not Afraid of his Martyrdom.......156 Hadrat Usman ra also did not Feel any Fear...............157 Martyrdom of Hadrat Ali ra.........................................160 Allah, the Almighty Safeguards His Khulaf a ’ from Ordinary Fears......................................................161 A Vision of the Holy Prophet sa Fulfilled after His Death....................................................................162 After the Deaths of Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n their Fear Continued to be Transformed into Security...........163 The Awe of Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n on Non-Muslim Kings....................................................................164

Page 9

IX True Khulaf a ’ are the Standard Bearers of Real Unity.....................................................................165 An Incident of Maulaw i Ghulam Ali...........................167 A Story of a Sunni Elder...........................................168 Resoluteness of Hadrat Abu Bakr ra during the Apostasy...............................................................169 Bold Acts of Hadrat Umar ra.......................................173 Spitting of Hadrat Abu Hurairah ra in the Scarf of Iranian King..........................................................174 Bold Defences by Hadrat Usman ra and Hadrat Ali ra.......................................................................175 Objections generally made on A yat-e-Istikhl a f...........176 Reply to the Question that the Promise is Made with the Muslim ummah, and not with Some Individuals............................................................179 An Incident of a Dissentient......................................182 The Effect of Protest against Afghanistan..................187 Khilafat is established through an Electoral Process in Which the Whole Community is Involved................................................................188 Why did Hadrat Abu Bakr ra Nominate Hadrat Umar ra ?.................................................................189 Can the Appointment of Yazid as Khalifah by Hadrat Muawiyah ra be Called Election?.................189 It is against the Sunnah of Companions ra that a Father Should propose His Son for Khilafat..........191 Surrender of Throne by a Son of Yazid......................192 Commentary of the Promised Messiah as on A yat-e- Istikhl a f................................................................194 Inference of Khilafat-e-Muhammadiyya.....................195 Evidence from the Way of Allah, the Almighty...........196 Resemblance of the Four Khulaf a ’ with the Previous Ones is not Necessary in Every Matter....197 “The Ulema of my Ummah are like the Prophets of Ban i Isr a ’ i l’ Refers only to the Spiritual Khulaf a ”................................................................202 Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya...............................................204 A yat-e-Istikhl a f Applies to Both the Nubuwwat and Khilafat of the Promised Messiah as.................208

Page 10

X No Connection of the Khulaf a ’ of ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) with the Management of the Country........209 Another Objection of the Opponents and Its Response..............................................................212 The Khilafat of Previous Prophets—Both in the form of Prophethood and Kingship—was Imperfect..............................................................213 Is Promise of Khilafat limited to the Khalifah immediately succeeding the Prophet.....................216 Is it lawful to Remove a Khalifah?.............................220 A Point to Ponder......................................................222 Another Verse in Favour of Khilafat-e-R a shidah.......224 A Command of the Holy Prophet sa Related to Khilafat.................................................................233 A Grave Objection on the Rights of Khulaf a ’..............233 Crookedness only means Open Infidelity...................235 Could Hadrat Abu Bakr ra Commit Open Infidelity.....236 Some Precedents of the Holy Quran..........................237 An Event in the Life of the Promised Messiah as.........238 Verse of Succession and the Second Khilafat............242 A Wonderful Manifestation of Allah, the Almighty.....250 The Fulfillment of the Revelation “I Shall Break Them in Pieces” Related to Dissentients................251 Total Trust in Allah, the Almighty.............................252 A Dream about the Mischief of Mistries.....................253 Always Remain Engaged in Prayers for the Descending of Second Manifestation of Divine Power....................................................................256 Index........................................................................259

Page 11

XI Publishers’ Note The name of Muhammad sa , the Holy Prophet of Islam, has been followed by the symbol sa , which is an abbreviation for the salutation ( ) S allall a hu ‘Alaihi Wasallam (may peace and blessings of Allah be upon him).The names of other Prophets and Messengers are followed by the symbol as , an abbreviation for ( / ) ‘ Alaihissal a m/ ‘ Alaihimussal a m (on whom be peace).The actual salutations have not generally been set out in full, but they should nevertheless, be understood as being repeated in full in each case.The symbol ra is used with the name of the Companions of the Holy Prophet sa and those of the Promised Messiah as.It stands for ( / / ) Ra di All a hu ‘anhu/‘anh a /‘anhum (May Allah be pleased with him/with her/with them).rh stands for ( ) Ra h imahull a hu Ta‘ a l a (may Allah’s blessing be on him).at stands for ( ) Ayyadahull a hu Ta‘ a l a (May Allah, the Al-Mighty help him).In transliterating Arabic words we have followed the following system adopted by the Royal Asiatic Society.at the beginning of a word, pronounced as a , i , u preceded by a very slight aspiration, like h in the English word 'honour'.th , pronounced like th in the English word 'thing'.h , a guttural aspirate, stronger than h.kh , pronounced like the Scotch ch in 'loch'.

Page 12

XII dh , pronounced like the English th in 'that'.s , strongly articulated s.d , similar to the English th in 'this'.t , strongly articulated palatal t.z , strongly articulated z.‘, a strong guttural, the pronunciation of which must be learnt by the ear.gh , a sound approached very nearly in the r ' grasseye ' in French, and in the German r.It requires the muscles of the throat to be in the 'gargling' position whilst pronouncing it.q , a deep guttural k sound.’, a sort of catch in the voice.Short vowels are represented by: a for (like u in 'bud'); i for (like i in 'bid'); u for (like oo in 'wood'); Long vowels by: a for or (like a in 'father'); i for ی or (like ee in 'deep'); u for و (like oo in 'root'); Other: ai for ی (like i in 'site') ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ; au for و (resembling ou in 'sound').♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ In Arabic words like (Shaikh) there is an element of diphthong which is missing when the word is pronounced in Urdu.

Page 13

XIII Please note that in transliterated words the letter 'e' is to be pronounced as in 'prey' which rhymes with 'day'; however the pronunciation is flat without the element of English diphthong.If in Urdu and Persian words 'e' is lengthened a bit more it is transliterated as 'ei' to be pronounced as 'ei' in 'feign' without the element of diphthong thus ' ' is transliterated as 'Kei'.For the nasal sound of 'n' we have used the symbol ' ń '.Thus Urdu word ' ' is transliterated as 'mei ń '.* The consonants not included in the above list have the same phonetic value as in the principal languages of Europe.We have not transliterated Arabic words which have become part of English language, e.g., Islam, Mahdi, Quran ** , Hijra, Ramadan, Hadith, ulama, ummah, sunnah, kafir, pukka etc.For quotes straight commas (straight quotes) are used to differentiate them from the curved commas used in the system of transliteration, ‘ for , ’ for.Commas as punctuation marks are used according to the normal usage.Similarly for apostrophe normal usage is followed.Publishers * These transliterations are not included in the system of transliteration by Royal Asiatic Society.[Publishers] ** Concise Oxford Dictionary records Quran in three forms— Quran, Quran and Koran.[Publishers]

Page 14

XIV Foreword Al h amdulill a h [All praise belongs to Allah] that Allah, the Almighty has enabled us to prepare an English rendering of the speech entitled Khilafat-e- R a shidah by Hadrat Mirza Bashiruddin Mahmood Ahmad ra , Khal i fautl Mas ih II.The paramount importance of the issue of Khilafat in Islam drew our attention to present the English rendering of the book on the blessed and august occasion of Centenary Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya (1908- 2008) being celebrated the world over.The speech, Khilafat-e-R a shidah , was made in Urdu during Jalsa S a l a nah on December 28, 29, 1939 when the Jam a ‘at was celebrating 25 th Anniversary of the Khilafat of Hadrat Mu s le h Ma‘ u d.Its Urdu edition was first published by Al-Shirkatul Islamiyyah in 1961 and has now been included in Anw a rul ‘Ul u m Vol.15.Khilafat-e-R a shidah , an exquisite exposition of the fundamental issue of Khilafat in Islam against the backdrop of Islamic history and doctrines, removes many misunderstandings and misconceptions of its readers.Among numerous related issues the reader will find: • In-depth review of the history of the four Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n after the Holy Prophet sa , and a detailed exposition of how the Divine promise in A yat-e-Istikhl a f, in all its aspects, was fulfilled through them;

Page 15

XV • A detailed discussion of A yat-e-Istikhl a f (Al-N u r, 24:56) of the Holy Quran and the A ha d i th of the Holy Prophet sa which contain the everlasting promise of Khilafat with those believers who act righteously.• Elaborate discussion of the writings of the Promised Messiah as , and the glad tidings granted to him about the establishment of Khilafat in his Jam a ‘at after his demise.• Detailed account, based on personal knowledge, of the circumstances during the Khilafat of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra , when some people started raising issues relating to Khilafat and the effective and firm handling of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra of the dissention; • An inside story of his own election as the second Khalifah and his valiant efforts to preserve the unity of the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jam a ‘at irrespective of who would be elected.Mirza Anas Ahmad MA M Lit.(Oxen) Wakilul-Ish a ‘at Ta h r i k-e-Jad i d, Rabwah.June 2009

Page 16

Page 17

1 1 After Tashahhud , Ta‘awwudh and recitation of s u rah Al-F a ti h ah, H u du r said: Need to Expound Various Aspects of Khilafat I generally deliver a scholarly speech on every Jalsa S a l a nah [Annual Convention].Accordingly, I want to express my views on an important topic today.As this Jalsa is special because of its relationship with Khilafat Jubilee, and the various presentations being made are also related to the issue of Khilafat, I deem it appropriate that my speech should also focus primarily on various aspects of Khilafat.Some people might be annoyed that every speaker addresses the same topic of Khilafat, but the significance of this subject and the requisites of this Jalsa S a l a nah demand that all details of this issue be explained cogently.It is a part of human nature that it benefits from consuming different varieties of food, but sometimes one has to take the same thing repeatedly.The Holy Prophet sa said concerning the Eids, “These are our days to eat and drink” 2 ; especially in the days of Eid ul-Adha , there is nothing 1 In the name of Allah, the Gracious, the Merciful.We praise Him and invoke blessings upon His Noble Messenger sa.(Publishers) 2 Bukh a r i , Kit a b-ul-A dah i, B a bo m a Yu’kalu min Lu hu mil A dahi … , by Muhammad bin Ism a ’ i l Abu Abdullah Al-Bukh a r i Al-Ju‘f i , publisher, D a r ibni Kath i r Al-Yam a mah, Beirut.

Page 18

2 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH to eat but meat.Similarly, in the days of Hajj, a large number of animals are slaughtered and as much meat as can be eaten is consumed, the rest being thrown away.Likewise, it is sometimes necessary to explain the same topic in different ways.Attempt by Opponents of the Jam a ‘at to Find Fault with Khilafat Among the schemes contrived by the opponents of our Community, and the steps taken by them to damage the honour of Ahmadiyyat, one is their constant attempt to find fault with Khilafat.They seek to awaken Satan within the heart of anyone who is prone to it.Because of this, I have decided this time to express my views about Khilafat, so that those who can benefit from it should derive benefit, and those who hold faith dear to their hearts may derive blessings and guidance from it.Paramount Importance of the Issue of Khilafat in Islam I consider Khilafat as one of the most important issues in Islam.Indeed, I believe that a commentary on the Kalimah should give a predominant position to this issue.There is no doubt that the Kalimah T ayyibah is the foundation of Islam.However, among the details implied in the Kalimah, and matters towards which it directs our attention, the greatest is Khilafat.Therefore, I have decided to put forth my

Page 19

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 3 perspective in detail before the Jam a ‘at so that it may provide a decisive argument to the enemies, and that we may witness a fulfilment of the verse: (Al-Anf a l 8:43) “He who is prone to being vanquished through a clear sign may be offered a manifest argument, and he whose faith is based on true understanding may refresh his faith.” Need to Link Organization of Muslim Ummah with Some Religious Precept I will first address a question that is often raised under the influence of western education.It is the fundamental question of this issue.The question raised is that an organization is, after all, a worldly matter, and since an organization is worldly, not religious, why should the organization of the Muslim ummah be linked with some religious precept? It is a political matter and has nothing to do with religion, why should it be examined from a religious perspective? Allah, the Almighty has revealed His religion and we have embraced it; now He has no right to interfere in the type of organization we adopt.Muslims should be free to choose an appropriate organization in every age.If they deem it appropriate, they may agree upon a sovereign kingdom, or they may wish to choose democracy, Bolshevik rule, or a

Page 20

4 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH constitutional monarchy.There is no need, or benefit, of adopting any specific system in the name of religion.The real object is to spread the faith.Why should we be overly concerned with the organizational system under which this work is done? In the present age, the newly educated and westernized youth have engaged in this debate.In fact, the misguided notion of freedom, which has developed among the Muslims of today under the influence of various philosophies, is lurking behind this issue.They raise this issue repeatedly and insist that this situation defames religion and turns the newly educated class away from religion.They conclude that it is better to keep both religion and politics separate and in their respective places.Under the influence of the West, the underlying current of these thoughts had long been in motion, but no Muslim had the courage to discuss them openly.When the Turkish Khilafat was destroyed, and Kemal Ataturk abolished the institution of Khilafat in Turkey, a commotion erupted in the entire Muslim world.Orthodox Muslims started forming Khilafat Committees.Many Khilafat Committees were also established in India, and people declared that they would fight this outrage [of absolution of Khilafat].When people, who already had misgivings about the matter, witnessed that a victorious and honoured king supported their views by his actions, they became bolder in declaring their ideas and even wrote

Page 21

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 5 booklets.Such booklets were written by Muslims, Europeans, and also Russians.However, an Egyptian scholar, Ali bin Abdur Razzaq , who is one of the scholars of Jamia Azhar and is a Justice of The Religious Court, presented this perspective cogently in his book Al-Isl a mo wa U su l-ul- H akam.The prime instigator of this trend, as I have already mentioned, was the profound unrest in the Islamic world in general, and Arabian countries in particular, caused by the abolition of Khilafat in Turkey.A Pertinent Question It might be asked: How is this discussion related to Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya, which should be the real crux of my discussion? The Khilafat discussed in this book is monarchic, whereas the Khilafat of the Ahmadiyya Jam a‘ at is spiritual.The Turks are kings and Ahmadis are not.Therefore, the arguments in favour of, and against, the Turkish Khilafat should be of a different category.After all, what possible relationship can this Khilafat have with Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya, which has no kingdom and is only spiritual in nature? The answer is that it is not necessary to confine oneself to those aspects of an issue which are raised specifically.At times, it is necessary to deal with all aspects of an issue comprehensively.For instance, when someone asks how hands are to be washed in ablution, there is no harm in describing all the steps of ablution to him.In this way, he will be able to

Page 22

6 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH understand related details as well.Similarly, though the Ahmadiyya Khilafat is a spiritual Khilafat, yet, there is no harm in discussing monarchic Khilafat.Indeed, it is essential to make the discussion comprehensive.Existence of Politics without Government The second point is that politics is, in fact, another name of an organization; it exists with or without government.It is a mistake to link politics exclusively with government, for politics can exist without government.In the same way, an organization can also be established without a government.For instance, the Holy Prophet sa said that when three people go on a journey, they should appoint one among themselves as their leader 3 , so that he can lead S al a t and direct consultations for addressing problems arising during the journey.This is a kind of organization which is not linked with government.An organization is, in fact, a permanent entity which directs the affairs of people and also of government, if the government is involved.Thus, the issue of Khilafat deals with the Islamic organization, whether it involves government or not.3 Sunan Ab u D a w u d, Kit a b-ul-Jih a d, B a bo Filqaumi Yus a fir u na Yu’mmir u na ahada hum , Hadith No.2610, by Ab u D a w u d Suleman bin Al- Ash’ath As-Sajist a ni, publisher D a rul Kit a b Al-Arabi, Beirut.

Page 23

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 7 An Objection on Religious Khilafat The third point is that if anyone were to prove that Islam has not presented any specific organization, it would not only affect monarchic Khilafat, but also the one presented by us.Thus, the monarchic Khilafat and the purely spiritual organization would both come under fire.All arguments presented against the Turkish Khilafat also affect Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya.Therefore, it is necessary that we should discuss these arguments in detail, for if Islam has not presented a specific organization, then Muslims would have free rein to choose not only the type of organization of state, but also that of religion.It would further grant them the unrestricted freedom to choose their own organization in any age and in any country.Combination of Organizations of State and Religion in Early Period of Islam This question acquires greater importance when we find that the organizations of state and religion were combined in the early period of Islam.Along with a religious organization in effect, there was also a standing army and justices as well.They administered penal laws, collected ransom, distributed stipends, and appointed people to offices.Similarly, they had institutionalized S al a t , Fasting, Hajj, and payment of Zakat.Thus, in early Islam, both types of organizations were combined.If it were argued that this does not ordain any specific organization, then the

Page 24

8 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH establishment of spiritual Khilafat would also have to be considered an interim arrangement made by the Muslims of that time, it would not be an authority for establishing spiritual Khilafat in the future.If the institution of Khilafat were not proven to have existed from the beginning, its establishment in the later era would not be a valid issue.Thus, if the issue of Khilafat were to be affected in any way, not only would people declare the Turkish Khilafat unlawful, but also they would deny Khilafat altogether.As a result, we, who believe in Khilafat, would not escape its effects.For example, if an objection is raised against Hindus and Christians which can also apply to Islam, then, it cannot be said that it only affects Hindus and Christian, and not Muslims.If the same objection can also be made against Islam, it would be our duty to resolve it, for if it were to cause people to turn away from religion, Islam would also be affected.The fourth point is that we cite the precedent of Khilafat-e-R a shidah of the Holy Prophet sa to prove the truthfulness of Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya.We declare that just as Hadrat Abu Bakr ra , Hadrat Umar ra , Hadrat Usman ra , and Hadrat Ali ra became Khulaf a ’ after the Holy Prophet sa , likewise there should be Khilafat after the Promised Messiah as as well.If the first Khilafat were to lose its validity, Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya would also become invalid.

Page 25

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 9 Does Organization Developed by the Holy Prophet sa Have Religious Sanctity or Not? It should also be kept in mind that if the belief of Ali bin Abdur Razzaq, which is also that of those who moved away from Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya, were to be taken as valid, then it would raise the question: were the measures taken by the Holy Prophet sa for the development of an organization religious or not? If we were to declare that Islam does not present any specific type of organization, and that the Khilafat of Hadrat Abu Bakr ra , Hadrat Umar ra , Hadrat Usman ra and Hadrat Ali ra were interim arrangements of the Muslims, and that whatever they did for the stability of the organization of the state was only done following in the footsteps of the Holy Prophet sa , then the question would naturally arise: Were the steps taken by the Holy Prophet sa for the establishment of a state and organization only provisional measures, or did they bear the support of religious authority? If they were temporary, then whatever was done by Hadrat Abu Bakr ra , Hadrat Umar ra , Hadrat Usman ra , and Hadrat Ali ra in his obedience would also be provisional and would not be an authority of sharia for us.On the other hand, if the steps taken by the Holy Prophet sa related to the government and the organization were religious, then we will have to adopt them as our guideline.Thus, this issue is not confined to the Khulaf a ’ but it also affects the Holy Prophet sa.If the institution of Khilafat is not based on

Page 26

10 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH a basic religious principle and is only done to follow the actions of the Holy Prophet sa , then it would be concluded that the actions of the Holy Prophet sa related to the establishment of an organization are not religious and do not need to be followed.Just as in the matter of food and clothing no one says that we should follow the Holy Prophet sa literally.For instance, no one says that the Holy Prophet sa wore a loincloth so others should also wear it, or that the Holy Prophet sa used to eat dates so we should also eat the same.Only a general principal is deduced from these practices that we should live a simple life.Similarly, if the steps taken by the Holy Prophet sa , which are concerned with the establishment of an organization, are not considered religious but are called provisional measures, then they would not be an authority for us to follow.At the most, we would be able to assert that with the fall of the rival Arabian empire, all of Arabia came under his command, so, he was compelled to establish a kind of organization.Since laws and regulations were required for the establishment of an organization, he made some as well.His only purpose was to improve the condition of people and not to establish an organization bearing religious authority for all time.In short, by accepting this doctrine, we would also have to accept that the measures taken by the Holy Prophet sa related to the establishment of an organization carry no religious significance, and that

Page 27

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 11 they were simply done to meet the need of the time.Had they borne religious authority, they would have been a sunnah binding on later generations.This is the natural conclusion which results from this doctrine.Those who turned away from Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya have always tried to hide this natural conclusion from people for fear that if they declare that the part of the life of the Holy Prophet sa concerned with management of the affairs of the state was only a worldly matter to meet provisional needs of the time, the Muslims would not tolerate it, considering it a defamation of the Holy Prophet sa.Therefore, they have always taken a very irrational approach to this subject.However, Ali bin Abdur Razzaq, one of the scholars of Jamia Al–Azher, has discussed this issue openly and boldly, and has reached the logical conclusion that I just mentioned.It is, therefore, an interesting coincidence that when I started collecting notes on this topic, it crossed my mind that if this argument were stretched to its limits, it would also affect the Holy Prophet sa.One would have to admit that this part of his life was merely a worldly matter which was adopted to meet the needs of that time.I reached that conclusion initially; later, when I read his book, I noticed that he drew exactly the same inference that I drew, though he, being afraid of Muslims, avoided discussing it in detail.He tried to present his perspective like sugar- coated poison.Nevertheless, the crux of his reasoning becomes very clear when he points out that the

Page 28

12 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH institutions of justice, and other requisites of government like budgeting, were not present at that time, which shows that whatever the Holy Prophet sa did was to meet the immediate needs of the time.A Dangerous Outcome of the Denial of Khilafat The fact is that with the denial of Khilafat, one would have to admit that the government of Hadrat Muhammad sa was not religious either.No matter how gently this idea is presented out of fear of opposition from Muslims, the fact is that it not only denies the religious status of the rule of the Khulaf a ’, but it also contends that the part of the life of the Holy Prophet sa which dealt with the management of the affairs of state was only worldly, undertaken to fulfil the needs of that time.It would be concluded that, with the exception of S al a t , Fasting, Hajj, and Zakat, organizational matters are left to the discretion of the people, and they are given full liberty by the Holy Prophet sa to follow the organization of their own choice.Ali bin Abdur Razzaq has discussed this subject also, and he says that: If the Holy Prophet sa had been running a government in the true sense of the word, he would have appointed judges everywhere and would have approved budgets on a regular basis.This is not found in his life.In this way, he tries to prove that the involvement of the

Page 29

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 13 Holy Prophet sa in management of the affairs of the state was only provisional.Just as when there is no chair in a house, one sits on the floor, in the same way, he made some laws to establish a temporary organization; this was a worldly matter and cannot be taken as a religious sanction.In short, by accepting this principle, not only is the organization of state established by the Khulaf a ’ stripped of religious status, but the measures taken by the Holy Prophet sa in this regard have to be declared worldly as well.One would have to admit that they were not a part of sunnah to be followed by the people of later generations.After these introductory comments, I will now discuss the fundamental issues of Khilafat and the Islamic organization.Two Types of Religion To fully comprehend this matter, it is necessary to understand that there are two types of religion in the world.First, those which confine their jurisdiction to certain types of prayers and doctrines, and treat worldly matters as separate.They do not interfere in worldly affairs, though they provide guidance on how to perform S al a t , keep fast, give charity, or carry out obligations due to other people.In short, they give commands for worship and remembrance of Allah, but they do not give guidelines for such affairs as the

Page 30

14 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH development of an organization, economy, international affairs, trade, or inheritance.Real Reason why sharia is called a Curse in Christianity Christianity is one such religion.It emphatically alleges that the sharia is a curse, primarily, because they seek to set apart the personal behaviour of people from the checks and restraints of religion.For them, the only purpose of religion is to direct people to say S al a t , observe fast, perform Hajj, pay Zakat, and accept Christ as God.They believe that the sharia has no authority to impose laws concerning murder, riots, thefts and organized robbery; nor to lay down guidelines on how nations should enter into treaties with one another, or control the economy.They argue, concerning the rights of men and women to inheritance, that the sharia again has nothing to do with it; rather, it is the duty of the parliament of a country to promulgate such laws as are in the interest of the nation.Similarly, they assert that if the government has decided to institute interest, whether in the shape of currency or goods, religion cannot declare that such money is unlawful.In short, they detest such commands of religion as are related to the organization, and thus, they declare the sharia to be a curse.This does not imply that fasting is a curse.Had it been a curse, it would not have been written in older editions of the Bible:

Page 31

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 15 “But the only way to force out that kind of demon is by praying and fasting.” 4 Is it possible that in the presence of such texts in the Gospels, the sharia be called a curse? The fact is that when the Christians declare the sharia to be a curse, they really mean that the authority of religion over the organization of a country is a curse.To them, religion has no control over affairs of the world; rather, a country can itself come up with rules and regulations of its own choice.Thus, they did away with restrictions imposed by the Mosaic sharia related to affairs of the state.No doubt, when ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) uttered these words (assuming that he did indeed say so), he did not mean what they attribute to him.On the contrary, he meant that the Jews gave greater importance to injunctions than to the inner self and spirituality, and this became a curse for them and pushed them far away from truth.When Christianity spread in Rome, people were not willing to relinquish their national constitution.They considered Roman law superior to every other law, in fact, European governments still benefit from Roman law.Therefore, the people of that time, who were very enlightened and possessed remarkable legal acumen, presumed that no one else could frame a better law than those.They acknowledged the goodness in the teachings of Christianity related to the 4 Matthew 17:21.North India Bible Society Mirza Pur, 1870.

Page 32

16 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH love of God Almighty, miracles, Divine signs, prayers, and the sacrifices made by Christ.When they studied the teachings of Christianity, their hearts inclined towards it, and they admitted that this religion was worth accepting.At the same time, they could not bear that Judaic law, which they deemed inferior to Roman law, be enforced among them.Thus, they found themselves in utter dilemma.On the one hand, they were attracted by the alluring teachings of Christianity, but on the other hand, their superiority complex concerning Roman law prevented them from bowing before Judaic law.In this state of confusion, they came across these lines in The New Testament: “Anyone who tries to please God by obeying the Law is under a curse.” 5 “But Christ rescued us from the Law’s curse, when he became a curse in our place.” 6 These are not the words of Jesus, but are of Paul.Nevertheless, the Romans found an excuse, and by extending the implication of these sentences, they decided that religion had no authority to issue commands concerning affairs of the world, and that every nation could frame its own laws according to the requirements of these affairs.5 Galatians 3:10, British and Foreign Bible Society Lahore, 1922.6 Galatians 3:13, British and Foreign Bible Society Lahore, 1922.

Page 33

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 17 ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) (if these are his words) and his disciples only meant that the Jews placed excessive emphasis on the letter of the Law and completely ignored righteousness.This became the cause of their being accursed.They did not observe prayers except in name, and their hearts did not turn towards God Almighty with love and fear, so this type of prayer became a curse for them.They slaughtered animals for alms and charity, but they never slaughtered their ego, so this charity and sacrifice also became a curse for them.In their acts of worship, they apparently bowed their heads down before God Almighty, but their hearts never bowed before Him, so their worship also became a curse for them.They, no doubt, spent in charity and abandoned their wealth for sacrifice before God Almighty, but they were not ready to abandon their false ideas, so Zakat also became a curse for them.In short, the Jews laid greater emphasis on pretence and ignored inner purification; therefore, ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) or his disciples had to point out that following the injunctions of the sharia in name without purifying the inner self is a curse.It did not mean that the sharia was a curse; rather, it meant that their ostentation and disregard for inner purification had become a curse for them.Nevertheless, the Romans found an excuse, and they misinterpreted these verses to mean that religion should be followed only in matters of prayer and fasting, but not in worldly matters, for religion has no

Page 34

18 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH authority over these matters.It is up to people to draft the law of their choice.The Romans, who called Christianity and the sharia a curse, forced people to abide by the laws which they drafted themselves.If the mere presence of a law had been a curse, they would not have enacted any law.They declared religion a curse on one hand and enacted various laws for their use on the other.This shows that according to them, the meaning of this verse was that only people had the right to make laws of their choice; religion had no right to present commandments dealing with temporal affairs.In this way, they freed themselves of those restrictions which were imposed by the Mosaic sharia related to affairs of the state.Involvement of Judaism in the Institution of Government The second type of religions are those which have broadened their jurisdiction and made rules and regulations for all spheres of life, including human activities, mutual relations, institutions of government, etc.The followers of these faiths must accept the authority of religion in the affairs of government.Individuals and societies must abide by these injunctions as obligatorily, just as they accept doctrines and commandments like prayers and fasting that affect personal life.Judaism is a good example of this type.If one studies Mosaic sharia, one will find all types of injunctions including, but not limited to,

Page 35

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 19 punishments prescribed for murder and theft, rules and regulations to be observed in war, principles governing sacrifice and also guidelines for transactions and trade.Thus, Judaism deals with matters related to government.Therefore, whoever studies the Mosaic sharia will conclude that religion has authority not only over individual matters, but also over the affairs of the nation and state.What Kind of Religion Islam is? Now we must determine what type of religion Islam is: does it belong to the first category or the second? For this purpose, we must see whether Islam has exerted authority over national matters or not.If Hadrat Muhammad sa dealt with national affairs out of his own desire or because of the dire needs of the nation, then it will have to be admitted that his actions are not binding on us.Just as when someone finds a stray child in a jungle and brings him in his home out of pity, it does not mean that he has the right of guardianship over him.Similarly, Hadrat Muhammad sa adopted orphans of Arabia out of feelings of pity for them, but this did not confer upon him the right of guardianship over them.Rather, when they came of age, they had the right to adopt a law of their own choice.On the contrary, if Islamic sharia does indeed include injunctions, then it will have to be admitted that the Holy Prophet sa did not interfere in these matters out of his own desire, rather, he did so

Page 36

20 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH when God Almighty commanded him.If this is proven, then it will in turn prove that the part of his life spent in the management of the affairs of state is religious in nature.The Muslims, who are bound by Islamic directives in a purely religious organization, are also not free in the matter of the organization of state, and are under obligation to submit to the organization of the state established by Islamic sharia.Even one glance at the Holy Quran and sayings of the Holy Prophet sa shows manifestly that Islam is not among the religions of the first category mentioned above but is of the second category.Islam issued commandments not only for certain beliefs and individual behaviour, but also for government and law.Therefore, it not only asks its followers to observe S al a t , keep Fast, perform Hajj, and pay Zakat, but it also gives precepts related to government and law.It discusses the relationship between husband and wife, and makes clear what should be done and what measures should be taken towards mutual reconciliation in case of a dispute; if a man ever has to punish his wife physically, Islam gives directives on how much and what sort of punishment should be given.Similarly, it elaborates the principles of transactions, prescribes the number of witnesses in case of debt, and discusses the illegality of certain types of debt.It also mentions the principles of business and finance, and defines the laws governing testimonies upon which the organization of Qa da

Page 37

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 21 (Justice) is based.Thus, it specifies the types of witnesses and their numbers, and the issues that should be taken into consideration while reviewing their testimonies as well.Likewise, it gives various instructions about the judiciary and mentions how judges should pass a judgment.It also prescribes physical punishments for various crimes which come under the authority of government, e.g.the sentence for murder and theft.It outlines the laws of inheritance, restricts the government’s jurisdiction of taxation, gives details about taxes, and defines the authority of the government in relation to the expenditure of these taxes.Rules for the army and rules governing treaties between nations are also set forth.Similarly, it gives basic principles for international relations.It also specifies rules for employees and employers, and even for roads.In short, Islam defines all matters concerned with government.Thus, it cannot be said that Islam has given free reign to government; rather, it has discussed every department of government in details.Whosoever follows Islam, and finds details of all commands related to government, cannot deny the relationship between government and religion.On the contrary, he will have to admit that those acts of the Holy Prophet sa which are related to government are as binding as the principles of S al a t, Fasting, etc.This is because the God Who commands us to pray, fast, perform Hajj, and pay Zakat has also given guidelines

Page 38

22 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH for the political affairs and organization of a country.It cannot be said that every nation and every country is at liberty to invent an organization of its own choice; rather, it has to follow Islamic rules in all spheres of life.If the Holy Prophet sa had adopted these of his own choice, we could have argued that people were free in this respect.However, when we admit that these rules and regulations have been described in the Holy Quran, and that the Holy Prophet sa narrated them under the command of God Almighty, then it shows that it was not the personal approach of the Holy Prophet sa.Considering that the Holy Quran has revealed all the basic precepts of governance, it would be unreasonable to assume that it does not clarify how government should implement them.It would be like a person who collects timber, windows, doors, paint, etc.to build a house, but when asked about the expected time of construction and proposed drawing of the house, he shows complete ignorance.Clearly, when he arranged for the bricks, had the doors, windows, and ventilators made, and acquired the lime and clay, his purpose was to build a house and not to let all these things go waste.Similarly, when the Holy Quran has mentioned all these things related to government, then the human mind cannot accept that it has not given commands on how to run government and the type of organization the Islamic government should have.If it does not make this clear, then one

Page 39

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 23 would have to admit that the Holy Quran (God forbid) is flawed.Comprehensive Guidance of Islam about all Institutions of Government As Islam has given detailed guidelines for all the institutions of government, one cannot say that religion has nothing to do with these matters and that every nation and every country is free to choose a suitable organization for itself.One can argue on whether the Islamic sharia has granted individual freedom in certain matters, but it would be illogical to assert that Islam discusses minor issues but ignores the most important issue, the issue of the rights of a person against the government and how the government should implement Divine commands in its jurisdiction.If this statement were taken as true, then we would be admitting that religion is flawed.A religion which declares the sharia to be a curse can argue that these matters are beyond its jurisdiction; and for the reason that it does not give clear guiding principle for every aspect of human life, it is considered imperfect.For example, if such a religion does not discuss the relation of man with God, the relation between men, or provide guidelines for the affairs of government and politics, it can escape blame because it declares the sharia a curse.On the other hand, a religion that deals with these matters and accepts the authority of God the Almighty to provide

Page 40

24 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH guidance in all these matters, but overlooks such an important issue and endangers the lives of billions of people, will definitely be negligent and defective.Detailed Instructions for Implementation of Law After this introduction, I now come to the actual issue.The Holy Prophet sa was raised in Arabia, and Arabia had no written constitution.For them, their tribal customs were law.Each tribe had a law of its own.They would decide their disputes according to their tribal customs, or, whenever they felt the need for an agreement, they would do so accordingly.When the Holy Prophet sa came, he presented the Divine sharia and told them that God had sent these teachings for them to practice.The Holy Prophet sa had them [Arabs] follow it.If the Holy Quran, a Divine scripture, had confined itself to the injunctions of S al a t , Fasting, and some other beliefs, and the Holy Prophet sa himself had prescribed political and national measures and had implemented them by force, one could have argued that: The Arabs destroyed their own government by brutally attacking the Muslims, thus leaving the country devoid of any organization and law; due to this difficulty and because of the dire need of the time, the Holy Prophet sa introduced and enforced some laws in order to save the country from chaos, but these steps were not a part of his religion.

Page 41

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 25 However, we see not only that detailed commandments for these matters are present in the Holy Quran, but that there are also guidelines for their implementation.For example (1) Allah, the Almighty says in s u rah Al- H ashr: (Al- H ashr, 59:8) “And Whatsoever the messenger gives you, take it; and whatsoever he forbids you, abstain from that.” In other words, the commands given by the Holy Prophet sa are binding upon the Muslims in all circumstances.(2) At another place, Allah, the Almighty says: (Al-Nis a ’, 4:66) “But no, by thy Lord, they are not believers until they make thee judge in all that is in dispute between them and then find not in their hearts any demur concerning that which thou decidest and submit with full submission.” Some people used to raise this objection—and even today some critics say—that the Holy Prophet sa , (God forbid) had no authority to issue guidelines for the settlement of mutual disputes and for the

Page 42

26 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH establishment of an organization.However, Allah says, We reject them in this matter and openly declare: They cannot be declared believers until they make you, O Muhammad sa , the judge in all their disputes, and then submit whole-heartedly to what you decide.Two very important matters are mentioned in this noble verse.Firstly, God the Almighty declares the Holy Prophet sa the final Justice and treats his decision as final; no one will ever have the right to challenge it.The fact that the Holy Prophet sa was declared to be the final Justice shows that he had been granted the right of governance by Allah, the Almighty.Secondly, it becomes evident from this verse that Allah, the Almighty considers submission to his decrees a part of faith.He says that: i.e.By thy Lord! They can never be believers until they submit themselves to your decrees.Thus, this is also a part of faith, just as S al a t , Fasting, Hajj, and Zakat are parts of faith.Suppose two people have a quarrel.One says that ten dollars are due from the other, and the other denies this claim.Both come to the Holy Prophet sa and put their dispute before him.The Holy Prophet sa decides the case in favour of one of them.If the other does not submit to

Page 43

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 27 the decision, then Allah, the Almighty calls him a disbeliever, despite the fact that he might be following Islamic injunctions of S al a t , Fasting, and Hajj.Allah, the Almighty gives His decree against that person, that he does not remain a believer if he does not abide by the decision given by the Holy Prophet sa.Thus, the words reveal that God Almighty has declared this a part of religion and does not treat it separately.(3) It is said in a third verse: (Al-N u r, 24:52) When God and His messenger call the believers and say, come, we will decide your disputes, their response is that we hear and we obey.We have heard the command of the Holy Prophet sa and we shall always obey him.Allah, the Almighty says: These are the people who will always succeed and will always be victorious.The fact that Allah, the Almighty has, on one hand, linked submission to the decisions of the Holy Prophet sa with faith, and on the other hand, called those people triumphant who say, “we hear and we obey”, and do not go against his decisions, shows that the approval of God is in all these matters.If one does not obey these commands, then the punishment of

Page 44

28 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH God befalls him and renders him unsuccessful.However, this does not apply to worldly matters where only natural consequences come forth.(4) Then Allah, the Almighty says: (Al-A‘r a f, 7:158) Meaning, those who follow him who is the Prophet sa of God, His Messenger, and the Immaculate one, about whom there are prophecies in the Torah and Gospel, know that he always enjoins on them good and forbids them from evil.It is as if he enforces a law on the people and guides them in what they should do and what they should not.He enjoins goodness and forbids them from evil.He gives appropriate instructions for human behaviour, speech, and eating habits.He tells them what to do and what not to do; what to say and what not to say.Similarly, he removes the burdens from them which had become unbearable for them, and releases them from their shackles that have blocked their path to progress.

Page 45

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 29 So those who believe in this Prophet sa , and honour his commands and support him, help him, and follow the light that has been sent down with him—these shall prosper in this world and the hereafter.It is obvious that governments always make similar laws, permitting some things and prohibiting others.The Holy Quran declares that the authority pertaining to a government is given to Hadrat Muhammad sa.Those who follow him will prosper and those who deviate from it will be unsuccessful.(5) Similarly, it is said: (Al- H ujur a t, 49:8) In this verse, Allah, the Almighty describes the type of government of Hadrat Muhammad sa , whether it will be a worldly kingdom or of some other form.He says that: The Messenger of God is present among the people, and if he were to comply with their counsel most of the time, the people would surely get into trouble.However, Allah, the Almighty has endeared faith to your hearts, and you are well aware of the fact

Page 46

30 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH that keeping faith is very valuable and beneficial for you, and loosing it is perilous for you.He has entrenched this faith in your hearts in a beautiful form, and He has made disbelief, wickedness, sin, and disobedience hateful to you.Therefore, you should understand clearly that your Prophet sa has the authority to comply with or reject your counsel.Surely these are the people who are the guided ones.The Holy Prophet’s sa System of Government In this verse, Allah, the Almighty has mentioned how the Holy Prophet sa carried out the affairs of the government and has revealed that he did not accept every suggestion given by the people.It was necessary to point this out, lest someone should say that Hadrat Muhammad sa made all decisions, like a parliament, according to the wishes of the people.Similarly, some might have asserted that he only enforced the decisions of his people and did not establish his own rule.Therefore, Allah, the Almighty clarified this confusion in this verse, and has directly addressed the people, saying, that if His Messenger sa were to comply with their wishes, they would surely come to trouble.Therefore, it was not the tradition of the Prophet sa to make decisions according to a majority vote.Rather, when he considered the opinion of the majority beneficial, he gave his verdict in its

Page 47

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 31 favour, and when he considered it harmful, he decided against it.The words, [in most matters], show that it was not necessary for the Prophet sa to comply with all of their wishes; rather, he had the authority to reject defective opinions and to give his own verdict.Sixthly it is mentioned: (Al-Taubah, 9:103) O Muhammad sa , take alms out of their wealth in order to cleanse their hearts and improve their economic condition, and always treat them kindly.In this verse, Allah, the Almighty has given three commandments.First, take Zakat , for it will create feelings of kindness and regard for the poor.Second, spend it in such a way as improves the condition of the poor, that they may also advance with the world.Third, it is enjoined in the words, , not to be harsh while collecting Zakat; rather, always be kind with them.This is why whenever the Prophet sa sent collectors of Zakat, they were particularly directed not to take the healthy and fat animals, but to take those animals which were presented willingly, and not to seek robust animals.They were directed to be as lenient as was permitted by the sharia and the law.

Page 48

32 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH In the seventh verse, which discusses matters related to government, Allah, the Almighty says: (Al-Taubah, 9:81) Those who did not partake in the blessings of joining the expedition with the Holy Prophet sa rejoiced in their sitting at home, and were averse to sacrificing their property and their persons in the cause of Allah.They said to one another, “To go forth in such scorching heat amounts to suicide”.Allah, the Almighty says, , Tell them, by making an excuse of heat you have stayed behind, but remember that the fire of Hell will be more intense in heat.Would that they knew and understood this.Here, Allah, the Almighty has expressly commanded the Holy Prophet sa to undertake Jihad, and has asked him to be a warrior and fight with the enemies.Allah, the Almighty has added that those who would not come to fight under his command would be considered guilty in the sight of Allah.Eighthly it is said:

Page 49

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 33 (Al-M a ’idah, 5:34) The punishment for those who fight against Allah and His Messenger, and strive to create disorder in the land, is only this that they be slain or crucified, or their hands and feet be cut off on alternate sides, or they be exiled.This will be a cause of their humiliation in this world, and in the Hereafter they will have a great punishment.Commandment to Expel Infidels from Arabia Ninthly, in the first verses of s u rah Al-Taubah, the commandment was given to expel the infidels from Arabia.Thus, it is said:

Page 50

34 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH (Al-Taubah, 9:1-5) “O Prophet sa of Allah, declare openly among them that the predictions of Allah and His Messenger about their disgrace have been fulfilled.Now none can blame Allah and His Messenger.So tell them to travel in all of Arabia for four months to see whether any government of their own is left, and let them realize that they cannot frustrate the plan of Allah, the Almighty, Who has disgraced the nonbelievers.And proclaim on the day of the Greater Pilgrimage, that Allah and His Messenger are clear of all allegations of the idolaters.So if they repent, it will be better for them, but if they turn away, then they should know that the remnant of their government, if any is left in Arabia, will also be destroyed,

Page 51

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 35 except those of the idolaters with whom you have entered into a treaty, and who have not subsequently failed you nor aided anyone against you.So fulfil your promise with those with whom you have made a treaty till the term of the treaty.Surely, Allah loves those who are righteous.But aside from them, however many idolaters are left, tell them that after the passing of four months from today, they should leave Arabia.If they disobey and stay in Arabia, then for their disobedience, We order you to kill the idolaters wherever you find them, for they have not abided by the orders of the government, and take them prisoners and besiege them, and lie in wait for them at every place of ambush.But if they become Muslims and perform S al a t and pay Zakat, then leave their way free.Surely, Allah is Most Forgiving, Merciful.” Now ponder: what is government? Government is not that the order of a husband be obeyed by his wife, and vice versa.Government has specific jurisdiction; anyone who gives commands cannot be called a king.In English there is a famous joke, that once a child asked his father, “Who is called a king”? The father said, “A king is a person whom nobody can disobey”.On hearing this, the child said, “Father, then our mother is a king”.It seems that the mother was a dominating person, which is why the child said that if

Page 52

36 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH this is the definition of a king, his mother proves true to the definition.Essential Features of Government Government has a specific jurisdiction.When we identify a government, it must have some necessary features.Some of them are: (1) There must be a specified boundary of a country’s government, i.e.whatever the organization is, it must have a boundary and jurisdiction from one place to another.Boundaries are an important feature of government.(2) Government has the power to restrict the financial, personal, and civic liberties of people.For instance, government has the power to imprison someone, to expel someone from the country, or collect revenue by force.Similarly, it can impose restrictions on personal liberty.For instance, it can order the youth to join the army or it can call volunteers at a time of need.(3) It has the power to levy and collect taxes.Similarly, it has the power to make treaties with sovereign countries, to make laws for immigrants and emigrants, and to regulate business and trade.It has the power of Qa da.In short, all of these functions fall within the jurisdiction of government, and it has the power to deal with them in its own way.Particularly, the existence of boundaries is a necessary requisite for government, for boundaries enable it to delimit the

Page 53

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 37 geographical extent of the implementation of its laws.It is also essential for foreigners who come into those boundaries to obey the laws of the country.One who goes out of the boundaries also goes, to a certain extent, outside the reach of the laws of that government.Thus, government is obliged to issue orders in certain matters, to prohibit certain other matters, and to impose restrictions on financial, personal, and civic liberties at times of need.It has the power to collect taxes, recruit for the army, enter into treaties, and render justice.Now let us see whether the Prophet sa was given all of these powers or not.First are the boundaries of a country.The empowerment of the Prophet sa in this regard is clear, since he declared that no one could live within a specific area except for Muslims.If someone else were to come, he would be expelled.Second, rules were enforced for those people living there.Similarly, Allah, the Almighty empowered him to conclude treaties with others, or to terminate them with certain conditions when he considered the need for it.He was given the power to collect taxes, and to restrict financial, personal, and civic liberties.Therefore, all powers of government were given to the Prophet sa by Allah.Government orders the legality of certain things and prohibits others; it checks the financial, personal, and civic liberties of people in certain circumstances.Allah, the Almighty empowered him to take their property, collect taxes, and demand their

Page 54

38 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH lives for war.He was empowered to expel unwanted people from his country.Justice is also an obligation of government.Government has the power to issue a decree, i.e.the final verdict, and Islam gives that authority to the Prophet sa and declares his decision to be final.The Prophet sa was not bound to comply with all of the wishes of the people, but they were obliged to submit totally, because compliance to their wishes in most matters could have dangerous consequences.Thus, it is proven from these verses that the Prophet’s sa management of the affairs of government was not an interim arrangement, but was a part of sharia.As the commands of S al a t and Fasting etc.are a part of religion, so is the organization of the government of the Prophet sa.It cannot, in any way, be called worldly or interim.Were Commands Related to Establishment of an Organization only for the Prophet sa ? The plea of those who deny the need for Khilafat, that “Islam does not present any definite organization”, is open to this critique, that by accepting the part of the Prophet’s sa work pertaining to the organization as having no religious sanction, it will also have to be accepted that his work was simply to meet provisional needs.Ali bin Abdur Razzaq has also realized this.As an intelligent person, he is apprehensive of opposition from people who may

Page 55

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 39 object that when the Holy Quran contains commands pertaining to government, how can he call the acts of the Prophet sa interim and claim that Islam does not present any specific organization.He has tried to find a way out by saying that the government of the Prophet sa was the government of Prophethood and love, and not a kingdom.He says that, though the Prophet sa gave many directives, they were all the commands of a Prophet, not that of the head of an institution.Since the commands were not of the head of an institution, they cannot be delegated to others.As all those commands were given in the capacity of a Prophet, they ceased to be operative upon his death.The powers which the Prophet sa exercised were specific to his Prophethood.People greatly loved him, and as a result, they obeyed his commands.This was the case at the time of the Prophet sa.The Companions ra loved him intensely and were always ready to obey him, even at the cost of their lives.Thus, they obeyed all of his commands, for they loved him and he was their beloved, and lovers always obey their beloved.However, this does not mean that all those commands became obligatory for all time.They were only concerned with him, and when he died, the applicability of these commands ended.

Page 56

40 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Intense Love of Followers with their Prophet The plea of Ali bin Abdur Razzaq is valid to the extent that the companions of a Prophet have an intense love for their Prophet.We are eyewitnesses of the fact that thousands of members of our community imitated the acts of the Promised Messiah as.Once, someone raised the objection, in the presence of the Promised Messiah as , that some members of his Community shaved their beard.The Promised Messiah as said: “Once they acquire perfect love, they will automatically start maintaining a beard because I have one; there would, then, be no need of any advice or directive”.There is no doubt that the love between a Prophet and his followers is so intense that its like cannot be found in worldly relationships.In fact, sometime, in the intensity of love, man apparently ignores sensibility.It was the habit of Hadrat Abdullah bin Umar ra that whenever he went for Hajj, he used to sit at one place to pass water.Someone enquired of him why he did thus.He replied, “The fact is that the Prophet sa once sat here to pass water.Whenever I come here, it brings to my mind the act of the Prophet sa and I sit here for a short time without fail.” 7 7 Musnad Ahmad bin Hambal, Vol.1, p.131, by Ahmad bin Muhammad bin Hambal bin Hil a l bin Asad, Published by Baitul Afk a r Ad-Dauliyya, Al- Ri ad , AH 1419, AD 1998.Note: Volume and page No.are according to Nuskha Maimaniyyah.

Page 57

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 41 In love, sometimes a person does such things in imitation as are apparently senseless.Thus, we accept that the Companions ra loved the Prophet sa and obeyed him completely.But here, the question is not whether they obeyed him due to their love for him or because they were under some pressure.The question is whether Islam gave the Prophet sa any power to rule a country and its people or not? Similarly, was he given power over those who disobeyed those commands? If the Holy Quran had mentioned only commands without prescribing punishments for those who did not comply, then it could be said that the Prophet sa issued commands and the Companions ra obeyed them due to their love for him.However, we see that this is not the case, because punishments are also prescribed.It is said, on committing such and such crime, one will receive this punishment, and for some other crime, one will receive that punishment.Since the Holy Quran has prescribed punishments, the rule of love is not correct in its entirety, for punishments are not prescribed when the compliance of commands is attached with love only.Islam has not simply given some commands, but it has also detailed the organization of government.Where details are given, there it has kept the door of consensus open for people so that rational mental faculties may not go to waste.Therefore, in some matters, Hadrat Abu Bakr ra applied his judgment and presented the real Islamic issue before people.

Page 58

42 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Similarly Hadrat Umar ra , Hadrat Usman ra , and Hadrat Ali ra guided people according to the prevailing circumstances.Indeed, there are some matters which are still under consideration.Issue of Consent upon Reaching Puberty For instance, when the Nik ah (announcement of marriage) of a daughter is agreed by her father before the daughter’s age of puberty, does she have the right to nullify it upon attaining puberty or not? This is a question which continuously arises.It is mentioned in the old books of Fiqah (Islamic jurisprudence) that if a father makes the Nik ah of his daughter, then she has no right to break it on attaining puberty, but I have concluded that a girl has that right, and if she does not like the match, she can refuse it.Similarly, there are so many issues of Fiqah which continuously arise, and a number of them will come up in the future.We are not concerned with details of whether Islam gave a specific form of government to the Prophet sa , because there are various forms of government.The form of the government of England is different from America, America’s from Russia, and Russia’s from Germany.However, due to these differences, we cannot say that one is a government and that the other is not.Government means that a specific organization should be chosen and established within national boundaries, and the reigns of the people should be entrusted in the hands of a

Page 59

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 43 person or a party.Thus, we have to look at whether Islam enjoins an organization or not, irrespective of how different it may be from others, and whether the Prophet sa implemented that organization or not.Islam Ordains a National and Legal Organization There is no doubt that Islam does not favour kingdoms, for kingship has a specific significance which Islam does not permit.The Prophet sa said, concerning himself, that he was not a king, and he did not use the word king for his Khulaf a ’.However, this does not mean that Islam does not favour any religious national organization.If some form of an organization is proven from the Holy Quran and Islam, then we can say that though Islam opposes kingdoms, it establishes a specific form of organization in its place, and that is a part of the religion of Islam.As it is religious, its establishment is essential for Muslims as far as they have power.Government is, in fact, a name of national boundaries and the implementation of specific rules within it.It is not the name of a particular form.National boundaries and enforcement of specific rules are proven from the Holy Quran, as is clear from the verses which I have just quoted above.Since the elements of a national boundary, a specific law, citizenship, treaties, and foreigners are found, a particular form of government is proven.We do not call it a kingdom because that

Page 60

44 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH word has a connotation which Islam does not approve of; nevertheless, the institution of a national and legal organization is proven.This is what we wish to prove; and we believe that Khilafat is essential to establish that organization.Thus, Khilafat is an Islamic organization, and not the outcome of an interim policy.I agree that if the need for Khilafat were denied, that would support the logic of Ali bin Abdur Razzaq.In one way or the other, that would also lead to rejection of the organization established by the Holy Prophet sa.Those who deny Khilafat without accepting this viewpoint are either fools or want to deceive people.Since it is proven that the Holy Quran ordains that national affairs and national organizations are a part of religion, and the fact that the Holy Prophet sa implemented them makes them religious, his directives and guidance in these matters is sunnah, which is to be followed in the same way as the commands of S al a t and Fasting etc.The demand for any concession in these is also a demand for a concession in the faith of Islam.This logic simultaneously affirms that as the commands of S al a t and Fasting did not come to an end after the life of the Prophet sa , so the commands concerning the nation’s and country’s organization have also not come to an end after his death.S al a t and Fasting are necessary for the spiritual progress of a person, also necessary is the organization to enforce rules for the progress of a

Page 61

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 45 country.As the assembly in S a la t is a congregational worship that should be continued through his successors after him, similarly, other affairs should also be performed through his successors.The commands of S al a t and Fasting, given by God Almighty, do not mean that after the death of the Prophet sa there is no need to perform S al a t and Fasting.Similarly, the Islamic directives to establish an organization do not mean that they will be impracticable later on.After the expiry of the first Imam, a second is appointed in his place.Similarly, the injunctions pertaining to the organizational system should remain in force through successors.Reasons for Mutiny of Arabian Tribes I think that it was due to this confusion—that the commands related to the organization were concerned only with the life of the Prophet sa —that the Arab tribes rebelled after his death.They refused to pay Zakat.Their logic was that God Almighty did not authorize any one else to collect Zakat except the Prophet sa.He said: “O’ Muhammad sa , take a part of their wealth as Zakat.” There is no mention of any one else being authorized to collect Zakat after him.The Muslims did not accept their plea, although here, the Prophet sa is particularly addressed.The

Page 62

46 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH major argument of the apostates was that: “Only the Prophet sa —and no one else—was authorized to collect Zakat”.This was the cause of their going astray.They thought that the commands related to the organization were not forever, but that they were concerned only with the life of the Prophet sa.As I have proven, this idea is wrong.The fact is that just as the commands of S al a t and Fasting have not come to an end after the Prophet sa , so the commands related to a nation’s and country’s organization would not come to an end after his death.Like the assembly of S al a t , which is a collective act of worship, other commands should also remain in practice through deputies among the Muslims.The Details of Issue of Khilafat After this discussion of basic principles, I now address the details of the issue of Khilafat.One should remember that a Prophet has a very close relationship with God Almighty.It is so intense that some people make the mistake of thinking that he himself is God, a type of mistake which the Christians made.Those who do not make this mistake consider a Prophet to be a human being.Due to the intensity of the attachment of a Prophet with God and the manifestations of His love, it never occurs to the followers that he will eventually die.It is not that they consider the Prophet immortal, but due to the intensity of their love, they presume that they will die first and

Page 63

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 47 that Allah, the Almighty will greatly prolong the life of the Prophet.Therefore, there has never been any Prophet about whom his followers ever presumed that he will die and they will remain alive.Rather, every person (except those of little faith) presumes that the Prophet will remain alive and that they will die.This is why also adherents never discussed what would happen after the Prophet.At other times, people may discuss the consequences of the death of a certain person, but they have no such apprehensions during the life of a Prophet.The reason for this, I have already mentioned, is intense love.We also have personal experience of this.A Personal Experience Among us, there was no Ahmadi—except those whose hearts were diseased or whose faith was imperfect—who ever thought that the Promised Messiah as would die and that he would outlive him.Young or old, children or elderly, men or women, all thought that they would die first and the Promised Messiah as would remain alive.Due to the intensity of love and the close relationship that a Prophet has with God Almighty, his followers always imagine that Allah, the Almighty would bestow great longevity upon His Prophet.No one thinks that a Prophet will live forever, but they do think that they will die first and that the Prophet of God Almighty will continue to live in this world.Thus, on many occasions, young

Page 64

48 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH men of eighteen to twenty came to the Promised Messiah as and respectfully requested him to lead their funeral on the event of their death.We were surprised to hear young men making that request to the Promised Messiah as —who was over seventy and not in good health—to lead the funeral on their deaths, as though they were sure that he would remain alive and they would die in his presence.Consequently, the thought would come to the minds of hundreds of people, ten to fifteen days after his death, that the Promised Messiah as has not yet died.My own condition was such that, three days after the death of the Promised Messiah as , I was on a walk with my friend to D a rul-Anw a r.In those days, there was a preposition under discussion and it was considered very important.On my way back, I began pondering and meditated quietly.Instantly, a subtle point occurred to me, and I exclaimed that I have found the solution and will mention it to the Promised Messiah as on reaching home, and I will tell him that on his demise, the enemies had made a query and I have found the answer, although at that time, three days had passed since his demise.Those who have tasted this love know what they thought in the lifetime of the Promised Messiah as , and what the condition of their heart was on his death.The same was the condition of the Companions ra of the Holy Prophet sa.Their love with the Prophet sa was unprecedented in history.It was very difficult for the Companions ra to believe that the Holy Prophet sa would

Page 65

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 49 die and they would live, though they did not consider him God.They considered him a human being, but due to the intensity of their love, they could not expect such a thing to happen in their lifetime.What happened at the time of his death is a very clear illustration of this point.Condition of Companions ra on the Death of the Holy Prophet sa A ha d i th and history reveal that when news of the death of the Prophet sa spread, Hadrat Umar ra stood up with sword in hand and said that the rumour was a mischief of the hypocrites; rather, the Prophet sa was alive and had not died, he had gone to heaven to receive some command of God and would return in a short time and punish the hypocrites.He was so strong in his assertion that he declared that if anyone said that the Prophet sa had died, he would kill him.After this, he paced back and forth in the mosque— impassioned and enraged—with sword in hand.8 This assertion appealed to the people so much that none of them felt any need to contradict it, even though it is clearly mentioned in the Holy Quran, about the Prophet sa , that: ( A l-e-‘Imr a n, 3:145) 8 As-S i ratul H albiyyah, Vol.3, p.500, by Abul Farj Nuruddin Ali bin Ibr a h i m bin Ahmad, Published by D a rul Kutubil ‘Ilmiyyah Beirut, Lebanon.First edition, AH.1422, AD.2002.

Page 66

50 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH “If Muhammad sa , the Messenger of Allah, dies or is martyred, will you turn back on your heels?” Despite a clear mention of this point in the Holy Quran, which revealed the death of the Prophet sa , the Companions ra were so shocked on his demise that many of them presumed that he had not died and treated the news as a rumour spread by the hypocrites.The reason for this was that they could not conceive, in the intensity of their love with the Prophet sa , that he would die and they would live.Some of the Companions ra , who were of a cooler temperament, feared that the people were being put to trial.They hurriedly brought Hadrat Abu Bakr ra.When he arrived at the mosque, he saw the Companions ra exclaiming that the hypocrites were liars and that the Holy Prophet sa had not died but was alive.It was as if a condition of madness had overwhelmed them, just as I mentioned earlier, that I thought of telling the Promised Messiah as the reply of the query raised by his enemies on his death.When Hadrat Abu Bakr ra saw this condition of the people, he went to the room where the holy remains of the Prophet sa had been laid.He enquired from Hadrat Ayeshah ra the condition of the Prophet sa.She told him that he had passed away.On hearing this, Hadrat Abu Bakr ra raised the cloth from the face of the Prophet sa , kissed his forehead, and said, “Allah, the Almighty will not combine two deaths upon you”, meaning that it is impossible that

Page 67

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 51 on one side, you should pass away, and on the other, that death should also overtake your nation, and that they deviate from true faith.Then he came out, and standing upon the pulpit, he addressed the people that Muhammad sa , the Messenger of Allah, had died, and he recited, ( A l-e-‘Imr a n, 3:145) After this, he said with great force, “O People! Muhammad, no doubt, was the Messenger of Allah, but now he has passed away.If any one of you worshipped Muhammad sa , the Messenger of Allah, they should know that he has passed away, but if you worship God, then know that your God is alive and that death will never overtake Him.” Hadrat Umar ra , who was standing by leaning on his sword, waiting that when Hadrat Abu Bakr ra descends from the pulpit he would behead him, heard this verse and a veil was immediately removed from his eyes.His knees began trembling, his hands began shivering along with his body, and he fell to the ground out of weakness.The other Companions ra also admitted that their eyes had been veiled, but when they heard this verse from Hadrat Abu Bakr ra , everything became clear to them.Their whole world became dark and they wandered the streets of Medina weeping, and reciting:

Page 68

52 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 9 The couplet of Hadrat H ass a n ra also reveals this condition: 10 “O’ Prophet of God! You were the pupil of my eye.Now, on your death, my eye has become blind.It was only you concerning whom I feared death.Now, after your demise, whoever may die, I cannot have any concern.” No Consideration on Succession of a Prophet in his Lifetime When the condition of the hearts and minds of people in the life of a Prophet is such, it can be understood that God and His Prophet save them from the agony of facing it.This sensitive issue, of what will happen after the death of a Prophet, is stated in subtle words.The nation does not give much attention to this issue, nor does it ponder over what will happen after the Prophet.It is not proven from any source that 9 As-S i ratun Nabawiyyah, Vol.4, pp.182-183, by Abu Muhammad Abdul M a lik bin Hish a m bin Ayy u b Al-Himyar i Al-Mu‘ a fir i , published by D a rul Kutubil ‘Ilmiyyah, Beirut, Lebanon.First edition, AH.1420, AD.2000.10 Sharha D i w a n H ass a n bin Th a bit Al-An sa r i , p.165.Edited by Abdur Ra h m a n Al-Barq u t i.Published by Al-Ma t ba‘ Ra h m a niyyah, Egypt.AH 1347, AD 1929.

Page 69

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 53 the Prophet sa was ever asked, “O Messenger of Allah, when you pass away, then what will happen? Will there will be Khilafat, or parliament, or a committee to look after the affairs of the Muslims?” Only a hard- hearted person can speak on such matters, or one who is devoid of love for a Prophet and unaware of his greatness.The A ha d i th show that the Companions ra enquired from him about many problems and received information by putting questions, but the issue of succession was one which the Companions ra could not ask about, nor could they think of it, for they thought that he would outlive them.Thus, this issue, to some extent, remained veiled, and the death of the Prophet sa was the real time of its disclosure.These were the state of affairs at the time of the death of the Prophet sa.Upon his demise, the Companions ra felt a great shock.It was the first time they realized that it was possible for the Prophet sa to be separated from them; for the first time, the importance of their need for an organization, in accordance to the ways and wishes of the Prophet sa , dawned upon them in its true significance, and they began to reflect on its different aspects.No doubt, the details of the organization are present in the Holy Quran, but they remained veiled to them and they never discussed them.They read them in some other context.They did not interpret them in such ways as would reveal to them what they should do after the death of the Prophet sa.

Page 70

54 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Every Prophet has Two Lives (I) Personal, (II) National There is Divine wisdom working behind this devoted love, because there are two lives of a Prophet—one is personal and the other is national.Allah, the Almighty initiates both these lives by revelation.The personal life of a Prophet starts with revelation as follows: When he is thirty or forty years old, revelation begins descending upon him, and he is called a Messenger for the guidance and purification of people.As a result of these revelations, he sees extraordinary blessings of Allah, the Almighty descending upon him, and feels a new vigour, a new life, and new nobility.The national life of a Prophet also starts with revelation.When he passes away, the organization which is initiated after his demise is not based on any ready-made scheme.Rather, an instant change occurs, and Allah, the Almighty diverts the hearts of people toward that organization by an indirect revelation.Prophet’s Personal Life is First Manifestation of Divine Power and his National Life is Second Just as Allah, the Almighty starts the personal life of a Prophet with revelation, in the same way, his national life, which starts after his demise, begins with revelation.Thus, there is a resemblance between the two.This is why the Promised Messiah as has named it

Page 71

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 55 the Second Manifestation of Divine Power.The First Manifestation of Divine Power is the personal life of the Prophet, and the Second Manifestation is his national life.Since Allah, the Almighty lays the foundations of his national life with revelation and by His Divine Power, He keeps its details veiled from the eyes of people in the life of the Prophet.When the Prophet passes away, Allah, the Almighty diverts the attention of people to the details of this life by indirect revelation.It is stated in the Gospels that after the demise of ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ), his disciples gathered at one place, and the Holy Spirit descended upon them and they started speaking many different languages.Though the authors of the Gospels have turned it into an absurd story, the incident makes it clear that after the assumed demise of Christ, there was a sudden change in the hearts of the disciples, of which they had no hint of before.They had to attribute this change to Divine Power.In short, Allah, the Almighty starts the new life of a Prophet like the personal one, with His revelation and Divine Power.That is why the details of his new life are kept veiled from the eyes of people during the life of Prophet.A Look in the Dispute of “ Qir ta s ” [Folio] Here I want to mention an interesting incident.There has been a prolonged dispute between the Shias and Sunnis, which is called the dispute of Qir ta s [folio].It is mentioned in A ha d i th that when the Holy

Page 72

56 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Prophet sa was suffering severely in his final illness, he asked the Companions ra to bring a folio, a pen, and inkpot, so that he might dictate for them something which would keep them rightly guided.The Shias assert that the Holy Prophet sa wanted to dictate that Hadrat Ali ra would be the Khalifah after him, and that he should be honoured as their Imam.They say that Hadrat Umar ra did not let him dictate, and asked the people to leave the matter, saying that the Holy Prophet sa was in great suffering, and it was not advisable to trouble him, and that the Holy Quran being sufficient as guidance, nothing else was required.The Shias call this the connivance of Hadrat Umar ra , that in order to usurp sovereignty from Hadrat Ali ra , he did not let the Holy Prophet sa dictate a will.They say that if he had let the Holy Prophet sa dictate a will, he would have dictated in favour of Hadrat Ali ra.There are many answers to this objection, but I will give only two at this time.First, if the Holy Prophet sa wanted to dictate a will of Khilafat in favour of Hadrat Ali ra , then why, on the intervention of Hadrat Umar ra , did he not ask again for the pen and inkpot? He, after all, should know that the attempt of Hadrat Umar ra , being an enemy of Hadrat Ali ra (God forbid), could not benefit Hadrat Ali ra in any way.In such a situation, the Holy Prophet sa would have surely asked of Hadrat Umar ra the reason for his conduct.He, no doubt, was suffering, but he did not take any notice of it.He could have ordered that the

Page 73

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 57 pen and inkpot be brought quickly, so that he might dictate something, but he did not ask for the pen and inkpot a second time.When Hadrat Umar ra said that the Book of God was sufficient as guidance, the Holy Prophet sa kept quiet.It clearly means that the Holy Prophet sa wanted to dictate the same thing as was stated by Hadrat Umar ra.After hearing the commitment of the Companions ra to act according to the Book of God, the Holy Prophet sa felt no need to dictate a separate will.Therefore, this incident does not convict Hadrat Umar ra in any way, rather it shows how close his thinking was to that of the Holy Prophet sa.The second answer, which provides great historical evidence as a conclusive rebuttal of the baseless ideas of the Shias, is the following: On such occasions, a will is dictated by a person who is on his death bed.If the will is not dictated at that time, then there no opportunity is left to do so.However, a person who has hope that Allah, the Almighty will grant him recovery from a simple ailment gives no importance to a will and considers it useless to trouble himself with it.When we consider these incidents in light of the circumstances which the Companions ra faced on the demise of the Holy Prophet sa , we find that Hadrat Umar ra had no notion of taking sovereignty in his hands when the Holy Prophet sa was about to depart.When the Holy Prophet sa passed away, the shock was so severe and sudden, and so contrary to expectations,

Page 74

58 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH that it made Hadrat Umar ra somewhat senseless, and he did not believe in any way that the Holy Prophet sa had passed away.He was the one who, even after the demise of the Holy Prophet sa , did not believe that he had passed away, and whose heart was full of the hope of his revival, and who came forward with a sword in his hand announcing that whoever would say that the Holy Prophet sa had died would be killed.How can it be imagined that such a person assumed that the Holy Prophet sa was about to die and stopped him from dictating something in favour of Hadrat Ali ra.Rather, when we consider events from the perspective of the Shias, we find that certain doubts may possibly be raised against Hadrat Ali ra , who appeared to be expecting the demise of the Holy Prophet sa.On the other hand, Hadrat Umar ra , in the intensity of love, appeared to be expecting his recovery from what he believed was a simple ailment, and hoping that he would not die.Thus, this situation, from the Shia perspective, raises some questions about Hadrat Ali ra.However, it does not malign Hadrat Umar ra ; indeed, it proves his nobility, righteousness, and excellence.Allah, the Almighty Starts National Life of a Prophet with Revelation I was pointing out that after the demise of a Prophet, Allah, the Almighty starts his national life by revelation.Therefore, Allah, the Almighty keeps the establishment of Khilafat and its details veiled until

Page 75

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 59 the demise of the Prophet.In the circumstances under which the Holy Prophet sa passed away, some Companions ra initially considered that he had not passed away, but when they came to know of his demise, they were struck with shock and grief.They started agonizing over what should be done and what steps should be taken to continue the mission of the Holy Prophet sa ? In such confusion and pain, they moved here and there, and consequently, in a short time, they were divided into two groups, which, later on, became three.Three Groups of Companions ra after the Demise of the Holy Prophet sa One group thought that, after the Holy Prophet sa , there should be a person who would establish an Islamic system.They thought that as the family members of the Holy Prophet sa were considered the best judges of his wishes, thus, a Successor should be from the family of the Holy Prophet sa , and not from any other family.They believed that if a Successor were chosen from another family, people would not obey him, and thus the Islamic organization would be jeopardized.If the Khalifah was chosen from his family, then the people, who were used to obeying the family of the Holy Prophet sa would obey him willingly as well, just as when a king dies and his son becomes his Successor people obey him willingly, just as they obeyed the father.

Page 76

60 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH The other group thought that the condition of choosing from the family members of the Holy Prophet sa was not necessary.The purpose was to have a Successor to the Holy Prophet sa.They thought that whoever was more competent should be entrusted with the responsibility.This second group was further divided in two sections.Although they agreed that there should be a Successor of the Holy Prophet sa , they differed on which people the Successor should be from.One group was in favour of a person who had been under his supervision for a long time, and for this, the deserving person should be from the Muh a jir i n [Immigrants], and especially the Quraish, whom the Arabs would obey willingly.The other group thought that, as the Holy Prophet sa passed away in Medina where the An sa r [Helpers] were in majority, they could fulfil this obligation best.Dispute between Muh a jir i n and An sa r A dispute arose between the An sa r and Muh a jir i n.The An sa r thought that, as the Holy Prophet sa lived among them during that part of his life which was related to an organizational system, and as there had been no such system in Mecca, they could understand the system better than any one else and were thus entitled to Khilafat.Their second argument was that as the territory, i.e.Medina, belonged to them, their word would carry more weight than that of the

Page 77

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 61 Muh a jir i n.Therefore, they thought that the Successor of the Holy Prophet sa should be from the An sa r and not from the Muh a jir i n.Contrary to this, the Muh a jir i n said that their companionship with the Holy Prophet sa was longer than that of the An sa r , thus, they could understand the religion better.People were still considering this dispute and had not yet resolved it when the group in favour of the An sa r gathered in the verandah of Bani Sa‘dah and started consulting with one another.They were inclined towards the appointment of Sa‘d bin Ubadah, leader of Khazraj and a recognized Chief, as Khalifah.During this discussion, the An sa r argued that they were the owners of the country, its lands, and its properties; therefore, it is better for Islam that the Khalifah be from them.They thought no person more competent for the post than Sa’d bin Abadah.While this discussion was taking place, some said: What if the Muh a jir i n reject this arrangement.Someone said that they would reply “ one Am i r from us and one from you ”.Sa’d, who was a wise man, called this the first weakness; saying that “ one Am i r from us and one from you ”, denotes complete ignorance about the concept of Khilafat.Such a situation would hurt Islam.When the Muh a jir i n learned of what was happening, they went there in a hurry, for they knew that if the Khalifah was not from the Muh a jir i n , the Arabs would not submit to him.No doubt, the An sa r were the majority in Medina, but all

Page 78

62 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH of Arabia honoured the nobility and greatness of the Meccans.The Muh a jir i n thought that if the Khalifah were from the An sa r , the Arabs would be put to a great crisis and there might be many who would not be able to preserve their faith in the face of such a crisis.Consequently, all of the Muh a jir i n went there, and among them were Hadrat Abu Bakr ra , Hadrat Umar ra , and Hadrat Abu Ubaidah ra.Hadrat Umar ra later recalled: “I had prepared an eloquent speech for this occasion.I had planned to deliver it immediately upon arrival so that it would convince all of the An sa r , and they would have no alternative but to elect a Khalifah from the Muh a jir i n rather than An sa r.When we arrived, Hadrat Abu Bakr ra stood up to make an address, and I did not expect anything exceptional from him, but by God, he presented all the points that I myself had thought of.In addition, he put forth more of his own arguments.Then I understood that I was no match to Hadrat Abu Bakr ra.” 11 The Muh a jir i n pointed out the necessity of an Am i r from the Quraish, and quoted a saying of the Holy Prophet sa , “The Am i rs should be from Quraish”.12 They also pointed out that they 11 Al-K a mil fit T a r i kh , Vol.2, pp.328, 329, by ‘Izzuddin Abul Hasan Ali bin Abul Karam Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Abdul Kar i m bin Abdul W ah id Ash-sh i b a n i , known as Ibnil Ath i r, publisher D a ru Sa dir, D a r Beirut, AH 1385, AD 1965.12 Musnad Ahmad bin Hambal, Vol.3, p.129, Hadith No.12332, by Ahmad bin Muhammad bin Hambal bin Hil a l bin Asad, Published by Baitul Afk a r Ad-Dauliyya, Al-Ri ad , AH 1419, AD 1998.Note: Volume and page No.are according to Nuskha Maimaniyyah.

Page 79

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 63 were the first to accept Islam and narrated the sacrifices that they had made for Islam.Hab a b bin al- Mundhir of Khazraj opposed this, and said that they could not accept a Khalifah from the Muh a jir i n , and that if the Muh a jir i n could not agree to this and strongly insisted upon their view, then , “one Am i r from us and one from you” should be acted upon.Hadrat Umar ra asked him to be careful of what he was saying and pointed out that the Holy Prophet sa has said that having two Am i rs at one time is unlawful.13 (This indicates that there were such traditions in which the Holy Prophet sa had elaborated the system of Khilafat, but, in his lifetime, the Companions ra did not pay much attention to them.The reason for this is the Divine wisdom that I have mentioned before.) Thus, Hadrat Umar ra concluded that the demand of making one Am i r from each group did not satisfy reason or sharia.Election of Hadrat Abu Bakr ra After some discussion, Hadrat Abu Ubaidah ra stood up and addressed the An sa r saying: You were the first people outside Mecca who accepted Islam; now do not be the first to pervert the principles of religion after the demise of the Holy Prophet sa.This had such a deep impact on them that Bashir bin Sa‘d Khazraji stood up and addressed his people: “This is 13 Ibid p.329.

Page 80

64 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH true that the help and support that we offered and the services we rendered to the Holy Prophet sa were not for any worldly gains or to attain sovereignty after him.They were only for the sake of God.The main concern now is not about the right to Khilafat but about the obligation to Islam.From this perspective, the Am i r should be from the Muh a jir i n , for they were blessed with the company of the Holy Prophet sa for a long time.” The debate continued for some time, and within half an hour or so, the people came around to the view that the Khalifah should be from the Muh a jir i n.Then Hadrat Abu Bakr ra nominated Hadrat Umar ra and Hadrat Abu Ubaida ra for this post, and asked everyone to enter into the Bai‘at (allegiance) of any one of them, but both declined the proposition and said that they would pledge allegiance to the person whom the Holy Prophet sa made the Imam of S al a t , and who was the best among the Muh a jir i n.In other words, there was no one better suited to Khilafat than Hadrat Abu Bakr ra.On this, the people started taking the pledge of Bai‘at at the hand of Hadrat Abu Bakr ra.Hadrat Umar ra was the first to take the Bai‘at , then Hadrat Abu Ubaida ra and after him, Bashir bin Sa‘d Khazraji ra.After them, the tribe of Aus and the people of Khazraj started taking Bai‘at.The people were so enthusiastic, that in their eagerness, they nearly trampled Sa‘d, who was ill and was unable to get up.Within a short time, all except Sa‘d and Hadrat Ali ra took the Bai‘at.Sa‘d’s son also took the Bai‘at.

Page 81

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 65 Hadrat Ali ra did the same after a few days.According to some traditions, Hadrat Ali ra took Bai‘at after three days, and according to others, after six months.The traditions mentioning six months also add that Hadrat Ali ra could not take the Bai‘at of Hadrat Abu Bakr ra because he was busy looking after Hadrat Fatimah ra who was ill at that time.When he came to Hadrat Abu Bakr ra to take the Bai‘at , he apologized for the delay, due to the illness of Hadrat Fatimah ra.14 Election of Hadrat Umar ra On his deathbed, Hadrat Abu Bakr ra sought the advice of the Companions ra on who should be appointed the next Khalifah.The majority gave their opinion in favour of Hadrat Umar ra.Some of them raised only one concern, that Hadrat Umar ra was very strict by nature and he might be hard on people.Hadrat Abu Bakr ra said that the harshness of Hadrat Umar ra would vanish when he is burdened with the responsibility.Thus, all the Companions ra agreed upon the Khilafat of Hadrat Umar ra.As the health of Hadrat Abu Bakr ra was very poor, he, with the support of his wife Asma ra , with trembling hands and feet, went to the mosque and addressed all the Muslims, and said, “I have continuously deliberated on who 14 Al-K a mil fit T a r i kh , Vol.2, p.331, by ‘Izzuddin Abul Hasan Ali bin Abul Karam Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Abdul Kar i m bin Abdul W ah id Ash-sh i b a n i , known as Ibnil Ath i r, publisher D a ru Sa dir, D a r Beirut, AH 1385, AD 1965.

Page 82

66 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH should be your Khalifah after my demise.After much contemplation and prayer, I have decided to nominate Hadrat Umar ra as Khalifah.So Hadrat Umar ra will be the Khalifah after me.” 15 All of the Companions ra and others agreed to this Khilafat and took Bai‘at of Hadrat Umar ra after the demise of Hadrat Abu Bakr ra.Election of Hadrat Usman ra When Hadrat Umar ra was injured and realized that his demise was imminent, he nominated six persons and advised them to elect the Khalifah from among themselves.They included Hadrat Usman ra , Hadrat Ali ra , Hadrat Abdur Rahman bin ‘Auf ra , Hadrat Sa‘d bin Al-Waqq as ra , Hadrat Zubair ra , and Hadrat Talhah ra 16.In addition to them, he included Hadrat Abdullah bin Umar ra as advisor, but did not declare him as entitled to Khilafat.He also admonished that these people should give their verdict within three days, and Suhaib ra should lead the prayer during that period of time.He appointed Miqd a d bin Al-Aswad ra to oversee the consultation and election process and directed him to gather the Electoral College at one place and to guard them.He issued more directions, the people should take the Bai‘at of the person who is elected by the majority of votes, and if any one 15 Al-K a mil fit T a r i kh , Vol.2, p.425, by ‘Izzuddin Abul Hasan Ali bin Abul Karam Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Abdul Kar i m bin Abdul W ah id Ash-sh i b a n i , known as Ibnil Ath i r, publisher D a ru Sa dir, D a r Beirut, AH 1385, AD 1965.16 Ibid, p.66.

Page 83

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 67 declines to do so, then he should be killed.If there be three votes on each side, then Hadrat Abdullah bin Umar ra would recommend who the Khalifah should be.If the members of Electoral College do not agree to the decision of Abdullah bin Umar ra , then the person favoured by Abdur Rahman bin ‘Auf ra should be appointed as Khalifah.These five persons discussed this matter (as Talhah ra was not in Medina at that time), but could not come to any conclusion.After a very long time, Hadrat Abdur Rahman bin ‘Auf ra asked if anyone wanted to withdraw his name, but all of them remained quiet.On this, Hadrat Abdur Rahman bin ‘Auf ra withdrew his name, then Hadrat Usman ra withdrew his name, and then two others did the same.Hadrat Ali ra remained quiet.Finally, the members of the Electoral College took a pledge from Hadrat Abdur Rahman bin ‘Auf ra that he would be completely impartial, and entrusted the responsibility of making the decision to him.For three days, Hadrat Abdur Rahman bin ‘Auf ra visited every house in Medina to obtain the opinion of every man and women about the issue.All of them expressed their agreement to the Khilafat of Hadrat Usman ra.Thus, he gave his verdict in favour of Hadrat Usman ra and he became the Khalifah.

Page 84

68 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Election of Hadrat Ali ra After this, Hadrat Usman ra was martyred and the Companions ra who were present in Medina— witnessing that discord was spreading among the Muslims—persuaded Hadrat Ali ra to accept the Bai‘at of the people.On the other hand, some miscreants also rushed to Hadrat Ali ra and told him that the Islamic state was facing the risk of destruction.They pleaded that he should accept the Bai‘at of the people in order to dispel fear and to establish safety and peace.In short, he was compelled to accept the Bai‘at and he took the responsibility after declining many times.Some of the eminent Companions ra were not present in Medina, and some were forced to take the Bai‘at.It is related that Hakim bin Jablah and Malik Ashter were sent with some aides to force Hadrat Talhah ra and Hadrat Zubair ra to take the Bai‘at at the point of the sword.They brandished their swords before them and asked them to take the Bai‘at of Hadrat Ali ra or they would kill them.According to some traditions, they were brought dragging on the ground for Bai‘at.Obviously, such an expression of allegiance cannot be called Bai‘at.Further, they took the Bai‘at on the condition that Hadrat Ali ra would take revenge from the murderers of Hadrat Usman ra.However, later, when they felt that Hadrat Ali ra was not taking any prompt action, they abandoned their Bai‘at and went from Medina to Mecca.

Page 85

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 69 Declaration of Jihad by Hadrat Ayeshah ra A group from those who were involved in the murder of Hadrat Usman ra convinced Hadrat Ayeshah ra to declare Jihad to get revenge for the blood of Hadrat Usman ra.Thus, she issued a declaration of Jihad and called on the Companions ra for help.Hadrat Talhah ra and Hadrat Zubair ra joined her.As a result, the armies of Hadrat Ali ra and Hadrat Ayeshah ra , Hadrat Talhah ra , and Hadrat Zubair ra fought a battle called the Battle of Jaml.In the very beginning of the war, Hadrat Zubair ra , on hearing a prophecy of the Holy Prophet sa from Hadrat Ali ra , left the battle and swore not to fight against him.He admitted that he was wrong in his interpretation.Hadrat Talhah ra also gave the pledge of Bai‘at of Hadrat Ali ra before his demise.It is mentioned in traditions that when Hadrat Talhah ra was dying from mortal wounds, somebody passed by him, and he asked that person which group he belonged to.He told him that he belonged to Hadrat Ali’s ra group.On this, Hadrat Talhah ra put his hand in his hand and said, “Your hand is the hand of Hadrat Ali ra , and I enter into the Bai‘at of Hadrat Ali ra ”.17 In short, the differences of the Companions ra were settled at the time of the battle of Jaml, but the 17 Al-K a mil fit T a r i kh , Vol.3, p.243, by ‘Izzuddin Abul Hasan Ali bin Abul Karam Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Abdul Kar i m bin Abdul W ah id Ash-sh i b a n i , known as Ibnil Ath i r, publisher D a ru Sa dir, D a r Beirut, AH 1385, AD 1965.

Page 86

70 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH dispute of Hadrat Muawiyah ra remained unsettled, and that became the cause of the battle of S af i n.Battle of S af i n In this battle, the comrades of Hadrat Muawiyah ra made a clever move and raised the Qurans on their spearheads, and declared that they would consent to the verdict of the Quran, and for this, arbiters should be appointed.On this, the mischievous people who were involved in the conspiracy of Hadrat Usman’s ra murder, and who, just after his martyrdom, associated themselves with Hadrat Ali ra to protect themselves, started pressuring Hadrat Ali ra to appoint arbiters.Hadrat Ali ra refused vehemently, but the mischievous persons, and other weak-natured persons who fell prey to their connivance, forced Hadrat Ali ra to appoint arbiters.Hadrat ‘Amr bin Al-‘ As from the side of Hadrat Muawiyah ra , and Hadrat Abu Musa Ash‘ari from the side of Hadrat Ali ra , were appointed arbiters.The issue to be settled was the murder of Hadrat Usman ra , under the condition that the decision would be according to the Holy Quran.However, ‘Amr bin Al-‘ As and Abu Musa Ash‘ari, after consultation, decided that Hadrat Ali ra and Hadrat Muawiyah ra should be dissolved from their offices, for it was they who had put all the Muslims to trouble, and then, the Muslims should be allowed to decide freely to elect the Khalifah of their choice.They were not appointed to make a decision in this respect.

Page 87

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 71 Nevertheless, they called upon an assembly of people to announce their decision.Hadrat ‘Amr bin Al-‘ As asked Hadrat Abu Musa Ash‘ari to announce his decision first, and said that he would do the same after him.Hadrat Abu Musa announced the dismissal of Hadrat Ali ra from his office.After this, Hadrat ‘Amr bin Al-‘ As stood up and said, Abu Musa has dismissed Hadrat Ali ra from his office, and I agree with him in this respect and remove Hadrat Ali ra from Khilafat, but I do not dismiss Muawiyah, rather, I reinstate him to his office.( Hadrat ‘Amr Bin Al-‘ As himself was a very pious man, but, at this time I do not want to enter into a discussion of the reasons behind his decision.) On this, the companions of Hadrat Muawiyah ra started saying that the arbiters had given their verdict in favour of Hadrat Muawiyah ra instead of Hadrat Ali ra.However, Hadrat Ali ra refused to accept this decision, because the arbiters were not appointed for this purpose, and their decision was not based on any Quranic injunction.On this, the same hypocrite associates of Hadrat Ali ra , who had pressured him to appoint arbiters, started questioning him as to why arbiters were appointed when there could not be any arbiter in religious matters.Hadrat Ali ra replied that first of all, there was a provision in the agreement that the decision would be according to the Quran, which had not been followed, and secondly, the arbiter was appointed on their demand, and now they were questioning the authenticity of that

Page 88

72 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH appointment.They responded, “We committed a mistake, and we do cut a sorry figure, but the question is, why did you listen to us? Therefore, we have become sinners and so have you.Now, we have sought Allah’s forgiveness, so you should do the same.You should confess that whatever you did was not lawful.” Their purpose was that in the case of Hadrat Ali’s ra denial, they would separate themselves from his Bai‘at , under the pretext that since he acted against Islam, they could not remain in his Bai‘at.Even if he admitted his mistake and repented by seeking Allah’s forgiveness, his Khilafat would become null and void, because such a person who committed an immense mistake could not remain Khalifah.On hearing these arguments, Hadrat Ali ra replied, “I have not committed any mistake.The matter for which I appointed an arbiter was within the provisions of Islamic sharia.Furthermore, at the time of their appointment, I clearly mentioned that I shall accept their decision if and only if it is based on the Quran and A ha d i th.Otherwise, it would not be binding on me.As they did not follow this condition and did not give their verdict on that matter for which they were appointed, therefore, their decision is not binding on me.” However, the hypocrites did not accept the plea of Hadrat Ali ra and separated themselves from his Bai‘at.They were called the Khaw a rij (Secessionists).They made this innovation in religion, that no Khalifah is worthy of utter submission on the

Page 89

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 73 part of the people, and that all decisions should be according to the verdict of the majority of Muslims, because to honour a ruler as worthy of complete submission from the people is against this verse 18 : “There is no judge except Allah.” The Doctrine of Unelected Khilafat of Hadrat Ali ra This was the first disagreement in the matter of Khilafat.At that time, the people who were in favour of Hadrat Ali ra started refuting those objections.While doing so, the prophecies of the Holy Prophet sa about Hadrat Ali ra were also discussed in detail, and some of the miscreants stressed that debate on Khilafat was unnecessary because the Khilafat of Hadrat Ali ra was based, not on an electoral decision, but on the prophecies of the Holy Prophet sa about him.Therefore, he was the Khalifah appointed by the Holy Prophet sa without the need for any electoral decision.This is the same as if someone, while discussing me as Mu s le h Ma‘ u d [the Promised Reformer], should say that he pledges allegiance to me as Khalifah because there are prophecies of the Promised Messiah as about me, and not because my Khilafat was established through the majority vote of the 18 Al-K a mil fit T a r i kh , Vol.3, p.335, by ‘Izzuddin Abul Hasan Ali bin Abul Karam Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Abdul Kar i m bin Abdul W ah id Ash-sh i b a n i , known as Ibnil Ath i r, publisher D a ru Sa dir, D a r Beirut, AH 1385, AD 1965.

Page 90

74 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Community.The moment anyone starts thinking on these lines, he will start moving toward destruction.It is because, by doing so, the feeling for the sanctity of the system of Khilafat gives way to the idea of Im a mat of one appointed person.In short, some of the “ Gh a l i s ” 19 [extremists] presented an interpretation from the prophecies of the Holy Prophet sa that Hadrat Ali’s ra Khilafat was only due to those prophecies, and not because of any election.Gradually, they inclined more and more towards the view that Hadrat Ali ra was, in fact, an Imam by appointment.To them, the concept of Khilafat, as had been generally believed by the Muslims, was invalid.Instead, whenever there is a need, an Imam is appointed by the special command of God Almighty, and he becomes the source of guidance and direction for the people.Three Groups of Muslims in Reference to Khilafat Due to these differences concerning Khilafat, the Muslims were divided into three groups with different concepts, as following: (1) “ Khilafat is in the sense of Succession, and there should be a Successor to the Holy Prophet sa.The method of the appointment of a Khalifah is that he should be elected by the majority of the Muslims, or 19 Literally, those who exceeded the limits.(Publishers)

Page 91

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 75 in accordance with an electoral process agreed by the ummah.Such a person is appointed as Khalifah and submission to him is obligatory on Muslims.” The group holding this belief is called Sunni.(2) “Authority belongs to God.To consider a human being worthy of obedience amounts to apostasy.Decisions should be based on the opinion of the majority, and Muslims are at liberty to appoint whomsoever they desire.” Those who hold these views are referred to as Khaw a rij (Secessionists.) (3) “The people do not appoint an Am i r (leader), rather, it is God Who appoints the Am i r.He appointed Hadrat Ali ra as Imam, and after him, appointed eleven more Imams.The last Imam is still alive, but is hidden.” This group holding these beliefs is referred to as Shia.Among them, there is a sect that believes in the continuous necessity of a living and visible Imam.They are referred to as Ism a ‘ i liyyah Shia.Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya This is the history of the Khilafat immediately after the Holy Prophet sa.Now I turn to the Khilafat which was established after the Promised Messiah as.The Ahmadiyya Jam a ‘at was in the same state of mind during the lifetime of the Promised Messiah as as were the Companions ra of the Holy Prophet sa during his lifetime.All of us believed that the Promised Messiah as would not die as yet.As a result, we never thought, even for a moment, about what would

Page 92

76 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH happen after his demise.I, at that time, was not a child.I was a young man, I used to write articles, and was editor of a magazine.I say on oath that I never thought, for a minute, or even for a second, that the Promised Messiah as would die, even though, in the last years of his life, there were a series of revelations about his demise.In his last days, such revelations increased manifold.Despite the fact that there were revelations and visions specifying the date etc.of the demise of the Promised Messiah as , and we used to read Al-Wa s iyyat (The Will), we still presumed that these things would probably happen after two centuries.Thus, the thought of what would happen after the demise of the Promised Messiah as never crossed our minds.Since we had assumed that he would not die in our lifetime, it was difficult for us to accept the reality of his demise when it happened.I clearly remember that after his demise, he was given a bath and was wrapped in the shroud.As is common, that one’s clothes and moustache etc.move with the blowing of the wind, some of the companions would come running, saying that the Promised Messiah as was alive, and his clothes or moustache was moving.Some said that they saw his shroud moving.Anyhow, the body of the Promised Messiah as was brought to Qadian and was placed inside a house in a garden.Around eight or nine o’clock, Khawaja Kamaluddin arrived in the garden, took me aside, and asked me, “Miy a ń ! Have you thought of what would happen

Page 93

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 77 after the demise of the Promised Messiah as ?” I replied to him, “Something should happen, but as to what it should be, I cannot say anything”.He said to me, “In my opinion, we should give Bai‘at to Hadrat Maulaw i Sahib ra ”.At that time, due to my age and lack of knowledge, I said, “the Promised Messiah as did not mention anywhere that we should take the Bai‘at of someone after him, so why should we take the Bai‘at of Hadrat Maulaw i Sahib ra ”? (Though it was mentioned in Al-Wa s iyyat , it did not occur to me at that time).On this, he started arguing that the Community would be destroyed if the Bai‘at was not taken at the hand of one person.He added that after the demise of the Holy Prophet sa , the people took the Bai‘at of Hadrat Abu Bakr ra , so the same should be done now, and there is no one more suitable in the Jam a ‘at than Hadrat Maulaw i Sahib.He also told me that Maulaw i Muhammad Ali Sahib had the same viewpoint.Finally, the whole Community unanimously requested Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra to accept the Bai‘at of the people.Then, all the people gathered in the garden and Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra addressed them and said, “I have no wish for Im a mat (leadership), and in my opinion, the Bai‘at of someone else should be taken”.For this purpose, he first proposed my name, then the name of our maternal grandfather, Mir Nasir Nawab Sahib, then the name of our brother-in-law, Nawab Muhammad Ali Khan Sahib, and then the names of

Page 94

78 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH some other people, but we all unanimously told him that he himself was entitled to the post of Khilafat.Then, everyone took Bai‘at on his hand.The Authority of the Khalifah About fifteen to twenty days after the Bai‘at , Maulaw i Muhammad Ali Sahib met me and said, “Miy a ń ! Have you ever considered how the organization of the Community would function”? I replied, “What is the point of pondering over this issue, for we have taken Bai‘at at the hand of Hadrat Maulaw i Sahib ra ”.On this, he said, “This is the relationship between a ‘ P i r ’ (spiritual mentor) and ‘ Mur i d ’ (follower of a ‘spiritual mentor’), and the question remains, how will the organization of our Jam a ‘at operate”? I said, “I do not see this matter worthy of discussion, as we have taken the Bai‘at of one person, and he can better explain which type of system should be established in the Jam a ‘at, and there is no need for us to interfere in this matter”.He stopped his argumentation, but added that the point required further consideration.Some Questions Presented by M i r Muhammad Is ha q Sahib ra to Hadrat Khal i fatul Mas i h I ra After a few days, when questions about the authority of the Khalifah, and whether the Khalifah or Sadr Anjuman Ahmadiyya has ultimate authority

Page 95

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 79 gained greater attention of people, M i r Muhammad Is ha q Sahib ra submitted some questions in writing to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra and requested him to elaborate on them.Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra sent those questions to the other chapters of the Jam a ‘at.He fixed a date for the assembly of the representatives of various Jam a ‘ats so that a decision could be made in this respect after consultation.I was unaware of these events until I saw a dream.A Dream I saw that there was a huge house, a part of which was complete, and the other was incomplete.On the side which was incomplete, the rails had been laid, but the bricks had yet to be placed and covered with soil.On that side of the building, four or five of us were standing, and M i r Muhammad Is ha q was among them.Suddenly, we saw some hay on those rails, and M i r Muhammad Is ha q immediately brought out a matchstick from a match box and said, “I wish to burn this hay”.I asked him not to do so, but he did not stop.Then I told him strongly that it would one day be burnt, but the time had not yet come, and then I turned my face away.After a while, I heard some noise and turned back.I saw that M i r Muhammad Is ha q was trying to light matchsticks, one by one, in order to set the pile of hay on fire by striking them against the box, but to no avail.On seeing this, I rushed to him, but before I could reach there, a match had become lit

Page 96

80 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH and the hay was set on fire.I jumped into the fire and extinguished it quickly, but the tips of a few rails were burnt away in the meantime.I wrote my dream to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra.He looked at me and said that the dream had already been fulfilled.I asked him for details.He said that M i r Muhammad Is ha q had given him some questions in writing which he had sent to other chapters of the Jam a ‘at outside Qadian, and he thought that it would give way to a grave crisis.Even then, I could not find out the type of questions put forth by M i r Muhammad Is ha q.Afterward, I inquired from my friends about those questions, and they told me the questions were related to the subject of Khilafat.Those questions created a great disturbance in the Jam a ‘at, and answers to those questions started coming in from all sides.At that time, the way these people [those against Khilafat] tried to deceive the Jam a ‘at was evident from the fact that they continuously tried to convince the Jam a ‘at that Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra held the same view as they did.They would say that they were grateful to God that this question was raised in the lifetime of a very selfless person, and had it been raised later, it would have created a great turmoil.Some of them would say that it was good that many Companions ra of the Promised Messiah as were still alive, and that they were about to decide that the true Successor of the Promised Messiah as was the Anjuman.In short, they tried their best to convince the Jam a ‘at that (God

Page 97

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 81 forbid) Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra was in complete agreement with their views.However, at that time, there was a great commotion in the Jam a ‘at, and it seemed as if there would be a dangerous revolt against the Khalifah of that time.Assembly of Representatives of Outside Jam a ‘ats in Qadian At last, the day fixed by Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra for this purpose arrived.The representatives of the Jam a ‘ats from outside were asked to assemble in Qadian.On that day, I was strolling in my veranda waiting for the Fajr Prayer and the people were waiting in the mosque for the arrival of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra.I heard the voice of Sheikh Rahmatullah Sahib, who was saying with great excitement, “By God! The Jam a ‘at is being ruined for the sake of a boy”.At first, I assumed that he was probably referring to M i r Muhammad Is ha q, but then I heard Sheikh Rahmatullah saying, “How can the Jam a ‘at agree to enter into the servitude of a boy”? This surprised me more, and I started wondering that M i r Muhammad Is ha q had only asked a few questions, which had nothing to do with the Jam a ‘at being in slavery or not.Despite the fact that I pondered over this matter intensely, I could not comprehend who that child could be.After the Fajr Prayer, I related this whole incident to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra and asked him who that child

Page 98

82 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH might be.Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra looked at me with a smile and said, “Don’t you know? You are that child”.Perhaps Sheikh Rahmatullah assumed that I had dictated all those questions which had caused the uproar in the Jam a ‘at.Address of Hadrat Khal i fatul Mas i h I ra on the Issue of Khilafat After this, Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra arrived for his address.I had already seen a dream about that speech.I saw that in a Jalsa, Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra was delivering a speech on the issue of Khilafat.It seemed as if an army had attacked him.At that time I also arrived at the Jalsa [in the dream] and stood on his right side and said, “ H u du r! Do not be worried.We are at your service and are ready to sacrifice our lives for your well-being.Someone can come near you only after killing all of us, and no one can harm you in any way in our presence.” I had narrated this dream to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra.When I came to attend the Jalsa, this dream slipped out of my mind and I sat on the left side of H u du r.On this, he said, “Miy a ń ! Move to my right side”.He further added, “Do you know why I have asked you to sit on my right side”? I expressed my unawareness.Then he reminded me of my dream and said: “It is due to your dream that I have asked you to sit on my right side”.When he came forward to make his speech, he did not stand on the proposed location.Rather, he stood

Page 99

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 83 on that side of the Mosque which had been built by the Promised Messiah as.He expressed his anger, and said to the people, “Your actions have caused me so much pain that I have not stood in that part of the Mosque which was built by you, but have preferred to stand in the portion built by my mentor [the Promised Messiah as ]”.After this, he explained the issue of Khilafat in light of the Holy Quran and A ha d i th.He said, “people usually say that the job of Khalifah is only to lead the S al a t , the funeral prayers, and to administer the marriage vows of people, and that it has nothing to do with the organization [of the Jam a ‘at].This is sheer impertinence.These functions could be carried out even by a mullah , and there is no need of a Khalifah for this.” The people who heard that speech know very well that it was so full of grief and passion that the listeners were virtually choked due to excessive crying.Renewal of the Bai‘at of Khawaja Kamaluddin and Maulaw i Muhammad Ali After the speech, H u du r ra asked Khawaja Kamaluddin, Maulaw i Muhammad Ali, and Sheikh Yaqub Ali to take Bai‘at again, and they did accordingly.I did not realize that their Bai‘at was taken due to their offence, and so I also advanced my hand for.However, Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra pushed my hand back and said, “You have nothing to do with this.They have committed an offence, so they

Page 100

84 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH are renewing the Bai‘at.What crime have you committed?” The purpose of renewing the Bai‘at of Sheikh Yaqub Ali was that he had arranged a meeting in which he condemned those people who had humiliated the system of Khilafat.Though it was an act of goodness, Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra said, “Since he was not assigned this job, he had no right to convene a meeting on his own”.Thus, Bai‘at was renewed by these three persons and they repented before all the gathering.After the Jalsa was over and the people went to their homes, the dissidents started making plans against Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra more actively.Maulaw i Muhammad Ali Sahib started saying that he had been humiliated to such an extent as he could no longer live in Qadian.Doctor Khalifah Rashiduddin (deceased) was very close to Maulaw i Muhammad Ali in those days.One day, he came to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra in great distress.By chance, I was also there.As soon as he arrived, he exclaimed, “ H u du r! Please do something as the situation has become quite grave”.Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra asked what had happened.He said, “Maulaw i Muhammad Ali is saying that he has been greatly humiliated here and he cannot live in Qadian under any condition.H u du r! You must do something to persuade Maulaw i Muhammad Ali to stay lest he should depart.” Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra said, “Doctor Sahib! Go and tell Maulaw i Sahib that

Page 101

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 85 tomorrow is still far, if he wants to depart, then he should do so today”.Doctor Sahib, who was under the impression that a crisis would ensue if Maulaw i Muhammad Ali left Qadian, was shocked to hear this reply.He said, “ H u du r! It will give way to a grave crisis”.Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra replied, “I do not care for this, and I am a Khalifah appointed by God.I am not going to yield to such threats.” On hearing this reply, Maulaw i Muhammad Ali Sahib was silenced, and he never expressed any intention of leaving Qadian during the life of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra.However, they kept on scheming behind the scene and tried to create disorder in the Jam a ‘at through various intrigues.These are long stories and cannot be narrated in detail at this time.Proposal to Publish an Announcement during Illness of Hadrat Khal i fatul Mas i h I ra When Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra was sick in his terminal illness, we were all naturally restless.We were all awaiting the next day with much concern.As there was no direct supervision of the people due to his illness, and the debate on controversial issues was growing, I wrote an announcement, the gist of which was that discussions on controversial issues should be stopped due to the illness of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra and should not be resumed until he recovers completely and is able to oversee such discussions personally.After writing this announcement, I gave it

Page 102

86 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH to Mirza Khuda Bukhsh and asked him to take it to Maulaw i Muhammad Ali for his signature; that as a result, the people who hold the same point of view as I do and those who are in favour of the viewpoint presented by Maulaw i Sahib will abstain from such discussions and thus any disturbance would be avoided.This happened one or two days before the demise of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra.Instead of signing the notice, Maulaw i Muhammad Ali sent a reply that the public is unaware of the differences in the Jam a ‘at, and publication of any such announcement would give the enemies a chance to laugh at us.He further said that in his opinion, it was better to arrange a gathering in which he and I should deliver speeches to convince people not to discuss such issues at all.Thus, a gathering was arranged in Masjid N u r.Maulaw i Muhammad Ali Sahib wanted me to speak first, so whatever I had written in the announcement, I mentioned in my speech and stressed upon unity.After my speech, Maulaw i Muhammad Ali stood up, and instead of giving any advice, he started scolding the people, saying that they were foolish to make accusations against him and Khawaja Sahib for no reason, and should desist from them.He was very harsh in his criticism.As a result, instead of fostering unity, the meeting flared disunity, and people developed feelings of resentment against them.

Page 103

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 87 Attempt to Save the Jam a ‘at from Disunity As the physical condition of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra was deteriorating, everyone was concerned what would happen after him.For me, the only question was that of the unity of the Jam a ‘at.I was not concerned from which side the Khalifah would be.Although, apparently, the companions of Maulaw i Muhammad Ali believed in the Prophethood of the Promised Messiah as , yet, they believed that they could not enter into the Jam a ‘at of a person whose beliefs were different from theirs, because that would destroy Ahmadiyyat.To the contrary, I started convincing my friends that if there is even a small chance of discord after the demise of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra , we should pledge Bai‘at to anyone from those people in order to save the Jam a ‘at from dissension.Thus, I convinced my friends that if the only bone of contentions were that the Khalifah should be from their faction, then we should be mentally prepared to pledge Bai‘at at the hand of one of them.Demise of Hadrat Khal i fatul Mas i h I ra On March 13th, 1914, Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra passed away.After leading the Jum‘ah (Friday) Prayer, I was on my way in the car of Nawab Muhammad Ali Khan when I received the news of his demise.In this way, another dream of mine was fulfilled, in which I had seen that I was travelling in a

Page 104

88 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH car towards my house, and someone informed me of the demise of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra.I had interpreted my dream that I would be on a journey at the time of demise of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra.However, God the Almighty fulfilled it in a different way.When I arrived home after leading the Jum‘ah Prayer, the servant of Nawab Muhammad Ali Khan brought his message for me that he was waiting for me outside in his car.I drove with him in his car, and on the way, I received news of the demise of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra.Request for Prayers After the demise of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra , telegrams were sent to all chapters of Jam a ‘at.I asked the members of the Jam a ‘at to pray constantly, observe Tahajjud prayer, and those who can, observe a fast the next day that Allah, the Almighty may guide our Jam a ‘at to the right path in this time of crisis and save us from taking any step in a wrong direction.Unanimous Decision of the Family of the Promised Messiah as The same day, I gathered all of my relatives and asked them for their viewpoint on this controversy.They insisted that the Khalifah should be one who has the same beliefs that they have.However, I pleaded with them: “The real need of the hour is unity.There is no doubt that the Khalifah is a religious requisite,

Page 105

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 89 but dissension in the Jam a ‘at is not good either.So if they agree with us that a Khalifah needs to be selected, then it would be pertinent to decide by common vote.In case of any dispute, Khalifah should be someone who is considered impartial by both sides.If this is not acceptable to them, then Bai‘at should be pledged to a person from their side, even if it be Maulaw i Muhammad Ali himself.” It was very hard for me to convince them, but on my persistence, the whole of our family agreed to it.My Meeting with Maulaw i Muhammad Ali After this, I met with Maulaw i Muhammad Ali and told him that I wanted to discuss some issues with him.Then we walked towards the woods.Maulaw i Muhammad Ali said to me, “We should not take any decision hurriedly after the demise of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih , because there is dissension in the Jam a ‘at and some disturbance is in the offing.Therefore, we should work amicably after negotiating thoroughly.” I told him that people would gather in large numbers by the next day.Therefore, we should discuss it tomorrow.Maulaw i Sahib again said, “There is no rush and we should give the Jam a ‘at four to five months to ponder over this issue.Then we should take action according to what is decided.” I said to him, “What if a dissention breaks out in the Jam a ‘at? Who will be responsible? There will not be a leader and a guide for the Jam a ‘at, and in that case,

Page 106

90 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH who will resolve the disputes of the people, and to whom will they turn for their complaints? There never is a fixed time for any disturbance.It is possible that it may happen tonight.As a result, we should dismiss the proposition that the Khalifah should not be elected but after five months.However, we should discuss who the Khalifah should be.” I even assured Maulaw i Muhammad Ali that I, along with my fellows, were ready to pledge Bai‘at to any person from his side.Maulaw i Sahib argued that it was a complicated matter and asked me to ponder over it before its discussion the next day.Then we departed.A Tract of Maulaw i Muhammad Ali That night when I woke up for Tahajjud Prayer, Bh a ‘ i Abdur Rahman Qadiani gave me a tract and told me that it was distributed among those Ahmadis who were coming from outside Qadian.When I read it, I found that it was written by Maulaw i Muhammad Ali.In it, he had stressed that Khilafat should not be continued any longer.He added that he took the Bai‘at of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra as a spiritual mentor, “ P i r ”, and not as a Khalifah.It was also written that there could be an Am i r of the Jam a ‘at, but his obedience should not be mandatory on the Jam a ‘at, and such an Am i r should not declare non- Ahmadis as kafir [infidel], and he should be above forty years of age.The real purpose behind these conditions was that if a Khalifah was to be made, it

Page 107

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 91 should be Maulaw i Muhammad Ali, because he was more than forty years of age at that time and he did not call non-Ahmadis kafir.The Consent of Ninety Percent of the Members of the Jam a ‘at on Khilafat by Election When I read that tract and apprehended the upcoming crisis, I immersed myself in prayers and awoke the others in the room.I informed them of the tract and enjoined them to pray.Thus, all of us prayed and observed a fast.The majority of the Ahmadis of Qadian participated in prayers and observed a fast.In the morning, some people, realizing that Maulaw i Muhammad Ali had not only deceived them, but also had degraded the wills of the Promised Messiah as and Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra circulated a paper among people to ascertain the trend of the Jam a ‘at.In that paper, it was asked if the Jam a ‘at wanted to have a similar Khalifah as Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra , and if they had pledged the Bai‘at to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra in the position of a Khalifah or merely as a spiritual mentor or an ascetic.We learnt from the signatures of people that more than ninety percent of the Jam a ‘at agreed that there should be a Khalifah and his functions should be the same as Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra had.

Page 108

92 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Second Round of Discussions with Maulaw i Muhammad Ali At about ten o’clock, I received a message from Maulaw i Muhammad Ali saying that he wanted to further discuss the matter of the previous day.Therefore, I called for him and we began talking.I emphasized that the issue of Khilafat should not be discussed, because by entering into the Bai‘at of a Khalifah he had accepted the principle that Khilafat would continue in the Jam a ‘at after the Promised Messiah as.The only debatable issue was who the Khalifah should be.He stuck to his view and said again and again that there should not be any hurry in this matter and the Jam a ‘at should be allowed to think over it for four to five months.On this, my reply was the same as I had already given him.Moreover, I asked him what would happen if the dispute remained unresolved after four or five months.If it was to be decided by the majority vote of the Jam a ‘at, then it should be done right now.When it appeared as if this discussion would never end, I asked Maulaw i Muhammad Ali to seek advice from the people gathered outside.On this, Maulaw i Sahib abruptly said, “Miy a ń Sahib! Do you know whom they will elect as Khalifah”? I said, “It is not the concern of the people, as I myself have decided to enter into the Bai‘at of any person from your side, and all of my fellows are also ready to do so”.However, he stuck to his point that it was in my knowledge as to who would

Page 109

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 93 be elected by the people as Khalifah.On this I got up disappointed, because the members of the Jam a ‘at who were outside were so enthusiastic that they were about to break open the doors and were continuously saying, “We cannot wait any more as the Jam a ‘at is without any leader and you people are not resolving the issues”.Finally, I said to Maulaw i Sahib, “We deem it necessary that there should be a Khalifah.So you can do as you please, but we are going to elect a Khalifah after seeking advice from the people.” Then I got up and the meeting ended.Establishment of the Second Khilafat After ‘ Asr prayer, Nawab Muhammad Ali Khan read the will of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra and requested the people to nominate his Successor.All of them unanimously proposed my name, and thus, the second Khilafat was established.I heard later that Maulaw i Muhammad Ali also stood up at that time to say something, but someone pulled his coat and asked him to sit down.All this happened according to the will of Allah, the Almighty.He appointed whomsoever He willed as the Khalifah.Real Meaning of Some Sayings of Hadrat Khal i fatul Mas i h I ra These people used to convey a different image of themselves to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra.Therefore,

Page 110

94 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH in the lectures of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra , it was sometimes said that: the Lahori people should not be mistrusted; the presumption that they are against Khilafat is not true.This is because they repeatedly conveyed to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra that whatever was thought about them was false and they were the upholders of Khilafat from the depths of their hearts.See how their falsehood has now been exposed.They vehemently deny the very things, which they used to affirm on oath.In short, after accepting the Khilafat of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra , they, like the secessionists, started chanting: 20 i.e.“Final decision belongs to Allah alone; consultation should be the basis of decisions”.Nevertheless, Allah, the Almighty caused them to fail and the Jam a ‘at gathered around me.Some people also left thereafter, for their own interests, and began the same chant.Allah, the Almighty has kept them unsuccessful so far, and we pray that Allah, the Almighty save the Jam a ‘at from their mischief in the future also.20 H u du r has here given the implied meanings of what Khaw a rij said.Actual words given in Al-K a mil fit T a r i kh are and in Vol.3, pp.334, 326, by ‘Izzuddin Abul Hasan Ali bin Abul Karam Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Abdul Kar i m bin Abdul W ah id Ash-sh i b a n i , known as Ibnil Ath i r, publisher D a ru Sa dir, D a r Beirut, AH 1385, AD 1965.

Page 111

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 95 Quranic Injunctions about Khilafat That was the history of Khilafat.Now we will see the guidance concerning this matter in the Holy Qur a n and A ha d i th.Has Islam ordained any organization to be established after the Holy Prophet sa or not? If so, what is it? When we reflect upon this matter, the first fundamental injunction we find in the Holy Quran is:

Page 112

96 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH (Al-Nis a ’, 4:52-60) Allah, the Almighty says: People of the Book are forsaking the truth by practicing falsehood, deceit, and infidelity.Whenever a comparison of believers and non-believers is made, they say that the believers are evil people and that the infidels are better than they are.The same is the case of those who stopped paying allegiance to Khilafat {dissentients}.In their enmity with us, they consider other Muslims better than us, and even perform their S al a t behind them.Whenever something comes up, they say, These Muslims are better than Ahmadis.Allah, the Almighty tells them: As you keep believers away and bring non- believers closer to you, so this day Allah says to you, move away from us.

Page 113

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 97 People merely curse verbally.Whenever they want to curse someone they say, “Curse be upon you”.However, when Allah curses someone, then for him there is no helper.Look at the Jews.Allah, the Almighty cursed them, and how disgraceful is their condition.Despite the fact that they have great wealth and property, various nations rise in different periods of time and continuously disgrace and debase them.The same is the case with dissentients.At the time when I accepted Bai‘at , there were about two thousand persons gathered in Qadian, and all of them took my Bai‘at except fifty to sixty people.Nevertheless, Paigh a m-e- S ul h wrote: “About half of the Jam a ‘at members present, did not take the Bai‘at and left the mosque lamenting.” 21 Then, the same paper, Paigh a m-e- S ul h , declared about me: “So far, hardly a twentieth of the community has accepted him as Khalifah.” 22 In their opinion, five percent of people were with us and ninety five percent were with them.However, now the situation is entirely different, as they have written repeatedly that the majority of the Jam a ‘at is with Khilafat.Actually, they have now reversed the 21 Paigh a m-e- S ul h , Lahore, March 22, 1914.22 Paigh a m-e- S ul h , Lahore, May 5, 1914.

Page 114

98 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH logic of their arguments.Earlier, they argued, as an evidence of their truthfulness, that the majority of Jam a ‘at was with them.However, when God Almighty turned us into the majority, they have started saying that consensus of the majority of any Jam a ‘at on some issue is not proof of its truthfulness, for it is clearly mentioned in the Holy Quran, “And most of them are perfidious.” (Al-Taubah, 9:8) As long as they were in the majority, their argument was that the majority of the believers of a Prophet could not be erring.When we became the majority, they declared us as an example of , “most of them are perfidious”.However, they have admitted that their helpers have disappeared, and this is what is mentioned in the above quoted Quranic verse.Then Allah, the Almighty says: These people are lamenting with jealousy that they could not get authority and power.However, if they had been given authority over the whole world, they would not have given even a trifle to the people.refers to the hollow at the back of date-stone.This means that they are greedy by nature.The same stinginess—asking “why has a boy been appointed as

Page 115

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 99 Khalifah”?—has consumed the dissentients [ Paigh a m i s ].Allah, the Almighty further says: You, who are avaricious by nature, say, why they received rule and power.Ponder over the fact! Who did get authority and sovereignty before? Were not the descendants of Ibr a h i m as (Abraham) given the sovereignty before? If so, then of what use is your jealousy? God gave authority and sovereignty to the descendants of Ibr a h i m as (Abraham) before, and He will give authority and sovereignty to the descendants of Ibr a h i m as (Abraham) again.We have given rule to the descendants of Ibr a h i m as (Abraham) before.Those who recognized their government were honoured, and those who denied it were punished.It is mentioned that the government that will be given to the descendants of Ibr a h i m as (Abraham) will be a source of mercy and blessing for the people.As long as they remain under this blessing and do not try to flee from this government, they will remain in comfort and peace.However, if they deny it, then Allah, the Almighty will put them to such a calamity

Page 116

100 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH from which there will be no way out, and they will suffer forever.It is a part of human nature that when one becomes used to a punishment, the pain is not felt as severely as it was in the beginning.A king can be cruel, but after some time, his cruelty is not felt as it was in the beginning, and the king himself gets somewhat lenient.However, when another cruel king replaces him, then his cruelty feels very painful.Thus, it is mentioned that if you reject this prize, then you will be ruled by cruel kings and their governments will be replaced rapidly so that you may receive the punishment of your deeds: However, those who believe and do good deeds shall be blessed with the most dignified rule, and in those gardens, they will have their spouses with them and they will have a long period of comfort and peace.In fact, there is a prediction of the establishment of an Islamic government in these verses, and it is made clear that Jews, who oppose it, will suffer great loss and will remain in torment forever.However, Allah,

Page 117

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 101 the Almighty will vouchsafe heavenly life on those believers who will acknowledge this blessing and their spouses will also be with them.An Unfair Objection of Enemies of Islam on the phrase “Pure Spouses” Some ignorant enemies of Islam raise objection on the words of , “pure spouses” that Islam presents paradise as a house of ill-fame because it mentions the presence of women in it, and says that there will also be women along with men in paradise.These ignorant people do not realize that the wickedness of their souls shows it to them as such.Otherwise, Islam says that just as men are entitled to paradise, so are women, and that paradise is made by the cooperation of man and woman.Man alone cannot make a paradise.Thus, look at this part [of the Holy Quran] in which there is a mention of worldly governments.While alluding to those governments, Allah, the Almighty makes it clear that the participation of women is also necessary for the formation of that paradise which cannot be called complete without their presence.Thus, man and woman both create paradise together.If they do not strive collectively, paradise can never be materialized, neither in this world nor in the Hereafter.Both men and women have to strive to create a heaven on this earth and so will it be necessary in the Hereafter.If they do not make a combined effort in building that

Page 118

102 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH paradise, they will never get the blessing of “dwelling there forever”.Cooperation of Man and Woman is imperative for the creation of Paradise of this World and of the Hereafter If people had comprehended this point and allowed the participation of women in national life by understanding its importance and value, then the condition of Islam along with that of the world would not have been how it looks now.This world would have been a paradise for human beings.They would have attained the paradise in this world.The paradise of people, who get it without women, is not real, for the characteristic of a paradise is that it should be a dwelling paradise, and without women, it cannot be achieved.On one side, man makes a paradise, and on the other, woman banishes his offspring from it, for without the proper training of offspring, the eternal paradise of a nation cannot be achieved.Women play a major role in training the children.There will always be a need for the cooperation and equal participation of a woman with man for the establishment of a paradise.When a woman is educated and righteous, has love for religion and a great urge to act upon the commands of God and His Messenger, then it will be impossible that she should not try to create the same passion in her children.Thus, where the duty of men is to prepare the paradise

Page 119

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 103 of today, the duty of women is to prepare the paradise of tomorrow.It is the job of men to establish paradise, and that of women is to produce new gardeners for it.If on one hand, man is busy in building paradise, and on the other hand, woman is busy in her work, or if on one hand, man protects it and on the other hand, woman produces new gardeners for its safety, then no one can destroy that paradise.Who can damage the unity, honour, and glory of that nation? However, if ever women are stopped from participating in the development of this paradise, then there would be no future owners and protectors of that paradise, and the training of the predecessors would stop.When the training of the predecessors ends and successors are not raised, the paradise can never survive.It is inevitable that Satan would destroy it.A Magnificent Point The Holy Quran has taught us a magnificent point, that for the establishment of national life, both men and women should strive collectively.Rest assured that you cannot establish paradise until you allow women to participate in the work.If you make the whole world to abide by S al a t by your efforts, then it will be of little benefit when the mothers of the off spring of these worshippers will be busy in making them turn away from S al a t.It will be as if you make a paradise and women continue destroying it.There was a relative of ours who was an ardent opponent of

Page 120

104 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH religion.He always ridiculed the commands of God and His Messenger.Once he fell ill and came to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra for treatment.During the talk, Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra asked, “Mirza Sahib, do you ever feel envious of the people who come to your neighbourhood for S al a t five times a day? Did it ever cross your mind that you should also perform S al a t ?” On hearing this, he burst into laughter and said, “Maulaw i Sahib I have been right-minded since my childhood.Even in those days whenever I saw people bowing their heads down and lifting their hips up, I would laugh at their foolishness.” Now consider, when mothers start producing such “right-minded” children, can the paradise prepared with the sermons of preachers last even for a day? Or take any issue—literary, religious, political, or economic; unless you ensure the participation of woman in it, she will keep your children completely ignorant of these issues, and your knowledge will end with you.In short, Allah, the Almighty has said in these verses that it is a universal truth that man cannot get an eternal paradise without woman.Those who have called Islamic paradise a brothel have only exposed the evil in their own natures.Alluding towards paradise, Allah, the Almighty says in the Holy Quran: (Al-Ra h m a n, 55:47)

Page 121

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 105 There are two Gardens for those people who have the fear of God in their hearts.At another place it is said: (Al-Ra h m a n, 55:63) For them, there will be two Gardens in this world and two in the next world, for one garden will be planted by man and one by woman.They are called , [dual form for Jannat ].It is also called Jannat— paradise in the singular form.The import is that there are two paradises from one perspective, and it is one from another perspective.They are two, because one is the outcome of man’s efforts and the other is a result of woman’s effort.But it is also one, because it is a common paradise of both man and woman.Then Allah, the Almighty says that these two Gardens are not only in the next world but there are also two gardens in this world.Out of these two, the creation of one is assigned to man and that of the other to woman.Thus, the believers get two Gardens in this world and two in the Hereafter, i.e.they get two types of victories: physical and spiritual, which leave an eternal impact.Allah, the Almighty points toward the same when He says: (Al-Kahf, 18:47)

Page 122

106 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH People who desire to attain worldly gains from their wealth, get a benefit for the time being.However, actions of those people who perform deeds to win the approval of God the Almighty become eternal.They not only get the immediate reward but also set in motion a perpetual stream of rewards from it.Explanation of Hadith that “Paradise is Under the Feet of Mothers” The A ha d i th that paradise is under the feet of your mothers also indicates that the better training of a mother will breed righteous offspring and the rewards attained by the father will become eternal.But if the mother does not educate the children well, then accomplishments of father will terminate with himself and the world would be deprived of the gardens of eternity.The same theme is also expressed in the Hadith, narrated by Muawiyah bin Jahmah.He relates that a person came to the Holy Prophet sa and sought his permission for joining a certain Jihad.He asked whether his mother was alive.The man replied in affirmative.The Holy Prophet sa advised him: 23 “Go and stay with her as paradise is under her feet.” 23 Sunan Nasa‘ i, Kit a b-ul-Jih a d, B a bur-Rukh s ati fit Takhallufi liman lah u W a lidah by Abu Abdur Ra h m a n Ahmad bin Shu‘aib An-Nasa‘ i , Hadith No.3104, Edition Fifth, AH 1420, Publisher, D a rul Ma‘rifah, Beirut.

Page 123

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 107 It appears that there were some shortcomings in him.The Holy Prophet sa thought that his shortcomings would be removed by the excellent training of his mother provided he lived with her.It is possible that there might be excessive zeal and passion in him and the Holy Prophet sa considered that if he went to Jihad then he would become more emotional by temperament.If he remained with his mother then he will have to suppress his emotions in his obedience to her, and in this way, he might be reformed.There definitely was a shortcoming in him due to which the Holy Prophet sa considered the training of his mother better for him than participation in Jihad.Therefore, he directed him to remain in the service of his mother.This Hadith reveals that paradise cannot be achieved without the cooperation of woman.In short, the presence of woman is not only necessary in the next paradise but also in the worldly paradise because no nation can succeed without it.The Command to Entrust the Trusts to the Deserving Then Allah, the Almighty says that the reward and blessing which you get will require an organization for its establishment.With obstinacy and dispersion, a nation cannot achieve this reward.Therefore, Allah tells you the way that you have to adopt for the establishment of this paradise: (Al-Nis a ’, 4:59)

Page 124

108 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH “Verily, Allah commands you to make over the trusts to those entitled to them.” The possessions of worldly governments, wealth and property are trusts of God the Almighty vested with you.Thus, Allah, the Almighty command you to give the trusts to those entitled to them, i.e.elect those leaders who are capable of holding this trust.Moreover: Allah, the Almighty commands those who are entrusted with these trusts to render justice and equity.Thus, both sides are given commands.On one side, the people are told: “O people! Allah, the Almighty commands you to entrust the authorities of government to those people who are the most competent to exercise these powers and for running the affairs of the government”.Then it is said, “O administrators! Allah commands you to treat the subjects with justice and equity, and never allow injustice to come near you”.i.e.This command of Allah, the Almighty is full of wisdom, and He always commands you to do good things, and He is All-Hearing and All-Seeing.In this way, after an organization is established, Allah, the Almighty admonishes to pay attention to the dignity of religion, which was the cause of the establishment of an organization, i.e.compliance with

Page 125

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 109 the commands related to national acts of worship and national obligations.Worship and obligations are personal as well as national.For personal worship and obligations there is no need for an organization and they have nothing to do with the election of the leaders.By saying: “Obey Allah and obey the Messenger” after giving the injunction about the election of Am i rs, it is indicated that the purpose of the organization was to perform the national worship and obligations properly.After the organization is established, you should be engaged in activities to fulfill its purpose.Do not sit in your homes after establishing organization and put the entire burden on the Am i r.The election of the Am i rs is not to do the work but to get the work done.Therefore, when an Am i r is elected, you should devote yourself to carry out the national responsibilities.Therefore, it is said: (Al-Nis a ’, 4:60) That is, when you have elected the leaders then remember that there will be three authorities ruling over you.First the rule of Allah, second the rule of His Messenger, third the rule of the Am i r.However, it is added:

Page 126

110 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH As the Am i rs will make various plans to fulfil these obligations so you are obligated to obey them to carry out those plans.If you, sometime, differ with them then refer the case to Allah and His Messenger, i.e.settle them in the light of the principles laid down by Allah and His Messenger, and do not follow your personal desires.It is the best and very rewarding in the end for you.Here Allah, the Almighty has stated it clearly that when you hand over the power of government to the most competent persons then you will have to obey their commands along with the commands of Allah and His Messenger.This is because the objectives of establishing a government have been stated first.Allah, the Almighty says that it is necessary for your progress to hand over your affairs to one person.Nevertheless, remember to prefer competency during the election lest you should cast your vote to a person who has benefited you, or is a close relative or has friendly relations with you.It usually happens in the world that at the time of vote, preference is given to one who is closer to us or is a relative or a friend and the competency of a person for the job is not considered.Thus, Allah, the Almighty made it clear that same should not be in Islamic election that you

Page 127

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 111 merely elect a person who is your father or your son or your brother, rather entrust this responsibility to the most competent person whether you have relations with him or not.After this, it is mentioned that when you have elected the leaders then they will surely make plans for the progress of Islam.Therefore, We command you to obey their orders whether you fully understand them or not.However, if at any stage you differ with them then refer it to the command of God and His Messenger.Those outside the Khilafat are overjoyed and say that the problem is solved as it is evidently mentioned that it is not necessary to obey Khalifah.They conclude that if the Khulaf a ’ proceed according to sharia, people should obey them, and if not, they should be rejected.I shall, God willing, address this issue later.Quranic Principles of Islamic Organization Right now, I want to say that the following principles have been described as general directives related to Islamic organization in the Holy Quran: (1) National organization is a trust because it affects not just one person but the whole nation.Therefore, while making a decision you should prefer national interest and benefits to your personal desires.(2) An organization is required for the fulfilment of this trust; people cannot execute it on individual

Page 128

112 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH level.Therefore, there should be an executive for its performance.(3) The nation should elect these executives.(4) During the election, it should be kept in mind that the elected persons are competent to fulfil these trusts.Apart from it, no other element should be taken into consideration.(5) Those who are assigned to such positions will not be the master of national affairs but the executives, because it is said: i.e.that they will not inherit the ownership from their forefathers but should be competent for the service.These commands are not purely for religious organization.It is evident from the words that these are the universal commands valid for both types of organization religious and worldly.Hence, Islam does not consider kingship a part of its organization, but it accepts a system based on the electoral process and stresses that all individuals should obey the people who are duly assigned to these functions.Does Islam Acknowledge a Certain Type of Pure Worldly Government? If it is asked whether Islam acknowledges a certain type of pure worldly government or not? The answer to it is that in the presence of all the means available for its support, Islam does not endorse any purely worldly organization.But it also does not ignore the

Page 129

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 113 prevailing circumstances.It is possible that the ideal organization which Islam envisions may not be enforceable under certain circumstances.In such a state of affairs there may arise a need for some worldly organizations.For instance, if the majority of Muslims comes under the rule of a government of the non-believers, and are deprived of their liberty, independence and collective power, then those countries where Islam is in power, cannot establish a combined religious and worldly organization because the majority of Muslims cannot follow it.In such constrained circumstances, there is a provision for the establishment of purely worldly organization, which will follow the principles of Islam, mentioned before.Interpretation of Purely Worldly Organization Purely worldly organization does not mean that it will not enforce those rules of Islamic organization which deal with the government.It, in fact, means that its rules will not be religiously binding for the whole Islamic world, because neither the majority of the Muslims will be able to abide by them due to political circumstances nor will the majority of Muslims be involved in the establishment of this organization.Therefore, in such circumstances it would be permissible to establish a separate purely religious organization.It would not only be lawful but also necessary that a separate purely religious organization

Page 130

114 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH be established which is affiliated to that Islamic organization which, in turn, should be linked not with any government but with a spiritual organization of Islam so that the other governments do not interfere.Since it would be a spiritual organization and will not meddle with the affairs of the government, such an organization would be able to unite the Muslims living in other countries and Islam would be saved from disarray.If the Muslims had acted upon the theme of this verse, they would have surely been saved from the degradation in the last period.A Regrettable Mistake of Muslims Muslims committed a mistake during the period of their decline.They presumed that since they could not establish an organization in the whole world to address both the religious and the secular, there was no scope for them to establish a purely religious organization.They also presumed that these two organizations could not be separated under any circumstances.When establishment of one organization became impossible, they abandoned the other too.It was the duty of the Muslims that after the institution of Khilafat came to an end, they should have made a centre for their national endeavours including the propagation of Islam in the whole world.Under this centre, they could have established the preaching missions in the whole world for the improvement of the morals of the people, teaching the

Page 131

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 115 Quran, and to convert the non-Muslims to Islam, and strive collectively for their common national interests.However, they presumed that there was no scope of the establishment of any religious organization.As a result, they continued to decline day by day.If, after their failure to establish an organization comprising religious and worldly affairs, they had established a purely religious organization, they would have saved themselves from a great misfortune.With such an arrangement, Islam could have been dominant in the whole world, and Christianity could have been totally wiped out.But they made the mistake that if they could not establish such an organization in the whole world based on religious and worldly sections, then there was no chance of establishing a purely religious organization.Therefore, when they lost one organization, they abandoned the other one.Second Mistake Their second mistake was to draw the inference that election was necessary only for the organization which covers the worldly and religious affairs of all the Muslims.The fact is that in these verses God Almighty has clearly mentioned that election is as necessary in a purely worldly organization as it is in the combined organization of religious and worldly affairs.If they were not able to do more, the Muslims could have set up an electoral system for choosing the king.It would have saved them from great

Page 132

116 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH destruction.If they had comprehended this point the hereditary kingship that prevailed among the Muslims and caused the destruction of the Islamic government, would have been avoided.Moreover, they would have become the first and true pioneers of the development of democracy.Establishment of Purely Religious Organization when Differences Prevent Setting up an All-encompassing System I have stated that the cited verse provides the need of the establishment of purely religious organization in a situation when there are controversies in the secular arrangements.This is because all the Muslims are addressed in this verse, and they are directed to obey “ those in authority among them ” at all times.There is no restriction of any period to obey those in authority, Rather, there is a command to obey them in every situation and in every age.If somebody says that the command to obey “those in authority” is for the time being, then it will have to be assumed that obedience to Allah and His Prophet are also temporary, because God has first commanded to “obey Allah and obey His messenger”.Since the command to obey God and His Messenger is for all times and for every age therefore the command to obey “the authorities” should be for every situation and for every age.In fact, by this verse, Allah, the Almighty has drawn the attention of Muslims to the

Page 133

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 117 fact that compliance with an organization is binding for them at all times.Just like the other commandments, if compliance of one part is not possible, the other parts are not automatically cancelled.One who cannot participate in Jihad, cannot be excused from Prayer.One who cannot perform Ablution, cannot be excused from bowing and prostration.He who cannot perform S al a t by standing, cannot be excused of performing his S al a t by sitting or by laying or by nodding.Similarly, even if there cannot be a political organization for the whole Islamic world, yet Muslims cannot be free from the compliance of other parts of the obedience of “those in authority”.Just as if someone goes to Hajj and cannot perform Sa‘ i in between Safa and Marwah, he is not excused from it.Rather, it will be necessary for him to fulfil this obligation by sitting on the back of some other person.Therefore, the Muslims committed a great mistake when they inferred that, as one organization had become impracticable for them so they were also freed of other organization.On the contrary, the establishment of purely religious organization does not become impossible when Muslims are divided in several political entities as has been proved by the advent of the Promised Messiah as.If people ask us why we do not cut the hand of a thief then we can tell them that it is not in our power but those matter in which we have control we consider it our foremost duty to establish an Islamic organization

Page 134

118 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH within our own community.If the Muslims had realized that to obey “those in authority” was binding at all times and had they established organization in other parts leaving the impracticable parts of the obedience to “those in authority” aside, they would have fulfilled this commandment and Islam would have been saved from the decline that it has reached.Perhaps it was the will of Allah, the Almighty that this part of Islamic organization be implemented through the Jam a ‘at of the Promised Messiah as and the community called [ others of them] may achieve this excellence because there should have been virtue reserved for us.The Companions ra were granted the excellence that they established a combined religious and worldly organization based on Islamic principles.However, Allah, the Almighty directed our attention to the establishment of an organization, which is purely religious.It is as if Companions ra followed one part of this verse and we followed the other, so we also joined them.In short, the principles of the establishment of Islamic organization are mentioned in this verse.This command is given: (i) Islamic organization should be based on election.(ii) The Muslims should remain obedient to [those among them who are vested with authority].

Page 135

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 119 It is regrettable that the Muslims forgot these two principles during the time of their decline.Even where it was possible for them, they did not maintain electoral process.And in situations which were not fully under their control, they did not keep the Islamic Unity by obeying the organization of “those who are vested with” authority even in areas where they did have control.They involved themselves in useless debates that they should obey only “those in authority”.In this way, they ignored the real spirit of this commandment.If they had fulfilled that part which was in their power, they would not have been accountable for things that were beyond their power.Clarification of an Objection on “Authorities among You ” S omeone may raise an objection that the Ahmadiyya Muslim Community teaches that “the authorities” that are non-Muslim are also included in these words, “authorities among you”, and according to this verse the obedience of non-Muslim authorities is also required.However, the meaning given above cannot be applied to non-Muslims.It is true.However, this meaning is based upon the part of the words, “the authorities” i.e.when we say that non- Muslims are also included in “the authorities” then we do not take the whole portion into consideration, but we deduce it from one part of the verse.But we cannot ignore the meaning of this part in conjunction

Page 136

120 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH with all the verses.No doubt, in worldly affairs the obedience of every “authority” is obligatory, but with it we cannot ignore that in every age the obedience of “those among them [Muslims] who are vested with authority” is obligatory for them.Interpretation of “Refer to Allah and His Messenger in situations of Disagreement with Authority among You” Now I come to the topic that I had promised to explain before.Some people have raised the objection that in case of disagreement with “authorities” Allah, the Almighty says, “refer it to Allah and His Messenger”; it indicates that their obedience is not obligatory but in controversial situation, we have to look at what the command of Allah and His Messenger is.The answer to this question is that this interpretation makes the whole verse meaningless because every person considers his own viewpoint as correct.If this meaning of verse is adopted, then there cannot be any obedience.After all what will the command be that would be unanimously acknowledged by all the people as the command of God and His Messenger? There is no doubt that difference of opinion is always present.If everybody has the authority to declare a command to be against the teachings of God and His Messenger then in that situation Khalifah is left to rule upon his own self.Particularly in the present age, it is the condition that

Page 137

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 121 followers are few and the self-proclaimed authorities in interpretation abound.When everybody considers himself a great mind, Khalifah while sitting on his mat will order the people to do such and such thing and the people will ask him first to prove the command from the Holy Quran and A ha d i th , and then they will obey, otherwise not.It is evident that there is no religious matter that is unanimously believed by the whole world.There is always a debatable point in every matter.There is a famous story that an illiterate person was fond of attending the company of learned people.As he had no knowledge of religion, wherever he went the people would throw him out.Once he told his friend that he was fond of attending the meetings of Ulema, but the people did not let him do so.What should he do? He advised him to wear a long robe and turban.The people would consider him a great scholar from his appearance, and they would not stop him from attending the meetings of Ulema.After entering a meeting, if somebody asks about something, he should tell him that it was a controversial issue.Some have written this and others opposite of it.As there is disagreement in most of the matters, no one would realize that he knows nothing.Therefore, he wore a long robe and a large turban, took a staff in his hand and started attending the meetings of Ulema.In the meetings, he would sit with his head bowed down.The people would seek his opinion on the topic under discussion.He would nod and say that it was useless

Page 138

122 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH to argue on that topic.The jurists of Islam greatly differed on it.Some Ulema had written as is told by this scholar and some Ulema had written so as is told by that scholar.The people thought that he was a well-read person, so they agreed with his viewpoint and would leave the dispute to talk on something else.It continued for sometime, and he was greatly honoured in the meetings of Ulema.One day it so happened that a discussion started on the topic that the time is very bad and even the educated people are denying God and ask for the proof of His existence.On this as per tradition, the people asked him to say something.He said it was useless to argue, some Ulema had written that there was God and some wrote otherwise.On hearing this people came to know of his ignorance and he lost his reputation.They expelled him from the meeting.To sum up, differences are rampant in the world.Therefore, if the verse: is taken to mean that whenever anybody differs with Khalifah about some command issued by him, he must ignore the Khalifah under the pretext that his command is against the command of God and His Messenger.In such circumstances, Khalifah will be unable to fulfil his obligations.This is not a rational approach.Some people of our Jam a ‘at have erred in comprehending the true meaning of this verse.If they

Page 139

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 123 had comprehended the true meaning, they would never have erred.The Verse “ Those who are in authority among You” is Applicable to Both the Worldly Authorities and Khulaf a ’-e- R a shid i n What are the true meanings? To know them it should be kept in mind that this verse is all-inclusive, and it includes pure worldly authorities and Khulaf a ’- e-R a shid i n as well.Therefore, this verse is not only related to pure religious Khulaf a ’ but is also concerned with worldly authorities.Now keeping it in mind that this verse, as meaning is concerned, is all inclusive and it includes both the pure worldly authorities and Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n , bear this in your mind that there are separate commands of the Holy Quran and the Holy Prophet sa about them.There are separate commands of Islamic sharia for pure worldly authorities, and separate for Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n.So when God says that “if you differ in saying anything among yourselves, refer it to Allah and His Messenger”, it does not mean that when you differ with authorities then you start interpreting the command of God and His Messenger according to your wishes.It means this universal command applies to both Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n and worldly authorities.So in case of difference with them, look what type of authorities they are.If they are Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n

Page 140

124 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH then follow the course of action laid down by Allah, the Almighty about Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n.If the authorities are worldly then act upon those commands which Allah, the Almighty and His Messenger have given about them.Separate Commands for the Two Types of Authorities Now we see whether Allah and His Messenger have given separate commands for the two types of authorities or not.If this is so then what are they? We see that the Holy Prophet sa has given two different commands for two types of authorities.As Abadah bin Samat ra relates: 24 24 Muslim, Kit a b-ul-Im a rati, Babo wuj u bi T a ‘atil umar a’ i f i Ghairi Ma‘ s iyatin, Hadith No.4874.Muslim, Kit a b-ul-Im a rati, Babo wuj u bi T a ‘atil umar a’ i f i Ghairi Ma‘ s iyatin, Hadith No.4877, by Abul Husain Muslim bin H ajj a j bin Muslim Al-Qushair i An-N i s a b u r i , publisher, D a rul Jail, Beirut and D a rul A f a q Al-Jad i dah, Beirut.

Page 141

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 125 “We took the Bai‘at of the Holy Prophet sa on the conditions that we will always obey the rulers whether it is convenient for us or hard and whether our heart intends to obey their commands or not, whether they give our rights to someone else, even then we’ll obey them.Similarly, there was another condition of our Bai‘at that we shall not dispute with a person to whom we entrust the government considering him fit for it.We shall not indulge in debate with him why he issued one command instead of the other one.It is possible that those authorities sometime may give a command against the religion.In that case, we had the instruction to inform them of the reality truthfully, and should not be afraid of any censure for the sake of the religion of God.” In another tradition it is mentioned, “We had the instruction from the Holy Prophet sa not to involve in any sort of dispute with those whom we have entrusted the job after considering them entitled for the government.But when you see an open infidelity and treachery from them, while the clear commands are in favour of your standpoint, then it is your duty to decline to obey them in that religious matter, and do what you are commanded by God.Similarly, it is mentioned in another Hadith: Hadrat ‘Auf bin Malik al-Ashjaey ra narrates that the Holy Prophet sa said:

Page 142

126 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 25 “Your best rulers are those whom you love and they love you.You send Dur u d on them and pray for their progress and they, in return, do the same.The worst rulers are those with whom you have malice and they are malicious with you.You curse them and they curse you.” The narrator mentioned that the Companions asked: “O Prophet of Allah! When such rulers are thrust upon us then why should we not dethrone them by challenging them”? The Holy Prophet sa said, “No, not at all until they put any restriction upon S al a t and Fast, and forbid you from worshipping Allah, the Almighty, you should not stop obeying them.Listen! when somebody rules on you and you see that he is disobeying Allah, the Almighty in some matters 25 Muslim, Kit a b-ul-Im a rat, B a bo Khiy a ril-A’immati wa Shir a rihim , by Abul Husain Muslim bin Hajj a j bin Muslim Al-Qushairy An-N i s a b u ry, publisher, D a rul Jail, Beirut and D a rul A f a q Al-Jad i dah, Beirut.

Page 143

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 127 then nurture hatred in your hearts but do not rebel.” In another Hadith , there is an additional command that in case they commit clear infidelity then you can rebel against them.The Command to Follow Always Sunnah of Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n There is another Hadith narrated by Irb a z bin S a riyah ra.26 He said, “One day the Holy Prophet sa led the morning S al a t , and after the S al a t he gave a 26 Muslim, Kit a b-ul-Im a rat, B a bo Khiy a ril-A’immati wa Shir a rihim , by Abul Husain Muslim bin Hajj a j bin Muslim Al-Qushairy An-N i s a b u ry, publisher, D a rul Jail, Beirut and D a rul A f a q Al-Jad i dah, Beirut.

Page 144

128 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH sermon.The sermon was so moving that our tears started falling and the hearts shivering.On this, a person stood up and said, ‘O Messenger of Allah! It indicates that this is a farewell sermon.You should give us some advice’.He said, ‘I advise you to adopt the righteousness of Allah, the Almighty and be submissive and obedient in your way of life, even if a Negro slave is made ruler on you.The people, who will live after me, will see great dispute among the people.Thus, for that time I advise you that you should adopt the sunnah of mine and that of Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n after me.You should strictly follow that sunnah and should stick to it as strongly as something is held by teeth.Similarly stick to that sunnah and never leave this path that is mine or that of my Khulaf a ’-e- R a shid i n.And save yourself from the innovations because every new thing which is against my sunnah and that of Khulaf a ’-e- R a shid i n will be an innovation in religion which will lead to destruction.’” From these two references it is proved that the Holy Prophet sa described two kinds of authorities : one worldly and the other religious and Islamic.The command of obedience is for worldly authorities, but simultaneously there is a reason of disobedience on case of their clear infidelity.In such a situation, provided there is a solid proof of it, and not a guess,

Page 145

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 129 there is not only permission but also a command to go out of their obedience.Some Muslim Ulema like Hadrat Mahyyuddin Ibn-e-Arabi has been so cautious in such matters that he said that in such situation only separation is permissible and not revolt.But there are religious and Islamic authorities, on whom we are not made judge, but they are made judge upon ummah; whatever they do is binding upon you and their obedience is as necessary as that of command of the Holy Prophet sa.So rulers are of two types: one who are worldly and about whom there is possibility that they might commit an infidelity.For them it is commanded to continue obeying them.Verily when they commit a clear infidelity then separate yourself from them.But other rulers are those who cannot commit a mistake.For them there is a directive to always follow their sunnah, and to never turn away from their path.But in case of a doubt whether your beliefs are true or not then compare your beliefs with those of Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n.If they corroborate, then consider yourself on the right path, and if not then consider yourself on the wrong path.Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n are a Model for the Ummah In fact, Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n are an example from whom other people can assess whether their steps are on straight footing or not.If the weight of two kilograms is on one side of the scale, and the other

Page 146

130 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH holds radishes and carrots, everyone will judge the weight of the vegetables against the two kilos.No one will throw away the weight as defective if they feel that there is a shortage of five to seven radishes.Instead, he will consider the vegetables to be short in weight.Similarly, the Holy Prophet sa did not say that you should judge the steps of Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n and see whether they make sense to you; nor did he say that you should judge how they compare with the commands of God and His Messenger.Instead, it is said that if a doubt arises about your own self whether your steps correspond with the will of God and His Messenger, then see what the Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n have stated about them.If your steps correspond with their viewpoint then consider them correct, but if not, consider your steps to be incorrect.So the matters which are to be judged against the commands of God and His Messenger are those that I have mentioned before, namely the rulers with whom you differ.But judge what type of rulers they are, worldly rulers or the Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n? If they are worldly rulers then obey them as far as you can.However, if they issue an order against the clear command of God then it is your duty to warn them of their mistake.Try to bring them towards the right path, and tell them that they are on the wrong path.If they commit a clear infidelity—as for example if they prohibit the performance of prayers or the observance of fast—then you have the right to disobey their orders and to tell them that you will continue

Page 147

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 131 performing prayers and observing fast no matter what they may say or do.But if those ( authorities ) are Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n, then beware for they cannot commit a mistake.What they do will be according to the will of Allah, the Almighty, Who guides them towards that path which leads close to Himself.So instead of judging them, make them your judge, and do not become counted among those who differ with Allah, the Almighty by differing with them.Discussion of A yat-e-Istikhl a f I will now take up the commandments about the pure religious organization in Islam.In s u rah Al-N u r, Allah, the Almighty says: (Al-N u r, 24:55-57)

Page 148

132 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH In these verses the commandment is first given for obeying Allah and His Messenger.Then a promise is made to the Muslims that if they are perfect in their obedience, He will make them leaders.Like the earlier nations, He would establish for them a Khalifah on the earth.At that time, it would be their duty to establish Prayer and pay Zakat, and also to obey the Messenger of God.By establishing faith through the Khalifah, they would also be following the Messenger.This is the point also stressed in: 27 In other words, at such times the obedience to the Messenger would consist of following the Khalifah in propagating and strengthening Islam.Performance of Prayer, in its True Sense, is not Possible without Khilafat So in these verses Allah, the Almighty has first promised Khilafat to the Muslims.Then they are commanded to perform Prayer and pay Zakat.In this way, Allah, the Almighty has indicated that performance of Prayer in the true sense is not possible without Khilafat, as is the case of Zakat.There was a regular system of Zakat in the age of the Holy Prophet sa.When he died, Hadrat Abu Bakr ra took 27 Bukh a r i Kit a b-ul-Jih a d was-siyar, B a bo Yuk a talo min war a’ il Im a mi wa Yuttaka bih i , by Muhammad bin Ism a ’ i l Abu Abdullah Al-Bukh a r i Al-Ju‘f i , publisher, D a r ibni Kath i r Al-Yam a mah, Beirut.

Page 149

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 133 charge of Khilafat.The majority of Arabs refused to pay Zakat.They were of the view that it was a command only during the period of the Holy Prophet sa , but not for the period of later Khulaf a ’.Hadrat Abu Bakr ra refused to accept their demand and was determined to fight with those who even refused to pay Zakat equivalent to the string that was used to tie the knee of a camel, and vowed that he would not stop fighting till he received Zakat from them the same way they used to pay in the period of the Holy Prophet sa.He succeeded in his campaign, and the system of Zakat again started functioning, which continued in the periods of the later Khulaf a ’.When Khilafat was terminated the Muslim world was left with no system for the recovery of Zakat.This is what Allah, the Almighty has mentioned in this verse.If there is no Khilafat, the Muslims cannot comply with the command of paying Zakat.The reason for it is that Zakat is a basic pillar of Islamic teachings.It is taken from the rich and distributed among the poor.It can only be possible where a regular organization exists.If an individual distributes Zakat to a few poor people then how can such good results come of it which are possible only in the presence of a system that ensures the utilization of the total collection of Zakat for the welfare and progress of all indigent people? So the system of Zakat requires the supervision of Khilafat.Similarly the performance of Prayer is not possible without Khilafat.The reason is that the best part of

Page 150

134 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH S al a t is the Jum‘ah Prayer with a sermon, in which the national needs are put before the people.If there is no Khilafat then how can the Jam a ‘ats of small towns come to know the situation of what is going on, say, in China or Japan? What type of sacrifices Islam is demanding from them? When there is a centre and a Khalifah, liable to be obeyed by all Muslims, he gets reports of what is happening from all the parts of the globe.In this way, he is able to tell the people what type of sacrifice is required and which services are needed.This is why it is the belief of Hanafis that performance of Jum‘ah Prayer is not lawful when there is no Sultan amongst the Muslims.The philosophy behind this view is the same which I have mentioned before.The same is the case for the Prayer of Eids.It is proved from the sunnah of the Holy Prophet sa that he always delivered a sermon according to the needs of the nation.When there is no system of Khilafat then what knowledge of national needs can one have individually? How can he express them in his sermon? But it is quite possible that due to ignorance of facts he may himself remain in confusion which may then lead to confusion in others.Once I read that forty to fifty years ago a person went to Beekaneer for a tour.It was, by chance, Friday and he went to perform Prayer in a mosque.He noted that the Imam first recited the usual sermon in Persian and then asked the people present in mosque to pray by raising their hands that Allah, the Almighty

Page 151

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 135 might keep Am i r-ul-Mu‘min i n, Jahangir, the Emperor, safe and sound.The poor fellow did not know that Jahangir, the Emperor, had expired long ago and that now the English were the rulers.So Jum‘ah, the best part of Prayer, can only be performed properly where there is a system of Khilafat in Muslims.You can see that as there is a system in us, my sermons are always concerned with the important needs of the time.It is a blessing of Allah, the Almighty.Some non-Ahmadis are so deeply affected by my sermons, that they deem them to be revealed.A famous leader of Muslims regularly reads my sermons; and stated that these not only guide Muslims religiously but also politically.The real task of the leader is to guide the people.Such leadership can only be provided by the person who gets news from various parts of the world, and has knowledge of ongoing circumstances.The knowledge of such circumstances cannot be acquired only from the newspapers because they also contain many false reports, and moreover, some events are not fully reported.As our missionaries are present in various parts of the world along with the members of our Jam a ‘at, who are spread in all corners of the world, I receive true reports from them, and by utilizing them I can guide the Jam a ‘at properly.To sum up, the performance of Prayer is not possible without the Khalifah.

Page 152

136 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH True Obedience to the Messenger is also not Possible without Khilafat Similarly obedience to the Messenger mentioned in “obey Allah and obey His Messenger” is not possible without the Khalifah, because the real purpose behind obedience to the Messenger is to string all in the thread of unity.In a way, the Companions ra performed Prayer and Muslims of today also do the same these days.The Companions ra fasted as do the Muslims now.The Companions ra also performed Hajj and the Muslims do the same now.Then what is the difference between Companions ra of the Holy Prophet sa and Muslims of these days? The difference is that at that time they performed Prayer when the Holy Prophet sa informed them that it was the time of Prayer as was the case with Fasting and Hajj.Though they submitted to the commands of Allah, the Almighty by participating in Prayer, Fast, and Hajj, all their acts were dominated by the spirit of obedience to the Holy Prophet sa.The benefit of this obedience was that when the Holy Prophet sa gave any command, the Companions ra promptly followed it.But this spirit of obedience is not present in the Muslims of these days.The Muslims perform Prayer, observe the Fast, and perform the Hajj but there is no sense of submission in them because the sense of submission cannot be created without the system of Khilafat.So when there is Khilafat there is obedience to the Messenger.

Page 153

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 137 Obedience to the Messenger does not just mean the performance of Prayer, Fast and Hajj; for these are all commandments of God.The submission to the Messenger is that when he says that now is the time to put more emphasis on Prayer, then all the people start asserting more emphasis upon Prayer.When he says that now the need of Zakat is growing, so be ready to offer contributions, then the people start focusing on contributing more towards Zakat.When he says that now is time to sacrifice your lives or the countries where you live, then they come forward to sacrifice their lives and their countries.Therefore, these three things are totally attached with Khilafat.Allah, the Almighty says that your Prayers will keep losing their value and determination when there is no Khilafat, and so is the case of Zakat, for the sense of submission to the Messenger will keep departing from your hearts.As our Jam a ‘at is accustomed to the system and our members have a sense of submission, even if the members of our Jam a ‘at were placed in the age of the Holy Prophet sa they would have started obeying just as the Companions ra did.But if you take the case of a non-Ahmadi and envision his condition in the age of the Holy Prophet sa , you will see him stumbling at every step.He may say that: “Wait a moment, I have not comprehended the command yet”.It is known about a Pathan who said, “Khu! The Prayer of Muhammad sa has been infringed; it is mentioned in Qud u r i that Prayer is infringed by a

Page 154

138 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH small movement” and he will start denying some other religious matter.But if you take an Ahmadi then he will instantly realize that he is not in some unknown place.Just as a tool of a machine quickly fits at its place, so he will also fit there, and immediately will become a Companion of the Holy Prophet sa.Summary of the Subject Matter of A yat-e- Istikhl a f The summary of the A yat-e-Istikhl a f is: What is mentioned is actually a promise.The promise is only with the people as long as they comply with faith and acts of goodness.The dissenters always assert that in this verse the promise of Khilafat is not with the person but with the people and I accept their point.I also affirm that this promise is for the people.And Allah, the Almighty mentions that as long as they will comply with faith and acts of goodness the promise from Him will remain effective.The purpose of this promise is that, a.Muslims should get the same awards which the previous nations have availed as evident in, (Al-N u r, 24:56) “As He made Successors from among those who were before them.”

Page 155

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 139 b.The second purpose of this promise is the dignity of the religion.c.The third purpose of it is to guide the Muslims from their state of fear to that of security.d.The fourth purpose of it is to dispel infidelity and the establishment of service to Allah, the Almighty.At the end the words, (Al-N u r, 24:56) “Whoso is ungrateful after that, they will be the rebellious.” The emphasis is again put on the promise.The attention is, however, drawn to the warning, (Ibr a h i m, 14:8) “And if you are ungrateful, My punishment is severe indeed.” Since Khilafat is a favour, remember it that the people who are ungrateful will be counted as rebellious.This verse is a great testimony in favour of Khilafat-e-R a shidah, and it is mentioned that the system of Khilafat will be established among the Muslims and it will carry the support of Allah, the Almighty as is evident from:

Page 156

140 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH (Al-N u r, 24:56) “Allah has promised to those among you who believe and do good works that He will surely make them Successors in the earth.” and: (Al-N u r, 24:56) “He will surely establish for them their religion which He has chosen for them.” He will help the Muslims inherit abundantly of the rewards granted to previous nations.Signs of True Khulaf a ’ In this verse, the signs of true Khulaf a ’ are also mentioned.This can help in distinguishing the true Khalifah from a false one.They are as follows: A Khalifah is appointed by God and no human hand is involved in appointing him, nor does he himself desire it, nor does he become Khalifah by some plan.Sometimes, a person whose appointment is considered impossible is appointed as Khalifah.The words: (Al-N u r, 24:56)

Page 157

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 141 “Allah has promised to those among you who believe and do good works.” indicate that God alone appoints the Khalifah because only He who made the promise can fulfil that promise.Some people make the mistake of thinking that this promise means that people appoint a Khalifah of their own choice, and that God will declare him to be His choice.But it is like the way of a teacher that I had who used to tell a boy that he was happy with, that “whatever money you are holding in your pocket is an award from me”.This mistaken notion amounts to rendering the promise of Khilafat to the same level; as if God says “Go ahead and appoint someone your Khalifah by your choice but consider him appointed by Me”.If this is the case then what is the prize? And how is this treatment distinctive that Allah, the Almighty has a special love with the Jam a ‘at which believes and does good works.One who makes a promise also fulfils it.Is it so that one who makes a promise has someone else fulfil it? The first thing mentioned in this verse is the advent of a Khalifah from Allah, the Almighty.All evidence points toward this.No one can become the Khalifah by his own desires.Similarly nobody can become the Khalifah by some connivance.The Khalifah is he whom God desires to be.Indeed, he will often become a Khalifah when the world considers it impossible.The second sign of a truthful Khalifah given is that Allah, the Almighty helps him in a manner similar to

Page 158

142 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH the way He helps the Prophets because it is mentioned that: (Al-N u r, 24:56) “He made them Successors from among those who were before them”.Such Khulaf a ’ deserve the same help that We gave to the previous Khulaf a ’.We know that the previous Khilafats were of two types: First Khilafat-e- Nubuwwat (the Khulaf a ’ that are Prophets as ) as was the Khilafat of Hadrat Adam as about whom it is mentioned: (Al-Baqarah, 2:31) “I am about to place a Khalifah in the earth.” Hadrat Adam as was not elected nor was he a worldly king.Allah, the Almighty made a promise with angels and made him a Khalifah in the earth on His Own.Those who denied him were punished.Similarly, it is mentioned about Prophet David as : ( Sa d, 38:27)

Page 159

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 143 “O’ David We have made you a Khalifah in the earth, (Prophet David was a Prophet of Allah, the Almighty.Therefore, it indicates that here Khilafat means Khilafat-e-Nubuwwat) so judge the people with justice.And follow not the desires of the people lest it should lead you astray from the right path.Surely those who go astray will have a severe punishment from Allah, the Almighty.Therefore, do not follow their desires but do the same to which God guides you.” In these verses the same subject is mentioned as is in the words, ( A l-e-‘Imr a n, 3:160) “And when thou art determined, then put your trust in Allah.” Some persons have mistaken the meaning of: They think that in this verse Prophet David is admonished not to follow the vain and immoral desires of people.This is not the meaning of this verse.It actually means that: “sometimes the majority of the people will advise you to do something.But it is not your job to yield before the majority, but to see whether what they say is useful or not.If it is useful then accept it and if it is not useful then reject it even

Page 160

144 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH if it is presented by the majority, especially in a situation when it is sinful.” Earlier Khilafats were either Khilafats of Prophethood or Khilafats of Kingship The earlier Khilafats were either Khilafats of Prophethood as were the Khilafats of Prophet Adam as and Prophet David as or were the Khilafats of governments as it is said: (Al-A‘r a f, 7:70) “Remember the time when God made you Khulaf a ’ after the people of N uh (Noah) and increased you abundantly in your structure and gave you abundant offspring.You should remember the favours of Allah, the Almighty so that you may prosper.” The word Khulaf a ’ in this verse only means worldly kings, and favour means governments.Allah, the Almighty admonishes them to perform their obligations with justice in the earth, otherwise He would destroy them.The mention of this favour to Jews is made in these words:

Page 161

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 145 (AL-M a ‘idah, 5:21) “And remember when Moses said to his people, ‘O my people, call to mind Allah’s favour upon you when He appointed Prophets among you and made you kings, and gave you what He gave not to any other among the peoples’.” We made them Khulaf a ’ in two ways.By virtue of they were given Khilafat of Prophethood and by virtue of they were granted the Khilafat of kingship.Therefore, the earlier Khilafats were of two types either they were Khilafat of Prophethood or Khilafat of kingship.Allah, the Almighty says to Muslims: “He will surely make them Successors in the earth as He made Successors from among those who were before them.” It is thereby deduced that they will get the favours like those of earlier Khulaf a ’.Allah, the Almighty will treat the Muslims in the same way He treated the previous Prophets.

Page 162

146 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Why has the Resemblance been Ascribed to Khilafat of Prophethood and Not the Khilafat of Kingship? If anybody says that the Khilafat of kingship is also mentioned for earlier people, so why is the present discussion focusing only Khilafat of Prophethood and ignoring the Khilafat of kingship? This verse reveals that though there is a promise of kingdoms for the Muslims in other verses yet, here, only religious favours are being mentioned.To be specific, in this verse Allah, the Almighty mentions, “He will surely establish for them their religion which he has chosen for them.” God establishes the religion of His Khulaf a ’ in the world.This is not the rule for the kings of the world and nor is their religion ever established by Allah, the Almighty.But this rule is only for spiritual Khulaf a ’.So this verse shows that here the resemblance of Khilafat is with the Khilafat of Prophethood and not Khilafat of kingship.Similarly it is mentioned, “He will surely give them in exchange security and peace after their fear”.This sign also cannot be assigned to the worldly kings in any way because if they are the masters of the

Page 163

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 147 kingdoms at one time, they are also seen begging at the other when they are separated from their thrones.There is no promise of changing their fear into security; indeed in the hours of severe danger sometimes they are totally disheartened under adverse circumstances.Then it is mentioned, “Those Khulaf a ’ will worship Me, and will not associate partners with Me.” So they will worship Me alone and would be strong opponents of polytheism.But worldly kings sometimes commit polytheism, and the Holy Prophet sa has said that it is possible that they may even commit an open blasphemy; so then how can they be considered the subject of this verse? The fourth argument to prove that these Khulaf a ’ are not to be worldly kings is that Allah, the Almighty says: “The people who deny these Khulaf a ’ will become rebellious.” Now tell me, can it be considered rebellious to disobey someone who is capable of open blasphemy? The decree of rebellion can only be invoked when he disobeys the spiritual Khulaf a ’.

Page 164

148 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH In summary, the four reasons mentioned in the verse prove that Khilafat in this verse does not refer to the Khilafat of kingship.So when God says that, “We shall favour those Khulaf a ’ as We have favoured the previous ones,” It means that just as the Prophets, who were before them, have been favoured by Allah, the Almighty, so shall these Khulaf a ’ be favoured.Therefore, in this verse the resemblance is towards Khilafat of Prophethood, and not with the Khilafat of kingship.Promise of Khilafat Conditional upon Faith and Acts of Goodness The third thing that can be deduced from this verse is that the promise with the ummah of the Holy Prophet sa only applies until the time the ummah remains established upon faith and acts of goodness.When it deviates from faith and acts of goodness, Allah, the Almighty will withdraw His promise.Thereby, a great difference is mentioned between Prophethood and Khilafat.Prophethood is established when the world is filled with evils and chaos.As it is mentioned: (Al-R u m, 30:42) “Corruption has appeared on land and sea.”

Page 165

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 149 People forget Allah, the Almighty and turn away from divine commands.They are captivated by error and perversion, and darkness covers every part of the land.This then causes Allah, the Almighty to send a Messenger who reforms the people.He brings down the light of faith from heavens, and puts the people to whom the Messenger is sent on the path of truthful religion.But Khilafat comes at a time when there is a majority of believers and performers of good works in the nation.As such, Prophethood comes at the extermination of faith and acts of goodness, while Khilafat comes at a time when people are on the path of faith and doing acts of goodness.This is the reason that Khilafat starts when Prophethood ends, because faith and acts of goodness are placed on sound footing by Prophethood.So as the majority of people are those who are on the path of faith and righteousness, Allah, the Almighty blesses them with Khilafat.In the middle period when the world is neither totally devoid of pious people nor full of evil then it is deprived of both the favours because neither the illness is so severe as to demand a Prophet, nor is the moral health so perfect as to justify a Khalifah to lead them in good deeds.

Page 166

150 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Loss of Khilafat is Due to the Shortcoming of a Jam a ‘at, not because of a Shortcoming in the Khalifah It is evident from this command that the loss of Khilafat is not due to any shortcoming of a Khalifah but due to a shortcoming of a Jam a ‘at.The loss of Khilafat does not prove the sin of a Khalifah, but it is a proof of the sin of a Jam a ‘at, because it is a clear promise of Allah, the Almighty that He will continue Khilafat while the majority is on the path of faith and doing acts of goodness.When change comes and most of the people deviate from the path of faith and acts of goodness, then Allah, the Almighty will say, “you have become evil doers, so I withdraw My blessing from you”.(Though if God desires, He may continue making Khulaf a ’ in a Jam a ‘at for some time as an extra favour).When a person says that a Khalifah has become worthless, he, in other words, declares that the Jam a ‘at has been deprived of a majority of believers and performers of good works.It is the promise of God that as long as a Jam a ‘at is firm in faith and acts of goodness Khulaf a ’ will continue coming, but when they lose their steadfastness, the Khulaf a ’ will cease to come—so there is no chance of corruption of a Khalifah.However, there is a chance that the Jam a ‘at be deprived of people of faith and of performing acts of goodness.As the Khalifah cannot be corrupted—only the Jam a ‘at can be—when a person declares before the world that the Khalifah of

Page 167

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 151 the Ahmadiyya Muslim Jam a ‘at has become corrupt, then he will have to admit that at this time despite there still being a large number of Companions ra of the Promised Messiah as present among us and the age being full of the machinations of the Antichrist, this tree [Ahmadiyyat] which was destined to prosper and spread throughout the world, has been attacked by Satan and has been deprived of its faith; and not just that, but even its potential for acts of goodness have been crushed.According to such a claimant, the Khalifah has become corrupt, and the Holy Quran reveals that true Khulaf a ’ will continue to come as long as the majority of Jam a ‘at remains firm on faith and acts of goodness.The denial of Khilafat is not just a denial of the Khalifah but it also amounts to saying that the Jam a ‘at has been deprived of faith and acts of goodness.Sign of the Establishment of Religion The fourth sign of a Khalifah enunciated by Allah, the Almighty is that their religious commands and ideas are spread in the world by Allah, the Almighty.Therefore, He says: Allah, the Almighty will glorify their religion and in spite of adverse circumstances, He will establish it in the world.

Page 168

152 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH This is a great proof of true Khilafat.When we consider it then it looks to be a great sign of Allah, the Almighty for the truth of Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n.It is remarkable that Hadrat Abu Bakr ra and Hadrat Umar ra belonged to the families that did not have strong tribal support, but those of Hadrat Usman ra and Hadrat Ali ra were tribal.Ban u Umayyah was in favour of Hadrat Usman ra and Ban u ‘Abb a s in favour of Hadrat Ali ra , and both of them had a great strength in Arabia.At the time of the downfall of Khilafat the majority of the Muslims had lost their faith and stopped committing acts of goodness.Ban u Umayyah took control of the Muslims after the martyrdom of Hadrat Usman ra and Hadrat Ali ra , and those who belonged to Hadrat Usman ra praised him and condemned Hadrat Ali ra in their rule.In this period there were few who appreciated Hadrat Abu Bakr ra and Hadrat Umar ra.After this the circumstances changed and Ban u ‘Abb a s came to power in place of Ban u Umayyah.These were the people that belonged to Ahl-e-Bait , and used all their energies to praise the virtues of Hadrat Ali ra while condemning Hadrat Usman ra.In short, Ban u Umayyah continued condemning Hadrat Ali ra , while on the other hand Ban u ‘Abb a s kept condemning Hadrat Usman ra.In this way, for many centuries, one group of Muslims remembered the virtues of the one and the other group counted those of the other one.After the first four Khulaf a ’ there came two periods of Islamic history when there was

Page 169

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 153 no admirer of Hadrat Abu Bakrra and Hadrat Umarra, but despite that their decrees and injunctions became revered in the entire world.The others were also honoured, but not to that extent as had been promised in: Allah, the Almighty will establish their religion, and put their honour in the hearts of the people.Accordingly, when any Muslim is asked whom he respects the most, he will name first Hadrat Abu Bakr ra , then Hadrat Umar ra , then Hadrat Usman ra and finally Hadrat Ali ra , whereas there was no one to name Hadrat Abu Bakr ra and Hadrat Umar ra for a long time.For such a long period even the names of these very great personalities were forgotten.But God kept their names alive, and gave honour to their decrees and injunctions, which He did not give to the decrees and injunction of Hadrat Usman ra and Hadrat Ali ra.In the period of Ban u Umayyah, attempts were made to defame Hadrat Ali ra , and in Ban u ‘Abb a s, Hadrat Usman ra was censured.But in spite of all these attempts made by the governments, who, in their periods tried their best to defame and erase their names from the history; even then these two Khulaf a ’ came out unscathed, and God established their honour and prestige in the Islamic world.

Page 170

154 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Transforming Fear into Security The Fifth sign that Allah, the Almighty mentions is: “He will surely give them in exchange security and peace after their fear.” After their fearful condition He transforms their fear into security.Some people take this verse to mean that they remain safe from every kind of fear, and argue that Hadrat Umar ra , Hadrat Usman ra and Hadrat Ali ra faced fear after their Khilafat because the enemies martyred them.They therefore argue that none other than Hadrat Abu Bakr ra can be accepted as Khal i fa-e-R a shid.Sheikh Abdur Rehman Mi s r i has also emphasized this point, and wrote that the real Khalifah was only Hadrat Abu Bakr ra , and that the Khilafat of Hadrat Umar ra , Hadrat Usman ra and Hadrat Ali ra do not come within the sphere of A yat-e- Istikhl a f.Bear in mind that such people are misled because they do not ponder over the deeper meanings of the words of the Holy Quran.No doubt, the transformation of fear into security is also a great favour, but Allah, the Almighty does not mention that whatever is considered fear by any random person will be removed from them.He only mentions,

Page 171

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 155 The fear that is created in their hearts and the thing from which they are afraid of, Allah, the Almighty will remove it and transform it into security.Therefore, promise is not that whatever is fearful for Tom and Harry will not happen with the Khulaf a ’.But the promise is that whatever is fearful for them, Allah, the Almighty will remove it and transform their fear into security.For example, consider the snake which is apparently a very terrible thing, but there are people who can carry snakes in their hands.For such people the fear of snakes is meaningless.Similarly, poverty is very frightening, but it was of no importance to the Holy Prophet sa.If somebody considers it very humiliating when he does not get a meal even for one time then shall we consider it humiliating (God forbid) for the Holy Prophet sa ? He considered poverty his honour, rags better than the costly dress, and worldly treasures pollution.For him the fear of poverty was meaningless.So Allah, the Almighty does not say, “Whatever fear is created, it will be transformed into security”.But He says, “There will not be any thing which will be frightening for them”.By taking this difference into consideration you will come to know that no such misery came to any of the Khulaf a ’ which they were afraid of.And if it came to them then Allah, the Almighty transformed it into security.

Page 172

156 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Hadrat Umar ra was not Afraid of his Martyrdom There is no doubt that Hadrat Umar ra was martyred.But when we look at the events that took place, it appears that Hadrat Umar ra was not afraid of his martyrdom.He continuously prayed to Allah for martyrdom, particularly in Medina.So can we say about a person who prayed all his life for martyrdom in Medina, and was martyred, that he passed through a terrible situation which was not transformed into security? No doubt, if Hadrat Umar ra were afraid of martyrdom, and then was martyred, maybe it could be said that Allah, the Almighty did not transform his fear into security.But he prayed, “O Allah, martyr me in Medina”.So how can it be said that he was afraid of martyrdom? When he was not afraid of it, but prayed for it, then Allah, the Almighty honoured his request.It indicates that according to this verse there was no such fear, rather that was his heartfelt desire.And in this verse I have mentioned that an incident cannot happen that a Khalifah can be afraid of.It is the promise of Allah, the Almighty that He will transform their fear into security.But when they are not afraid of something, and consider it their honour and greatness, then calling it fear and asking why it was not transformed into security is totally meaningless.When I read the prayer of Hadrat Umar ra I presumed that apparently it means that an attack of an enemy on Medina would be so severe in magnitude

Page 173

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 157 that it would destroy all the Muslims and come to the chair of the Khalifah to martyr him, but in granting the prayer of Hadrat Umar ra Allah, the Almighty created such circumstances that instead of a foreign attack on Medina, a wicked man rose from inside to martyr him by dagger.Hadrat Usman ra also did not Feel any Fear The incidents that happened to Hadrat Usman ra also indicate that he never entertained any fear of them.History proves that when the rebels attacked Medina, they spread on all sides of the mosque before prayer.They separated the Medinites from one another so that they might not face them collectively.But in spite of this revolt, mutiny and disturbance, Hadrat Usman ra came to the mosque all alone for leading the prayer.He did not fear anyone at all.On his way to the mosque the people warned him not to go there in such a great disturbance while the rebels attacked his house.Instead of asking the Companions ra to guard his house he, on oath, asked them not to put their lives in danger while protecting him.He advised them to go to their homes and not to worry about him.Does a person afraid of martyrdom behave like this? Can a fearful person tell those concerned people to go home and not worry about him? Another weighty evidence that Hadrat Usman ra was not afraid of these painful incidents is that once

Page 174

158 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Hadrat Muawiyah came for Hajj during these disturbances.On his way back to Syria he met Hadrat Usman ra in Medina, and requested him to accompany him to Syria where he would be safe from all the disturbances.He said to Muawiyah that he could not give preference to any thing other than the neighbourhood of the Holy Prophet sa.Muawiyah offered him an army of Syrian soldiers for his security if he did not like to move to Syria.Hadrat Usman ra declined the offer saying that by keeping an army for his protection he did not want to lessen the food for the Muslims.Hadrat Muawiyah made a submission, “Am i r-ul-Mu’min i n, people will either kill you by fraud or there is a possibility of making a war against you”.Hadrat Usman ra replied, “I do not care about it.My God is sufficient for me”.At last he said, “If you do not agree upon anything then, at least, exile all the mischievous people from Medina.They are proud of some great Companions ra about whom they think that they will take over the charge after him, and they deceive the people by naming some of them.They should be spread in foreign lands to discourage the rebels who may stop their resistance with the mind that it is of little gain, when there is no one to take the charge of Medina.But Hadrat Usman ra did not accept it and asked how he could exile the people who were brought together by the Holy Prophet sa.On hearing this, Hadrat Muawiyah wept and begged him to make an announcement that the revenge of his blood would

Page 175

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 159 be taken by Muawiyah.He said, “Muawiyah, you are sharp by temperament.I am afraid that you might treat the Muslims harshly.Therefore, I cannot make such an announcement.” Now it is said the Hadrat Usman ra was a man of weak heart.But think about it.How many people can be so courageous? In the presence of these testimonies can it be said that there was fear in his heart.If he was afraid he would have asked for a platoon of an army for his protection, and he would get their salaries paid.If he was afraid then he would have made an announcement that if anybody raised a hand against him, then the revenge would be taken by Muawiyah.But he replied only by saying this much, “Muawiyah! You are sharp by temperament and I am afraid that if I give you this power, you will be hard on Muslims”.When the enemies climbed up the wall and attacked him, he continued reciting the Holy Quran without any fear.So much so that a son of Hadrat Abu Bakr (God’s mercy upon him) stepped forward and strongly pulled the beard of Hadrat Usman ra.He raised his eye and said, “O son of my brother if your father had been present, you would never have done this”.On hearing it, he shivered from head to toe, and went out ashamed.After this another person came forward and hit an iron bar on his head and kicked away the Holy Quran lying in front of him.On his retreat another person came ahead and martyred him by sword.In view of these incidents how can one say that Hadrat

Page 176

160 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Usman ra was afraid of them? And when he was not afraid of them then how can these incidents be counted as going against (security and peace after their fear)? These people (Khulaf a ’) were only afraid that there might be any decrease in the light of Islam, so in spite of these incidents, at last, they established what they wanted to do, and Allah, the Almighty transformed their fear into security.Martyrdom of Hadrat Ali ra The case is the same with Hadrat Ali ra.The fear in his heart was only regarding truthfulness, spiritualism and propagation, so Allah, the Almighty transformed this fear into security.He did not fear how the people would treat him.In spite of the fact that the army of Hadrat Muawiyah ra was sometime many times greater than that of Hadrat Ali ra , even then he was not afraid of it, and continued asserting that he would only accept what the Holy Quran says.He would not accept any thing against the Holy Quran.If the opposition of the people is called fear then one will have to admit that the Prophets (God Forbid) were always afraid of the people because the people did not oppose anyone else as much as they opposed the Prophets.Worldly opposition amounts to nothing.Allah, the Almighty does not say that whatever fear is created, it will be transformed in security.But He says,

Page 177

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 161 Allah, the Almighty will remove that thing from which they were afraid of, and transform their fear into security.I have said before that they were only afraid of the Muslim ummah going astray or being humiliated, so Allah, the Almighty saved the ummah collectively from humiliation due to their watchfulness and blessings of their prayers; and so the religion of Ahl-e-Sunnat wal-Jam a ‘at has always dominated the major part of the world.Allah, the Almighty Safeguards His Khulaf a ’ from Ordinary Fears The interpretation that I have given for this verse—that the fear being mentioned is not an ordinary one but one felt by the Khalifah’s heart— does not mean that they must experience ordinary fears.Indeed, Allah, the Almighty safeguards them from even ordinary fears also excepting that in which there is some wisdom from Allah, the Almighty.As in the time of Hadrat Ali ra fear was created because the condition of common Muslims had deteriorated and in the eyes of Allah, the Almighty they were not worthy for the reward of Khilafat.Therefore, I do not mean that Allah, the Almighty did not save them from ordinary fears, but I mean that the real promise in this verse is concerned only with those matters which are deemed by them to be fearful.The only thing fearful for them was that Ummat-e-Muhammadiyya might go

Page 178

162 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH astray or be humiliated.But by the grace of God, Ummat-e-Muhammadiyya was saved from such humiliation, even during the great disturbances Allah, the Almighty created circumstances for their guidance after their deaths.And it is a real miracle that their desires are fulfilled even after their deaths.If the desires of somebody are fulfilled in his lifetime then it can be said that he contrived to do so, but if someone’s life ends and then his desires are fulfilled it cannot be said about him that he has used some apparent contrivances.This is the proof that he was a beloved of Allah, the Almighty.A Vision of the Holy Prophet sa Fulfilled after His Death For example the Holy Prophet sa saw the gold bangles of the Emperor of Iran on the hands of one of his companions.The miracle of the Holy Prophet sa is not that he saw the gold bangles in his hands, but the miracle took place a long time after the death of the Holy Prophet sa.When the gold bangles came in booty, and despite the fact that sharia prohibits the wearing of gold bangles for men, Allah, the Almighty created an urge in the heart of Hadrat Umar ra to fulfil the vision of the Holy Prophet sa by putting the gold bangles on the hands of that person, so he put them on him.The miracle in this incident is that despite the demise of the Holy Prophet sa , Allah, the Almighty created an urge in the heart of Hadrat Umar ra to fulfil

Page 179

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 163 the vision of the Holy Prophet sa.It is also a miracle that Hadrat Umar ra heard the words of the Holy Prophet sa and got the chance to fulfil them.Though Hadrat Umar ra did not hear every word of the Holy Prophet sa , and there was a possibility that somebody had heard it and he might have forgotten to convey it to the others.But the part of the miracle is that the gold bangles came on to the hand of the very person who had himself heard the vision of the Holy Prophet sa.The miracle is also that Allah, the Almighty created an urge in the heart of Hadrat Umar ra to insist that the gold bangles be worn by that Companion ra , whereas according to sharia it is forbidden for men to wear gold.As Allah, the Almighty wanted to fulfil this vision of the Holy Prophet sa , He drew Hadrat Umar’s ra attention to it.Though the wisdom for not allowing men to wear gold is, no doubt, good; yet it is not wrong for the gold bangles to be worn for a short time to fulfil the vision the Holy Prophet sa –and so the bangles were worn by that Companion ra.28 After the Deaths of Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n their Fear Continued to be Transformed into Security Similarly we see that Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n died and years after their deaths Allah, the Almighty 28 Usudul-Gh a bb a h , Zikru Sur a kah bin M a lik , Vol.2, p.281, by Imam ‘Izzuddin Abul Hasan Ali bin Muhammad Al-Hazri Ibnil Ath i r, publisher D a rul Ma‘rifah, Beirut, Lebanon.Second edition, AH 1422, AD 2001.

Page 180

164 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH transformed their fears into security.Sometimes after one hundred years, two hundred years, three hundred years or four hundred years and sometimes even after five hundred years, it was manifested that God loved them and did not want to let their desires go vain.There is no harm if the whole verse [ ] is applied to the nation as well, because it will mean the same thing in this situation that I have mentioned before—that is, if there was any fear that struck at the whole nation it was the domination of the disbelievers against Islam.Individually anyone may have fear that their son may die while others may also have a fear that their business may go into a loss.But the fear of a nation can only be national, and therefore, the fear that the infidels would somehow gain against Islam, also became removed by the nation through Islam.By these means Islam became so dominate, that its precedent cannot be found any where.The Awe of Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n on Non- Muslim Kings In the age of Hadrat Ali ra , when internal disputes and controversies increased by manifolds, the Roman king thought it good to attack the Muslims at a time when they were busy fighting with one another, and their power had been weakened by internal conflict.He thought that if the Muslims were attacked they would soon be defeated.When this rumour reached

Page 181

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 165 Hadrat Muawiyah, he sent a notice to the king that if he attacked the Muslims then from the side of Hadrat Ali ra , he would be the first General to come out to fight against him.When this message reached the Roman king, he at once gave up his plans for war.This incident shows that there was a great fear of the Khulaf a ’, because when the Roman king came to know that Muawiyah would come to fight against him under the command of Hadrat Ali ra , he was amazed and took heed that the war would not prove beneficial for him.True Khulaf a ’ are the Standard Bearers of Real Unity The Sixth sign of Khulaf a ’ mentioned by Allah, the Almighty is that: This means that the Khulaf a ’ will worship Allah, the Almighty and will not associate any partners with Him.Allah, the Almighty will create extraordinary courage and bravery in their hearts, and the fear of anyone other than Allah, the Almighty will not be present in their hearts.They will not do anything due to fear of the people, but will trust in Allah, the Almighty, and will work for His pleasure alone.It does not just mean that they will not worship idols, for idol-worship is not practiced even by ordinary Muslims; so then how could it be said about Khulaf a ’ that they will not worship idols? Therefore, this verse

Page 182

166 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH does not refer to idol-worship, but it says that Khulaf a ’ will not step back from sure footing due to fear of people.Whatever will they do, they will do it with the fear of Allah and will fulfil the will and plan of God, no matter how much danger and other perilous misfortunes they may come across.In the world, sometimes even a very bold person changes his position due to fear of people.He does not intend to abandon the truth, but there is always a desire in the heart to work in such a manner that does not cause someone to raise an objection.Once there was a fanatic Wahhabi named Maulaw i Ghulam Ali.The Wahhabis believed that there could be Prayer of Jum‘ah in India.But the Hanfis believed that it could not be offered in India because, according to them, Jum‘ah Prayer is only lawful when there is a Muslim sultan.The person who leads the Jum‘ah Prayer should be a Muslim Q ad i in the city.Due to the English government in India there was left neither a Muslim Sultan nor Q ad i, so they did not consider it lawful to perform the Jum‘ah Prayer.On the other hand, it is mentioned in the Holy Quran that when you are called for Jum‘ah Prayer, leave all business immediately and perform Jum‘ah Prayer.Therefore, their hearts were not satisfied.On one side they wanted to perform Jum‘ah Prayer, but on other side they were afraid of the decree of some Hanfi Maulaw i.Due to this problem it was their practice that they first performed Jum‘ah Prayer on Friday and

Page 183

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 167 then they performed their Z uhr Prayer.They presumed that if the issue of Jum‘ah Prayer was correct then they were safe and so also if Z uhr prayer was true.They called it I h ti yati (precaution) instead of Z uhr Prayer.And they believed that if God rejected their Jum‘ah Prayer then they would present their Z uhr Prayer and vice versa.If anybody did not perform I h ti yati , he was presumed to be a Wahhabi.An Incident of Maulaw i Ghulam Ali The Promised Messiah as used to say that once he went to Gurdaspur with Maulaw i Ghulam Ali.It was time for Jum‘ah Prayer on their way.They went to a mosque for Prayer.The practice of the Promised Messiah as was somewhat similar to that of Wahhabis because they considered it necessary to practice according to A ha d i th and their faith is that it is necessary to practise the sunnah of the Holy Prophet sa for salvation; so he accompanied Maulaw i Ghulam Ali and performed the Jum‘ah Prayer.After the Jum‘ah Prayer, Maulaw i Ghulam Ali performed four rak‘ a ts of Z uhr Prayer.When he was questioned about the four rak‘ a ts of Z uhr Prayer, he said that it was I h ti yati.The Promised Messiah as asked Maulaw i Sahib that being a Wahabbi why had he done contrary to his faith? What did mean by I h ti yati ? He said that it was not in the sense that God would accept his Jum‘ah Prayer or Z uhr but it was in this sense that people might not raise an objection on his doing so.

Page 184

168 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Many people behaved like Maulaw i Ghulam Ali, who was pleased in his own heart to perform Jum‘ah Prayer, but also performed four rak‘ a t of Z uhr Prayer to please the people.A Story of a Sunni Elder There is a famous story.It is said that once there was a Sunni elder who lived in the area of Shias.Once poverty troubled him so much that he decided to seek the help of the king by making a request, and so He went to the king and begged for help.The minister told the king that he looked like a Sunni by appearance.The king asked him how he had come to know of it.He said that he looked to be so by appearance.The king asked him to give some reasons and examine the elder in his presence.So the minister praised Hadrat Ali ra very much before the elder, and in turn, the elder also started praising him.On this the king told the minister that his presumption proved wrong.If he had not been Shia he would not have praised Hadrat Ali ra so much.The minister asserted that whatever the case was he looked to be Sunni.The king asked him to take another test.The minister asked him to curse the three; i.e.(God forbid) curse on Abu Bakr ra , Umar ra and Usman ra.He also cursed the three.The king told him that from it he proved to be a Shia.The minister said that the case looked to be so but he was not satisfied.At last the minister took him aside and asked him to tell the truth about his

Page 185

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 169 religion.He told him that he was Sunni by faith.Then he asked him why did he curse the three? The elder clarified that he did not mean Hadrat Abu Bakr ra , Hadrat Umar ra and Hadrat Usman ra but he meant, “Curse be upon me and you two.On you because you curse the elders, and on me because I have come to you due to my misfortune.” In short, a person acts in many ways to meet their contingency and considers that he has not committed any sin but Allah, the Almighty says: The Khulaf a ’ will be very bold, and fear will not come close to them.Whatever they do would be according to the will of God.They will not do anything due to the fear of any person.Resoluteness of Hadrat Abu Bakr ra during the Apostasy This quality is found in Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n in its perfection.When the Holy Prophet sa died and Hadrat Abu Bakr ra became the Khalifah, the whole of Arabia turned apostate and only at two places were collective Prayer performed.The agitation spread everywhere else.All the people refused to pay the Zakat except those of Mecca and Medina, and a small town.They said that: Allah, the Almighty revealed to the Holy Prophet sa : (Al-Taubah, 9:103)

Page 186

170 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH “Take alms out of their wealth.” Nobody else is empowered to take Zakat.So the whole of Arabia turned back on their faith and came out to fight.In the days of the Holy Prophet sa , no doubt, Islam was weak, but the attack of Arabian tribes was in a scattered form.Sometime one tribe attacked, and sometime another did so.In the battle of Ahzab, the army of infidels collectively attacked the Muslims, and at that time Islam had gained greatly in strength, though they were not strong enough to avoid fear of any attack in future.After the battle, the Holy Prophet sa set out to conquer Mecca.On his way the other tribes of Arabia also came out to render their help.In this way God restrained the enemies so that the Muslims might become strong enough to be dominant in the whole of Arabia.But during apostasy, the people of all the places refused to pay Zakat except Mecca and Medina, and a small town.The tribes came out to fight.At some places they had an army of hundred thousand.But the Muslims had an army of ten thousand, and that too was set out for Syria.It was the army the Holy Prophet sa had prepared to attack the Roman territory before his death.Hadrat Usama ra was made the chief of it.The rest of the people were either weak, old, or too young.In such circumstances, the Companions ra thought that if the army of Hadrat Usama ra was sent at the time of disturbances, there would not be any arrangement for the protection of Medina, so a delegation of great

Page 187

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 171 Companions ra –including Hadrat Umar ra and Hadrat Ali ra , who were renowned for their courage and bravery–met Hadrat Abu Bakr ra and asked him to stop the departure of the army for some time till the revolt was suppressed.After that it might be allowed to proceed because sending it now was very risky, and there would not be any arrangement for the protection of Medina, especially at the time of the advancement of the enemy toward them.Hadrat Abu Bakr ra angrily said, “Do you want the son of Abu Qahafa to stop the army that was ordered to advance by the Holy Prophet sa.I cannot stop it any way.If the whole of Arabia has rebelled, even so let it be, and if there is no arrangement for the protection of Medina, even then let it be.I swear on the oath of God that if the army of the enemy were to enter Medina and drag the corpses of Muslim women like dogs before them even then I’ll send the army whose departure is ordered by the Holy Prophet sa.Leave me if you are afraid of the armies of enemy.I’ll alone face all the enemies.” It is another great proof of: 29 “They will worship Me, and they will not associate anything with Me.” 29 T a r i khul Khulaf a’ , p.74, by Jal a luddin Abdur Rehman bin Abu Bakr As-Suy uti , publisher Nur Muhammad, A ss a h ul Ma ta bi‘, K a rkh a nah Tij a rat Kutub, A r a m B a gh, Karachi.

Page 188

172 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH The other question was of Zakat.The Companions ra requested that if the departure of the army could not be stopped then he should make a temporary truce and tell them that the Zakat would not be levied that year.In the meanwhile their passions would cool down and a way would be found to resolve the differences.As at present they were emotional and ready to fight, it was not good to take Zakat from them.Hadrat Abu Bakr ra said, “It will not happen at all.In the age of the Holy Prophet sa , if they gave a piece of string to tie the knee of a camel in Zakat, and refused to give it now then he will have to fight till I get that piece of string”.On this the Companions ra said that if the army of Usama ra went out and no temporary truce was made with rebels then who would face the enemy, because there were only a few old and weak persons or some young ones.How could they face hundreds of thousands of enemies? Hadrat Abu Bakr ra replied, “If you cannot face them then Abu Bakr ra alone will come out to face them”.30 This is the claim of the person who was not skilled in warfare, and about whom it was usually presumed that he was weak-hearted.What created this courage, bravery, certitude and confidence in him? Hadrat Abu Bakr ra took it that he was made Khalifah by Allah, the Almighty, and on him was the whole responsibility, so it was his duty to come out to fight.Success or 30 T a r i khul-Kham i s , Vol.2, p.201, by Husain bin Muhammad bin Al- Hasan Ad-Diy a r Bakari, publisher Mu’assasatu Shu‘b a t, Beirut.

Page 189

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 173 failure is in the hand of Allah, the Almighty.If He wants he will give success otherwise all the armies cannot achieve victory.Bold Acts of Hadrat Umar ra After this, when Hadrat Umar ra became Khalifah— this same Umar ra who advised Abu Bakr ra that they would face that great army and advised the army of Usama ra be retained for help—became similarly confident and fought with the whole world at one and the same time, and was not at all fearful.In the age of Hadrat Umar ra , the fight with the Romans was going on.The Romans were very powerful.The Muslims’ fight with them was just like the fight of Afghanistan with English Government.But in spite of a war with such a great army, when Hadrat Umar ra got news of the movement of the Iranian army against Muslims, and there were signs of revolt in those territories which were under the control of Muslims; the same Umar ra who advised Abu Bakr ra that it would be a great mistake if they, at one and the same time, sent army of Usama ra to fight with Romans, and on the other side fight with internal rebels; ordered to attack Iran immediately.Companions ra wondered how, at one and the same time, they would fight with two great powers.But he said, “Don’t worry and fight”.As the Muslims were busy in fighting with Romans, so the attack of Muslims on Iran was unthinkable.When the king of Iran heard the news of the

Page 190

174 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH advancement of the Muslim forces, he did not give any importance to it, and considered it to be a rumour which people had spread for no reason.He thought that the Muslims were already engaged in a dangerous war, and could not possibly think of attacking Iran.So for some time, this became the main cause for the defeat of Iranians, and no army came from the capital to fight the Muslims because the king considered the news of the attack a false rumour spread by the people.When this news continuously kept reaching him, then he sent for a General to give him a true report.What he reported was that the Muslims were really advancing, and had already captured many areas, it was only then that the king of Iran sent an army to fight the Muslims.From this you can assess how dangerous it appeared to be for Muslims to be involved in this fight when they were already fighting with the Romans.But such things were of no importance before the power that Allah, the Almighty had bestowed upon Hadrat Umar ra after making him Khalifah.Spitting of Hadrat Abu Hurairah ra in the Scarf of Iranian King It was the same war in which the Muslims were victorious, and a scarf of the king of Iran also came in the booty.It was given to Hadrat Abu Huraira ra.One day he coughed and spat in the scarf of the king of Iran.He said, “Bravo! Abu Hurairah, how great you

Page 191

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 175 are today, spitting in the scarf of the king of Iran”.When the people asked the reason he said that in the age of the Holy Prophet sa , sometimes he had to starve so much that he became unconscious due to the pangs of hunger, and people took it to be the epileptic fits, and started striking sandals on his head.But the time had come when his condition was that he was spitting on the royal scarf of a king.31 The sign of: was made visible very clearly by Allah, the Almighty through Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n.And they never allowed any fear to enter their hearts except that of Allah, the Almighty.Bold Defences by Hadrat Usman ra and Hadrat Ali ra Similarly the way a modest and soft-hearted man like Hadrat Usman ra , faced the internal conflict with such confidence and certitude is remarkable.He is generally considered to be weak, but during the time of his Khilafat he worked with such bravery and courage that it astonishes the reader.Similar is the case of Hadrat Ali ra , who was not disturbed by any opposition, even though he faced both internal and external threats.For him the only 31 Bukh a r i , Kit a b-ul-E‘iti sa m bil-Kit a bi was-Sunnah, B a bo m a Zakaran- Nabiyyu sa , by Muhammad bin Ism a ’ i l Abu Abdullah Al-Bukh a r i Al-Ju‘f i , publisher, D a r ibni Kath i r Al-Yam a mah, Beirut.

Page 192

176 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH concern was the fulfillment of the will of Allah, the Almighty.He never deviated from what he believed to be the Divine will under the fear of any one.In short, in all the Khulaf a ’ we see the excellence of This is a clear and definite proof that Allah, the Almighty Himself appointed them as Khulaf a ’ and He Himself took the responsibility to provide them assistance and aid.Objections generally made on A yat-e- Istikhl a f Now I take the objections which are generally made on this verse.The first objection is that the promise made in it is for the Muslim ummah, not with some individuals; the ummah has been promised to be made a Khalifah, not just some special individuals.It is argued that the verse means that Muslims will gain power and their own government.The second objection they have is that in this verse it is said: “As He made Successors from among those who were before them.” The earlier nations were granted Khilafat by Prophethood or by kingship, so the comparison can be

Page 193

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 177 considered valid only up to this extent.The critics concede that there would be prophets and kings amongst Muslims, but they then say that the type of Khilafat in which we believe comes neither under Prophethood nor under a Muslim kingdom.So then what is the argument for its establishment? The third objection is that even if we take the model of the Khilafat which came after the Holy Prophet sa , it was accompanied with a government.Therefore, it would come under: “and He made you kings.” How does this then justify the Khilafat of Jam a ‘at- e-Ahmadiyya, which is neither a Khilafat of Prophethood nor kingship? The fourth objection that is contained in the promise in this verse, is taken to refer to a Jam a ‘at which means that some persons will be Prophets in this ummah and some will be the kings.However, the Khilafat of Prophethood was terminated by the Holy Prophet sa because it is a shared belief that the types of Prophets who came before, cannot come again.Moreover, it is a shared belief that the previous Khulaf a ’ were not considered as kings.As it is mentioned in the A ha d i th :

Page 194

178 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 32 “The Holy Prophet sa said, Prophethood will remain among you as long as God desires, then God will take back this blessing, and will bless you with Khilafat on the pattern of Prophethood, and it will remain among you as long as God desires, then God will take it back, and will establish kingdom as long as He desires.” The critics conclude that the Holy Prophet sa did not consider the Khulaf a ’ to be kings as it is said that there will be Khilafat and then the kingdom.It shows that the people of Ummat-e-Muhammadiyyah can get neither Khilafat of Prophethood, nor of kingship.Therefore, there is no proof of any personal Khilafat in this verse, but only of a Khilafat of the community as a whole; and nobody can object to that.32 Musnad Ahmad bin Hambal, Vol.4, p.273, by Ahmad bin Muhammad bin Hambal bin Hil a l bin Asad, published by Baitul Afk a r Ad-Dauliyya, Al- Ri ad , AH 1419, AD 1998.Note: Volume and page No.are according to Nuskha Maimaniyya.

Page 195

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 179 Reply to the Question that the Promise is Made with the Muslim ummah, and not with Some Individuals Now I will respond to the following questions.The first question is that the promise made in this verse is with the Muslim ummah, and not with only some individuals.My answer is: No doubt, the promise is made with the nation but it does not mean that it is not to be fulfilled through some individuals.Some promises are made with a nation but they are fulfilled through certain persons, and it is said that the promise made with a nation is fulfilled.The incidents of it are available in every language, e.g.in our language it is said that English are the kings.Does it mean that every Englishman is a king? Every Englishman is neither a king nor can be a king.Even then it is said that the English are the kings.Similarly, it is said that a certain nation is the ruler, whereas the whole nation cannot possibly be the ruler, a few people are in charge of the government and the rest of them are their subordinates.Sometimes it is said that such a nation is very rich but it does not mean that every one person of that nation is rich.It is usually said that the British people are very rich but there are also very poor people amongst them.Our elder brother Mirza Sultan Ahmad (deceased) once told me that when he was in London, the house maid threw out the waste of the house.Suddenly an English boy rushed to it, picked up a piece of bread and ate it.

Page 196

180 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Similarly, I have seen women going out with pots on their heads to fetch water in Brindisi, 33 and the pants of their children patched with different pieces of cloths.Even then it is said that the English are very rich.Therefore, the promise made with a nation does not mean that it is not fulfilled through some individuals.Many promises are made with a nation but they are fulfilled through individuals.An incident of it is available in the Holy Quran.Allah, the Almighty says: When M u sa (Moses) reminded the people to call to their minds Allah’s favours upon them and the appointment of Prophets amongst them and also [and He made you kings].Can anybody prove that every person of Ban i Isr a ’ i l were kings? Surely there were very poor people in Ban i Isr a ’ i l, but M u sa (Moses) said to them, that He made you all kings.The import is that when there are kings in any nation, the whole nation shares the favours and blessings of the kingdom.In other words, we can say that the nation has been granted the kingdom.So in the light of the verse [and He made you kings], it does not mean that every Jew became a king.Then how can we conclude from: 33 A southern city of Rome.

Page 197

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 181 “Allah has promised to those among you who believe and do good works that He will surely make them Successors in the earth, as He made Successors from among those who were before them.” That this promise should not be fulfilled through some individuals, but every member of ummah should get the blessings of Khilafat.Is it not strange that Allah, the Almighty says about Jews that He [made you kings]? The commentators say without any hesitation that though few people became kings, as the standard of living of the common man was raised, it could be said that they were all granted the kingdom.But when Allah, the Almighty says: They start saying that this promise is with the whole nation, and they cannot believe that the promise can be fulfilled through some individuals.Even if the verse is taken to means the domination of a nation, how can every believer share it? Some get it and some do not.There were many Companions ra who remained poor even in the days of their national rule, and their financial condition did not improve.

Page 198

182 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH The incident of Hadrat Abu Hurairah ra is worth noting.When the armies of Hadrat Ali ra and Hadrat Muawiyah ra came face to face in the battle of S af i n then, in spite of the distance of one mile between them, when the time of Prayer came Hadrat Abu Huraira ra went to the camp of Hadrat Ali ra , and at the time of meals he went to the camp of Hadrat Muawiyah ra.Somebody asked, “How strange it is that you are coming and going to the Majlis of Hadrat Ali ra on one side and the Majlis of Hadrat Muawiyah ra on the other side.What is the matter?” He said, “Prayer is better at the side of Hadrat Ali ra , and meal is good at the side of Muawiyah ra.Therefore, at the time of Prayer I go there and at the time of meal I come here.” He was served sumptuous meals at the side of Muawiyah ra , so he went there at that time.But the Prayer of Hadrat Ali ra was charged with humility and submission, so he joined him at the time of Prayer.An Incident of a Dissentient The condition of some of our dissentients is also the same.The incident reported about one of them is even more remarkable than that of Hadrat Abu Hurairah ra.Once I was sitting with Chaudhry Zafarullah Khan ra and someone told us about a dissentient who said that, “We hold the correct beliefs, but the prayers of Miy a ń Sahib are accepted more”.Just as Abu Hurairah ra said, “The meal of Muawiyah’s side is good and Prayer of Ali ra is better”.

Page 199

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 183 Similarly he said, “We hold the correct beliefs but their prayers are accepted more”.In short, even in a ruling nation, many people remain poor.But it is said that the nation is ruling, even though only one man is the king, and the rest are not kings.Similarly it is said about Jews, [made you kings].If it was necessary that God would make them kings when God says that “He made them kings”, then everybody should have become a king.Obviously that is not the case.When there is a king from any nation, and the whole nation shares the benefits of kingdom, we can, in other words, say that it is the ruling nation.Similarly, when someone from a nation is bestowed Khilafat then it is said that the nation has been bestowed the reward.The second example is the verse in which Allah, the Almighty says: (Al-Baqarah, 2:92) When it is said to Jews, “Believe in what Allah had sent down in the Holy Quran,” they say: “We believe in what has been sent down to us.”

Page 200

184 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Now this is very clear that revelation was not sent down to them but it was sent down on Hadrat M u sa as (Moses).But they say: “Sent down to us”.This is what they say about the words that descended upon Hadrat M u sa as (Moses) and of other Prophets, whereas the revelation was sent down to their Prophets, and not to the people themselves.Therefore, when a reward is sent down to some people and the whole nation is benefited then it is said that the whole nation has been granted the reward.For instance, if someone has money we cannot say that the whole city is wealthy.But if there is a scholar in the city who serves the people by teaching, then the city is said to be a city of scholars.A good example of this is that all types of people live in Qadian: scholars, illiterate, storekeepers, labourers, educated and uneducated.But when two to four people from Qadian go to nearby villages, then they start saying that the “Maulaw i s of Qadian have arrived”, even though they may be only manual workers.The reason for this is that scholarly discourses are always taking place in Qadian, and therefore everybody living in Qadian is called a Maulaw i.Similarly, when the father is a hakim (physician) the son—even if he does not know an iota of medicine—is called a hakim.In summary, when the association is strong it is given due consideration, and all the people are considered to be a part of the whole.

Page 201

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 185 When the revelation of God is sent down to a Prophet then it is said that the Word of God has descended upon the nation to which that Prophet belongs, whereas the Word of God descends only upon the Prophet, and not upon every one.Similarly, when the king belongs to a nation, the whole nation is considered to be the ruling country.There are many poor people in England who beg from others.But even if a garbage cleaner from England comes to India, people start saluting him from a distance.The policeman also takes care that the British gentleman should not be disrespected, whereas he has no honour in his own country.But since someone is a king, so then everyone belonging to that nation is considered honourable.Sometime back in India, a Raja went to England.When he came back and reached Bombay, he wanted to come out of the port immediately due to some urgent piece of work.An Englishman was on duty to check the passports.Taking the passport he went ahead hurriedly and asked him to check his passport first as he wanted to leave early due to some urgent piece of work.But the Englishman asked him to wait for his turn, for he would check the passports turn by turn.He did not care for the Raja, and made him wait for his turn and thus caused him to leave at the end.On this there was a great hue and cry in the press that the Raja was humiliated, but nobody asked the

Page 202

186 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Englishman why he did so.Therefore, when a nation is in power its poor also get some honour.In America, when liquor was banned, the ships of some foreign countries secretly supplied it.Once a British ship carrying liquor came to the notice of the Americans, and they chased it.In the meantime it went three miles away from the shore of America, and sailed without any fear.The American ships signaled it to stop, threatening an attack in case of non- compliance.The ship raised its flag and threw light on it.The purpose was to display its national identity to make them desist from attacking.When the Americans saw the British flag, they went back thinking that if they attacked it, war would break out between America and England.When a nation gets power then the persons of its lower rank also gain honour in certain matters.Many Hindu friends have told me that when they go out and mention that they have come from Qadian, people show great hospitality to them, merely because they belong to Qadian.When a person from Arabia arrives in India, we Indians honour him greatly, whereas he may have no importance in his own country.Look at our own Jam a ‘at.As Allah, the Almighty has blessed our Jam a ‘at with Khilafat, the entire Community benefits from it.If an Ahmadi is slightly harmed anywhere, the whole world comes to know of it.Similarly if the people are in need of some assistance they come to Qadian, and most of their

Page 203

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 187 needs are fulfilled here.If, God forbid, there were to be some dissention among us, as it is in other Muslims, there would neither be any force in our voice nor would the members of the Jam a ‘at collectively avail the benefits which they avail now.The Effect of Protest against Afghanistan When some members of our Jam a ‘at were martyred in Afghanistan, we made a protest and by the grace of Allah, the Almighty it was so effective that it became the talk of the streets of London for six months, and the Ambassador of Afghanistan was put to great shame.Whenever he came out the people remarked, “Is this the liberty in your country”.But many Pathans are killed in Afghanistan, and nobody takes any notice of it.Due to the system of Jam a ‘at the members are getting many benefits.Therefore, when someone from a Jam a ‘at gets such a reward then it is said that the Jam a ‘at has received the reward, because the Jam a ‘at shares the rewards and benefits related to Khilafat or as a kingdom.As the whole nation is honoured through kingdom, so for this reason, it is said: [made you kings].The whole Jam a ‘at has benefited by Khilafat.Therefore, it can also be said about Khilafat that you will be made Khalifah.

Page 204

188 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Khilafat is established through an Electoral Process in Which the Whole Community is Involved The second answer is that Khilafat is established through an electoral process and the whole Jam a ‘at is involved in the election.To put emphasis on election it is said: The import is that this is a promise with the Jam a ‘at so this post cannot be inherited, but the Khalifah would be the person around whom the Jam a ‘at is gathered.The special emphasis is on the issue of election.It is mentioned that only he can be a Khalifah who has the support of the believers.No doubt, it is a Divine reward but it is a reward that Allah, the Almighty gives first to His believers.He admonishes them to hand it over to the most competent person amongst them by election.He gets the Khalifah elected by the believers so that Khilafat may not run on the basis of inheritance.For this purpose, the Jam a ‘at always elects the best person.Allah, the Almighty has promised the Muslim ummah: To emphasize that the promise of Khilafat is national, and Allah, the Almighty will make Khalifah whomsoever He pleases through the hands of Jam a ‘at.

Page 205

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 189 Why did Hadrat Abu Bakr ra Nominate Hadrat Umar ra ? When it is said that the Khalifah can only be made by the election of Jam a ‘at then why did Hadrat Abu Bakr ra nominate Hadrat Umar ra ? The answer is that he did not nominate someone on his own.His consultation with the Companions ra on this matter is a proven historical fact.The only difference is that the other Khulaf a ’ were elected after the death of their predecessors, and Hadrat Umar ra was elected in the life of Hadrat Abu Bakr ra.He did not just merely hold consultation with some Companions ra and declare the Khilafat of Hadrat Umar ra.In spite of his severe illness and weakness he came to the mosque with the support of his wife and addressed the people, “O people! After consultation with the Companions ra Hadrat Umar ra is my choice for Khilafat.Do you approve of his Khilafat”? On this all the people gave their approval, so this was also a type of election.Can the Appointment of Yazid as Khalifah by Hadrat Muawiyah ra be Called Election? If it is said that the appointment of Yazid by Muawiyah ra can also be called election because he also presented this matter before the people.The answer is that Muawiyah ra himself was not elected and when his own Khilafat is not proved, how can the Khilafat of his son be proved.We are ready to admit Yazid as successor of Muawiyah ra but we cannot call

Page 206

190 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH him a Khalifah.When the Khilafat of Muawiyah ra is not proved then how can that of his son be proved? As Muawiyah ra was a temporal king, we can admit Yazid to also be a temporal king.But neither Muawiyah was the Khalifah nor was his son.Moreover, when Muawiyah consulted his people about his son, he was the ruler of those people.In such a situation his consultation cannot be called an election, because freedom of expression is necessary in such matters.When there is no freedom of expression, and the king asks the subject to take the Bai‘at of his son, how can the subjects be at liberty to give advice, or even to disobey his order? To give an example, if the king of Afghanistan were to ask his subjects to accept him as Khalifah, and upon their acceptance were to say that the people have elected him to rule; this would not be an election, nor can such type of counselling be called consultation.Real consultation only takes place when the people are free to express their opinions, and every one is at liberty to propose the name of his choice.Thus, firstly Muawiyah himself was not a Khalifah but a king.Secondly, he presented the matter of the Khilafat of his son to the people during his rule.This cannot be called consultation or election in any way.

Page 207

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 191 It is against the Sunnah of Companions ra that a Father Should propose His Son for Khilafat The father’s nomination of his son for Khilafat also indicates that it was not a real election because the nomination by the father is against the sunnah of the Companions ra.When Hadrat Umar ra was on his death bed, many delegations came to him and all unanimously suggested that his son Abdullah was the most suitable person for Khilafat after him, and they asked him to appoint his son Khalifah.But he said that for a long time the Muslims had been under the rule of his family, and now he wanted to let someone else have this blessing.34 If the people had elected his son Abdullah for Khilafat after his death that would have been something different, but the nomination by Hadrat Umar ra would not have been lawful.Similarly, if Muawiyah ra had not presented the case of Yazid before the people in his presence, and later on, the people had elected him, we could have called him an elected king.But now we can neither call him Khalifah nor an elected king.We do not call Muawiyah ra sinful, as he did it under the pressure of the circumstances.But we cannot give the title of Khilafat to Yazid, nor to Muawiyah ra.We can only call them kings.34 Al-K a mil fit T a r i kh , Vol.3, p.65, by ‘Izzuddin Abul Hasan Ali bin Abul Karam Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Abdul Kar i m bin Abdul W ah id Ash-sh i b a n i , known as Ibnil Ath i r, publisher D a ru Sa dir, D a r Beirut, AH 1385, AD 1965.

Page 208

192 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH When the case of Yazid was presented before the people by Muawiyah ra , the Companions ra of that time considered it a mockery.For them it had no significance.History shows that when Muawiyah ra addressed the people saying: “O Muslims! You know that my family is one of the chiefs of Arabia, so who is more entitled for rule than I, and after me who is more entitled than my son”.Hadrat Abdullah bin Umar ra was also sitting in a corner.When he heard Muawiyah ra say this he unknotted the cloth wrapped around his feet with the intent of standing up to tell Muawiyah ra , “O Muawiyah ra , the one who is more entitled for this post than you, is the person whose father has fought against your father under the flag of the Prophet sa , and who has himself fought in the Islamic armies against you and your father”.But then he thought that the worldly things had no significance for him and his saying anything at that time would create a disturbance, and weaken the power of Muslims.So he remained sitting and did not speak against Muawiyah ra.To sum up, the Companions ra considered the act of Muawiyah ra quite absurd and attached no value to it.Surrender of Throne by a Son of Yazid Not to speak of the consent of other people to the Khilafat of Yazid, his own son did not agree to it.Immediately after his accession to throne, he went into seclusion and surrendered the throne.It is a well-

Page 209

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 193 known historical event, but I am not sure why Muslim historians have not highlighted it.They should have repeated it frequently because it is another clear proof of the atrocities of Yazid.It is recorded that after the death of Yazid, his son, who was also named Muawiyah ra after his grandfather, acceded to throne and went home after taking the Bai‘at of the people.He did not come out for forty days.When he came out, he rose to the pulpit and addressed the people that he had accepted the Bai‘at from them, not because he was more entitled to it, but because he did not want dissention among them.He had been continuously meditating in his home to find a person more entitled to take the Bai‘at of the people so that he might get himself relieved of chiefdom by handing it over to him.But in spite of his great efforts he did not find any such person.Therefore, he said, “O people listen to it carefully that I am not fit for this post.I also want to tell you that my father and grandfather were also not entitled to this post.My father was inferior to Husain ra , and his father from the father of Hasan ra and Husain ra.Hadrat Ali ra at his time was more entitled for Khilafat than my grandfather, and after this Hasan ra and Husain ra were more entitled than my father.Therefore, I retire from this chiefdom, and you can take the Bai‘at of the person of your choice.” At that time his mother heard the speech behind the veil, and she burst out: “O wretched, you have dishonoured your family and

Page 210

194 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH damaged its dignity”.He replied, “I have said what is true, now it is your turn to say whatever you like”.He then remained confined to his home, and died after a few days.35 What great evidence it is that, not to speak of others, even his own son did not agree to the Khilafat of Yazid.He did not do so for some vested interest nor did he oppose it due to the fear of any opposition.He made a decision after serious meditation that Hadrat Ali ra was more entitled than his grandfather, and Hasan ra and Husain ra than his father, and he himself was not ready to take the responsibility.Therefore, appointment of Yazid by Muawiyah ra cannot be called an election.Commentary of the Promised Messiah as on A yat-e-Istikhl a f The third answer for Ahmadis is that the Promised Messiah as , commenting upon this verse has written in Sirrul-Khil a fah that: 36 35 Al-K a mil fit T a r i kh , Vol.4, p.130, by ‘Izzuddin Abul Hasan Ali bin Abul Karam Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Abdul Kar i m bin Abdul W ah id Ash-sh i b a n i , known as Ibnil Ath i r, publisher D a ru Sa dir, D a r Beirut, AH 1385, AD 1965.36 Sirrul-Khil a fah , Ru ha n i Khaz a ’in , by Hadrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian as , Vol.8, p.334.

Page 211

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 195 “In these verses Allah, the Almighty has promised Muslim men and women that He will make some believers from among them Khalifah by His grace and mercy.” Since the Promised Messiah as mentions that: does not refer to the whole nation, but only to some individuals in the ummah, no Ahmadi can take it to mean the whole community.Inference of Khilafat-e-Muhammadiyya The fourth answer is also for Ahmadis.the Promised Messiah as has repeatedly inferred his Khilafat-e-Muhammadiyya from this verse and has included the Khilafat-e-Nubuwwat in it.And it is evident that Khilafat-e-Nubuwwat cannot apply to the whole nation but only to some specific individuals.To illustrate, wherever the Holy Quran mentions the kingdom, it uses the expression or He made you kings.But when Nubuwwat is mentioned then it is said, or, “He has appointed Prophets from you”.The reason for this difference is that we can say that God granted kingdom to a nation but it cannot be said that nation has been appointed as Prophet.Therefore, if the promise of Nubuwwat can be fulfilled through some individuals, even when the

Page 212

196 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH whole nation is addressed, then the promise of Khilafat can also be fulfilled through some individuals even when the whole nation is addressed.The way one part of the promise is fulfilled, can also be the way the other part would be fulfilled.Evidence from the Way of Allah, the Almighty The fifth answer is that the acts of Allah, the Almighty provide evidence of the actual meaning of this verse.Allah, the Almighty says: Meaning that He would appoint those who believe and do good deeds Khulaf a ’ in the same way as He appointed them to earlier people.If Allah, the Almighty meant for the establishment of democracy then we should have seen democracy established after the Prophet sa , or if it was the plan of Allah, the Almighty that some persons of ummah will get Khilafat and all the people will be entitled to have the blessings of Khilafat, then we should have seen whether or not Khilafat was established among the Muslims in this way.However, the way God fulfilled this promise after the Prophet sa can be the meaning of this verse because nobody can fulfill the promise of Allah, the Almighty better than He Himself.With this point of view when we study the circumstances after

Page 213

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 197 the death of the Prophet sa , we find that only a few individuals were bestowed Khilafat; not all of them.Therefore, either believe that after the death of the Prophet sa the people did not remain worthy of being called [those who believe and do good works], or as Shia believe that there were left only two and a half believers in ummah.In this way you will have to declare that all who were left were hypocrites (God forbid), so the promise of national Khilafat could not be fulfilled by them.But if they were on the path of their faith and acts of goodness then who can be more worthy to fulfill the promise than them? However, the way that Allah, the Almighty established Khilafat amongst the Muslims after the Prophet sa is the only evidence needed to show that the promise with the people is fulfilled through individuals.Resemblance of the Four Khulaf a ’ with the Previous Ones is not Necessary in Every Matter The second objection to this verse is that the Khilafat of specific individuals is promised in this verse.However, it is a shared common belief that the Khilafat of the previous Khulaf a ’ was either through Prophethood or through kingdom, but then it is also agreed that the four Khulaf a ’ after the Holy Prophet sa were neither prophets nor kings.Then how was this promise fulfilled, and how can it be a testimony of

Page 214

198 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH this verse? The answer is that there is no doubt that the previous Khulaf a ’ were bestowed Khilafat either by way of Prophethood or in the shape of kingdom, but the resemblance does not mean complete identity in everything.Resemblance is only seen in principle.To illustrate, we may talk of the heights of two persons and say one is as tall as the other.There would be no point in someone’s asserting that they do not resemble each other because one of them is a thief and the other is a devoted worshipper; or that one is the scholar and the other is illiterate.In this case, resemblance will only be seen in height and not in other traits.There are instances of this in the Holy Quran.Allah, the Almighty says: (Al-Muzzammil, 73:16) “Verily, We have sent to you a Messenger, who is a witness over you, even as We sent a Messenger to Pharoah.” Allah, the Almighty has pointed out the resemblance of the Holy Prophet sa and Hadrat M u sa as (Moses), whereas Hadrat M u sa as (Moses) was sent to Pharoah and the Holy Prophet sa was not sent to any such king.Similarly Hadrat M u sa as (Moses) was sent for the guidance of Ban i Isr a ’ i l but the Holy Prophet sa was sent for the guidance of the whole world.The period of the Prophethood of Hadrat M u sa as (Moses)

Page 215

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 199 extended to few centuries and, at last, it came to an end.But the period of the Prophethood of the Holy Prophet sa extends to the Day of Resurrection.Thus, there are important differences in the lives of Hadrat M u sa as (Moses) and the Holy Prophet sa.In spite of these differences the Muslims affirm that the Holy Quran says that the Holy Prophet sa resembles Hadrat M u sa as (Moses), whereas the Holy Prophet sa was sent neither to a king like Paroah nor some particular nation but to the whole world; and neither did his Prophethood come to an end in any age like that of M u sa as (Moses).If these differences do not bring any change in resemblances then there is no harm when the Khulaf a ’ of Islam partly differ from the Khulaf a ’ of the past.In fact the resemblance of the Prophet sa is only in the sense that just as M u sa as (Moses) was bestowed a book of sharia that was complete and covered all the subject matter to meet the needs of that age, similarly the Holy Prophet sa was bestowed the book of sharia which is perfect and covers all the subject matter to meet the needs of humankind till the Day of Resurrection, and is superior and exalted above the Old Testament.Just as the community established by Hadrat M u sa as (Moses) continued after him through the Prophets; similarly, whenever there arises any deficiency in Ummat-e-Muhammadiyyah, Allah, the Almighty sends some persons who reform the ummah.Their resemblance also shows that just as a Messiah came thirteen hundred years after Hadrat

Page 216

200 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH M u sa as (Moses), the Promised Messiah as would come in Ummat-e-Muhammadiyyah after thirteen hundred years.It is not the case that because Hadrat M u sa as (Moses) was for a specific period and for a particular nation, the Prophethood of the Holy Prophet sa is also for specific period and for a particular nation.So if there is a resemblance of Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n in some matters with the Khilafat of the previous Khulaf a ’ then we’ll have to admit their resemblances.It is not necessary that they should have resemblance in every matter.The real point is that just as some individuals were raised to rejuvenate the people after the death of earlier Prophets, similarly, after the death of the Holy Prophet sa , Allah, the Almighty would raise such personalities to rejuvenate his ummah, and this objective was comparatively better achieved by the Khulaf a ’ of the Holy Prophet sa than the previous Khulaf a ’.No doubt, the successors to Hadrat M u sa as (Moses) were Prophets, as were the successors to Hadrat Ibr a h i m as (Abraham), as well as other Prophets as ; but can anyone say that the establishment of faith that was achieved through these Prophets was not achieved by the Khulaf a ’ of the Holy Prophet sa.If we analyze the circumstances with wisdom and insight we will have to say that Joshua as , Ism a ’ i l as (Ishmael), I sha q as (Issac) and Ya‘q u b as (Jacob as ) could not do for the establishment of their religion, what was done by Abu Bakr ra , Umar ra , Usman ra and Ali ra.An

Page 217

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 201 ignorant person may say that my statement about the Prophets is derogatory, but there is actually no element of humiliation in it.When it comes to the question of Prophethood, we’ll say that Abu Bakr ra was not a prophet nor was Umar ra , or Usman ra , or Ali ra.But when there is a question of the establishment of religion, we’ll say that in this matter, the Khulaf a ’ who succeeded the Holy Prophet sa are surely greater than the previous Prophets.The fact is this that since Prophets who were raised before the Holy Prophet sa did not bring complete sharia, either Prophets were raised or kings were appointed after them.When there was the need of revelation for the reformation of the public, a Prophet was raised, and he got the status of Prophethood directly.When there was a problem in the system, a king was appointed.The people had not yet reached the maturity to manage their own affairs.Therefore, Allah, the Almighty directly assigned not only the status of Prophethood but also of kingship.It is said in the Holy Quran: [Allah has appointed for you Tal u t as a king (Al-Baqarah, 2:248) ].The people were still not capable of electing their king nor was the sharia so perfect so as to enable one of its followers the acquisition of Prophethood.On the other hand, the Holy Prophet sa brought a complete code of life, so it resulted in a distinctive status for both types of Khulaf a ’.The Khulaf a ’ of the previous Prophets were Prophets though they were

Page 218

202 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH bestowed Prophethood directly.If the kings were appointed to run the administration, they were not elected but they acquired kingdom either by inheritance or appointment by a Prophet appointed under the command of Allah, the Almighty.As the followers of the Holy Prophet sa were exalted, there was no need of Prophet Khulaf a ’ after him.Similarly, the lesser form of kingdom was also abolished, and a perfect form was granted.It is evident that the promise is fulfilled with the Muslims is through Islamic Khilafat—the element of election is included, and the public rights are preserved.This was not the case of the previous kings.The creation of a better situation is not against the promise.For example, if you promise someone to give him five rupees it would not be a violation of the promise to pay him ten rupees.It only means that just as the Holy Prophet sa was superior to the previous ones, so his Khulaf a ’ are also superior to those of the previous Prophets.“The Ulema of my Ummah are like the Prophets of Ban i Isr a ’ i l’ Refers only to the Spiritual Khulaf a ” The second answer is this that the Holy Prophet sa says, 37 i.e.“The Ulema of my ummah are like the Prophets of Ban i Isr a ’ i l”.It does 37 Al-Mauz u ‘ a tul Kab i r, p.82, by Nuruddin Ali bin Sultan Al-Haraw i known as Mulla Ali Al-Q a r i.Publisher, N u r Muhammad, A ss a h ul Mat a bi‘ wa K a rkh a nah Tij a rat Kutub, A r a m B a gh, Karachi.Published by Educational Press, Karachi.

Page 219

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 203 not mean that every scholar among the Muslims is like the Prophet of Ban i Isr a ’ i l, because there are also so- called scholars whose religious and moral condition is very depressing.At the age of ten or eleven, I went to Amritsar to purchase a few things with my maternal grandfather (deceased).I saw a Maulaw i wearing a long cloak with a staff and a rosary in his hand, walking in Rambagh.Behind him was a poor person begging him repeatedly, “Maulaw i Sahib, for God’s sake give me my money.” After walking a few steps the Maulaw i turned back and said, “Go away, you wretch!” At last the poor man was tired and left him.I asked him what the matter was.He told me that he saved about two hundred rupees with great difficulty for his marriage and, considering the Maulaw i a religious person, he left the money with him as trust.But now on his demand the Maulaw i refused to pay it back, and denied recognizing him as well as his deposit.Can such Ulema be like the Prophets of Ban i Isr a ’ i l? Can it be said that the Hadith of the Prophet sa is concerned with such shameless Islamic “scholars”.The fact is that the Ulema mentioned in this Hadith are actually the Khulaf a ’ who are the spiritual Ulema.The meaning of this saying of the Prophet sa is that the tasks that were performed by Prophets in earlier times would now be entrusted by Allah, the Almighty to some divinely guided Ulema, i.e.the Khulaf a ’-e- R a shid i n.Just as, after Hadrat M u sa as (Moses), his work was entrusted to Joshua as , now this work would

Page 220

204 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH be entrusted to Hadrat Abu Bakr ra.The work of Hadrat David as would be performed by Hadrat Umar ra , and the work of some other Prophets, e.g.Hadrat Suleman as , would be performed by Hadrat Usman ra and Hadrat Ali ra.In short, the Holy Prophet sa has pointed out in his sayings that Allah, the Almighty has given him such a status that in his ummah the Khulaf a ’ will perform the deeds that were performed in earlier times by the Prophets.Here Ulema does not refer to the corrupt ones, but to the scholars Hadrat Abu Bakr ra , Hadrat Umar ra , Hadrat Usman ra , and Hadrat Ali ra.As long as the need remained limited, Allah, the Almighty raised these Ulema, and then when the age was in need of a Prophet more manifestly, Allah, the Almighty fulfilled His promise through the Promised Messiah as.The difference is that the previous Prophets received Prophethood directly but the Promised Messiah as obtained his Prophethood by total submission to the Holy Prophet sa.Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya The third objection is that in this verse the words are [as He made Successors from among those who were before them].Granted that the previous Khulaf a ’ fulfilled this promise, because they headed a political system.But how can the present Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya satisfy this promise, because it does not have any political system under it.

Page 221

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 205 The answer is that Allah, the Almighty has promised that He will appoint as Khalifah the Jam a ‘at that passes the test of faith and acts of goodness.Khalifah means the successor of a predecessor.The minimum condition to satisfy this promise is that after every Prophet there should be successors.This condition would be satisfied if the successor of the Prophet is of the same type as the Prophet whom he succeeds.And as the Promised Messiah as was not in charge of a political system, whoever serves the functions entrusted to his Prophethood would fulfil this promise.Had a political system been assigned to the Promised Messiah as , an objection could have been raised about such successors as do not have political authority.But since a political system was not granted to the Promised Messiah as , this objection cannot be raised.The Khalifah of a Prophet will get the same thing which is given to that Prophet.How can the Khalifah acquire what his Prophet does not have? There is a well-known fact related to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra that he himself used to mention.Whenever he was in need of money, Allah, the Almighty sent it from somewhere.Once somebody gave him thirty two rupees as trust, which he spent to meet some need.After a few days the person came and demanded his money.At that time he did not have it, but he asked him to wait for a while and promised to give it back to him immediately.After ten to fifteen minutes a patient came and placed some money as fee

Page 222

206 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH before him.Hafiz Roshen Ali ra was also sitting there.Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra asked him to give those rupees to him after counting them.He gave the money to the person concerned as directed, received an acknowledgement, but destroyed it.Afterward we asked him what the amount was.He said, “it was exactly what the man had demanded”.Allah, the Almighty helped him in marvelous manners, and sometimes as a divine sign he was blessed with wealth.We considered it the blessings of his prayers.But some people believed that he knew alchemy.When Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra died, a hakim from Delhi came to me, and asked to meet me privately, and I agreed.He first talked in religious terms and praised that Allah, the Almighty had given my father a great honour, and he was the Messenger of Allah.He then added that the son of someone whom God makes a Messenger cannot possibly be a miser.He desired to get my help in some matter and requested me not to treat him miserly.I enquired about the matter.He told me that he was very fond of alchemy and had spent his whole life in pursuing it.He had come to know that Hadrat Maulaw i Sahib ra had a recipe of alchemy.Now, in my capacity as the Khalifah in his place, he must have told me about it.Then he requested me to tell him that recipe.I told him that he had not given me any recipe of alchemy.“How can it be so?” He said.“You are Khalifah in his place, and he did not tell you any recipe of alchemy”.

Page 223

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 207 The more I tried to make him understand that I did not get any such recipe, the more he became certain about my miserliness.I told him repeatedly that I had no knowledge of it.But he again started over praising me, and stressed that he had spent his whole life to find it and continued asking me to tell him about it and not be a miser.When I was fed up with his insistence, Allah, the Almighty guided me to a response and I told him, “Though I have become Khalifah in his place, but as you know, I have not inherited any property of Hadrat Maulaw i Sahib ra.He asked who inherited the property.I told him that his sons did.I further told him that he had a big library, which I did not get, so when I got neither his property nor his library then how could he tell me that recipe of alchemy? If he had given it to somebody, it would have been given to his sons.Go to them and ask them to tell you that recipe.” In this way he left me.Abdul Hayee (deceased) was alive in those days.He went to him and asked him to give that recipe of alchemy.He asked, “Recipe of what type”.“The same recipe of alchemy that your father knew,” said the hakim.He was perplexed as to what to say.At last he gave the same reply that he had no knowledge of any recipe.When he failed, he again came to me and told me that the father’s miserliness was also present in his son.I said, “You are free to think whether he is miserly or not, but I am only a Khalifah and have received only what pertains to it,

Page 224

208 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH nothing else.In short, the successor can only be like his principal.As there was no political system assigned to the Promised Messiah as , the question as to why his Khulaf a ’ did not have it cannot be raised.A yat-e-Istikhl a f Applies to Both the Nubuwwat and Khilafat of the Promised Messiah as Another reply is that the words, [as He made Successors from among those who were before them] are not confined to a political system.Instead, these words apply to all the promises made in the verse.But the dissentients who believe in the Nubuwwat of the Promised Messiah as , e.g.Sheikh Mi s r i etc., admit that the Nubuwwat of the Promised Messiah as does not correspond with the Nubuwwat of the previous Prophets.As the Promised Messiah as has written himself his Nubuwwat differs greatly from that of the previous Prophets in that the previous Prophets were appointed independently, while he is a subordinate Prophet.Just as the fulfillment of the promise “He will surely make them Successors in the earth, as He made Successors from among those who were before them” does not suffer from any deficiency because of the different nature of his Prophethood;

Page 225

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 209 similarly, the variation of his Khilafat causes no deficiency in the fulfillment of this promise.If it is argued that the variation from previous Khulaf a ’ takes Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya out of the sphere of this promise, then one would also have to admit that the Prophethood of the Promised Messiah as also does not fall within the sphere of this verse.Our Khilafat varies to some extent from that of the Hadrat Abu Bakr ra and Hadrat Umar ra , but the Prophethood of the Promised Messiah as also varies to some extent from that of the previous Prophets.If our Khilafat is not under this verse then we will have to admit that (God forbid) the Prophethood of the Promised Messiah as is also not under this verse.However, in spite of variation, the Promised Messiah as treats his Prophethood as a fulfillment of this verse.Just as the Prophethood of the Promised Messiah as , in spite of variation from the previous Prophets, is included in the promise made in this verse, this Khilafat—though it differs from the previous Khilafats—is also included in the promise made in this verse.No Connection of the Khulaf a ’ of ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) with the Management of the Country Thirdly, successors of ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) were not concerned with managing the affairs of their countries.If someone objects that Jesus as was not

Page 226

210 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH succeeded by Khulaf a’ , they must first consider that the Holy Prophet sa himself said, 38.“There had not been any Prophethood which was not succeeded by Khilafat.” If ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) was bestowed Prophethood, then we must admit that the same type of Khilafat was established after him as was granted to all other Prophets.Otherwise, the critics will be forced to maintain that ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) was not a Prophet, because the Holy Prophet sa has made Khilafat necessary after Prophethood.A second consideration is that Christians themselves have acknowledged Peter as the successor.Thus, when the Holy Prophet sa stated that Khilafat existed after every Prophet, and Christians themselves acknowledge Peter as Khalifah of ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ), then what is the basis for the claim of this third group, which claims that ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) was not followed by Khilafat? The person who was granted knowledge by Allah, the Almighty (i.e., the Holy Prophet sa ) said that Khilafat was established after every Prophet.When Christians, for whom this is an internal matter, also claim that Khilafat was established after ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ), and it has been proven by history, then the denial of it is only a 38 Kanzul Umm a l f i Sunanil Aqw a l wal Af‘ a l, Vol.11, p.476, Hadith No.32246, by Al a ’uddin Ali bin Hass a muddin Al-Muttaq i Al-Hind i Al- Burh a nf u ri.First edition, AH 1394, AD 1947, published by At-Tur a th Al- Isl a mi Halb.

Page 227

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 211 contradiction.If it is asserted that certain Christians did not accept Peter as Khalifah, then the answer is that certain Muslims also do not accept the four Righteous Khulaf a ’.The matter is not nullified by their rejection.A third consideration is that the Promised Messiah as has pointed out in Al-Wa s iyyat [The Will] that such a system was established among the Christians He writes: “Believers face difficulties and problems and the enemy gains force and thinks that now all is lost [as for as the mission of the Prophet is concerned], and is convinced that it is the time win the community [of the followers of Prophet] will be wiped off the face of the earth, and even members of the community start dithering and plunge into despair, feeling so helpless, and a few of them who are unfortunate resort to apostasy, then God, for the second time, shows His Mighty Power and supports and takes care of the community which was about to fall.Thus a person, who remains steadfast till the end, sees this miracle of God.As is happened at the time of Hadrat Abu Bakr S idd i q ra , when the death of the Holy Prophet sa was considered untimely and many an ignorant Bedouin turned apostate.The Companions ra of the Holy Prophet sa , too, stricken with grief, became like those who lose their senses.Then

Page 228

212 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Allah raised Abu Bakr S idd i q ra and showed for the second time the manifestation of His Power… That is also what happened at the time of M u sa as (Moses)….The same happened with Christ as.” 39 Just as Hadrat Abu Bakr ra became Khalifah after the Holy Prophet sa , Khilafat was similarly established after Hadrat M u sa as (Moses) and ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ).So a person who argues that there was no Khilafat after ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) does so entirely against the saying of the Promised Messiah as , and presents such an argument which is not supported by the A ha d i th of the Holy Prophet sa nor history, nor is it supported by the Promised Messiah as.Another Objection of the Opponents and Its Response The fourth objection is that if this verse refers to persons, then it raises another issue: it is concerned with two types of personalities—Prophets and kings.As for the type of Prophets who appeared before the Holy Prophet sa , they ceased to come after him.As for the kings he did not like it; he clearly stated that the Khulaf a ’ who follow him would not be kings.Thus it is argued that we should take the promise in this verse to apply to the nation as a whole, and not to 39 Al-Wa s iyyat , pp.6-7, R uha n i Khaz a’ in , Vol.20, by Hadrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian.

Page 229

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 213 individuals.The answer is that there is no doubt that previous types of Prophethood have come to an end, as is the case with previous kings.But the end of these specific types of successors does not mean that better successors will not come.As the Holy Prophet sa is singular among all Prophets, so it is necessary that his system should be unique among all systems.Its uniqueness does not exclude it from the sphere of resemblance.However, it increases its elegance and excellence.As Hadrat Muhammad sa was the perfect Prophet and brought the perfect sharia, it was necessary that prophets appearing after him should have received the status of Prophethood by his grace.Similarly, his system was more perfect than all others, so it is necessary that there should be such Khulaf a ’ who are elected by public.In short, Allah, the Almighty moulded Prophethood and kingdom in a new shape and abolished the previous type of Prophethood and kingdom.The Khilafat of Previous Prophets—Both in the form of Prophethood and Kingship—was Imperfect It should be remembered that a Prophet Khalifah comes to support the previous Prophet, and a King Khalifah comes to protect the rights of believers, and to nurture their faculties.Now we can see that the Prophets who were assigned as the Khulaf a ’ of previous Prophets were

Page 230

214 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH imperfect as Khulaf a ’ because they discharged their duties, but they received Prophethood directly.Therefore their Khilafat was not perfect.Similarly, if their people received the kingdom then also they were not perfect as Khulaf a ’ because they directly inherited the power.Consequently the faculties of their people were not nurtured because the public was not involved in their appointment, and there was no involvement of initial Prophets in the Prophethood of their subordinate Prophets.Whenever authority is inherited by the son or the grandson by inheritance, no need is felt to raise the level of learning and the growth of the faculties of the common man to the extent that they may elect their authorities properly.But when the election of the authorities is in the hands of public, the government is bound to make every person well- informed, gain an awareness of the political situation and public affairs, so that they may not make an unwise choice at the time of election.Islam is the only religion that directs the election of authorities, thus addressing the need for increasing awareness of public affairs.In short, the Khilafat of the Prophets before the Holy Prophet sa , whether it took the form of Prophets or kings, was imperfect.As the Holy Prophet sa was the perfect Prophet in the real sense; the one who had to come after him or will come, would have to be his subordinate, and would receive Prophethood only by

Page 231

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 215 his blessings.Similarly his people were the ummah par excellence in the real sense, as it is said, ( A l-e-‘Imr a n, 3:111) “You are the best people raised for the good of mankind”.It is, therefore, necessary that those who serve its causes also have public involvement in their election.Therefore Allah, the Almighty decided not to appoint King Khulaf a ’ (in whose election the people are not involved).It was decreed that there should be an elected Khalifah to fully represent Ummat-e- Muhammadiyya, and to ensure the proper growth of the faculty of the ummah.Due to this command every Khalifah is bound to create a maximum awareness so that the public does not commit any mistake in the forthcoming election.This is so because of the distinction of the Holy Prophet sa who is the Chief of all the Prophets, and his ummah is the best of all.Just as the subordinate Prophets of the chief of Prophets received Prophethood by his blessings, so the Khulaf a ’ of the best ummah are appointed by the consent of the ummah.Therefore, this system is due to the superiority of Islam, the Prophet of Islam and the magnanimity of Ummat-e-Islamiyya.The Khilafat of an individual is not abolished but the Khilafat of an individual is presented in a better and more excellent

Page 232

216 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH form.Having answered these basic questions I must now address one or two subsidiary objections.Is Promise of Khilafat limited to the Khalifah immediately succeeding the Prophet Another objection that is made about the promised Khilafat mentioned in this verse is that it only applies to the Khalifah who comes immediately after the Prophet, and not to a long chain of Khulaf a ’ following the first.The reply to this objection is that the Holy Prophet sa himself addressed the four Khulaf a ’ succeeding him as Khilafat-e-R a shidah.There is a Hadith: 40 i.e.“ Hadrat Saf i nah ra says that he heard the Prophet sa saying that: after him Khilafat would last in his ummah for thirty years.After it there would be kingdom.” The period of four Khulaf a ’ is only thirty years.Since the Holy Prophet sa himself extends the period of Khilafat to four Khulaf a ’, who has the right to confine it to the first Khalifah? 40 Musnad Ahmad bin Hambal, Vol.5, p.222, by Ahmad bin Muhammad bin Hambal bin Hil a l bin Asad, published by Baitul Afk a r Ad-Dauliyya, Al- Ri ad , AH 1419, AD 1998.Note: Volume and page No.are according to Nuskha Maimaniyyah.

Page 233

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 217 Some people say that the Promised Messiah as has mentioned this in Sirrul-Khil a fah , but it is not true.Whatever he said was to refute the Shias who say that the real successor of the Holy Prophet sa was Hadrat Ali ra.In reply to this allegation he says, the promise of Khilafat is in the verse of the Holy Quran: The conditions mentioned in it are found by degree of perfection in Hadrat Abu Bakr ra.41 He means that the Khilafat of Hadrat Abu Bakr ra is more firmly established than that of Hadrat Ali ra , not that Hadrat Ali ra was not a Khalifah.He has also used the term four Khulaf a ’ in his books.42 He has also specifically mentioned the Khilafat of Hadrat Ali ra.43 Further proof regarding this is that of the late Maulaw i Abdul Karim ra delivered a lecture to refute the Shias’ viewpoint.In it he proved the Khilafat of Hadrat Abu Bakr ra , Hadrat Umar ra and Hadrat Usman ra , and has also the Khilafat of Hadrat Ali ra at several places.Later on, he published the lecture with some additions in book form named Khilafat-e-R a shidah.In this book he pointed out that the Promised Messiah as heard his lecture and read it time and again, and even quoted 41 Sirrul-Khil a fah , R uha n i Khaz a ’in by Hadrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian as , Vol.8, pp.333-334.42 Ibid, p.326.43 Ibid, pp.358-359.

Page 234

218 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH part of it in his book H ujjatull a h and has also sent it as gift from his own self to his friends at different places.It shows that the Promised Messiah as agreed with the viewpoint of Hadrat Maulaw i Abdul Karim ra , which he mentioned in Khilafat-e-R a shidah.44 The second answer is that when the Khilafat of the first Khalifah is proven then the others’ is proven automatically.Just as Hadrat Abu Bakr ra became the first Khalifah, he then selected Hadrat Umar ra after consultation with Muslims and appointed him Khalifah.In this age Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra once gave a command by naming me, and a second time made a will without naming me.However, he established the Khilafat.The words of his will are: “This humble writes with full awareness that: [There is none to worship except Allah; Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah] My successor should be a righteous, popular, hard-working scholar, tolerant and forgiving in conduct with new and old friends of the Promised Messiah as.I am well wisher of all.He should also be a well wisher.Teaching of Quran and A ha d i th should continue.” Wassalam Nuruddin 44 Khilafat-e-R a shidah by Hadrat Maulaw i Abdul Karim, part I, p.110, published by Zia-ul-Islam Qadian, August 1904.

Page 235

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 219 March 4 45 At another place he said that he was made Khalifah by Allah, the Almighty, and after him, God will appoint a Khalifah.He said, “Khilafat is not the soda water of a provisional store.You cannot get any benefit from this disputation.You cannot be appointed as Khalifah by someone nor can anyone else be made Khalifah in my lifetime.When I shall die he whom God desires will be raised, and God Himself will raise him.” 46 Therefore, if the previous Khulaf a ’ were under the command of this verse, then their decisions are also in its support.After them Khilafat will continue in the same form as theirs, and their decisions are binding in this respect, because Allah, the Almighty says: “He will surely establish for them their religion which He has chosen for them.” A third reply is when causes are present, then why should not their natural consequences be present? Either one must admit that there was no need of Khilafat later, and the ummah was also devoid of those who believe and do good deeds, or the existence of Khilafat will have to be admitted.45 Al-Fa d l , Qadian, 11 March, 1914.46 Badr , Qadian, 11 July, 1912.

Page 236

220 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Is it lawful to Remove a Khalifah? Another objection is made that since the Khalifah is chosen by election, it should be lawful for the ummah to remove him.The answer is that though the appointment of the Khalifah is made through election, the clear and decisive verdict of the Holy Quran is that Allah, the Almighty makes the ummah a medium of implementing His will in this matter.He specially enlightens their minds but the real decision is made by Allah, the Almighty Himself.Therefore, He says: “He will surely make them Successors”.Though the election of Khulaf a ’ is through the believers the revelation of Allah, the Almighty inclines the hearts of the people to the rightful person.It is also revealed that Allah, the Almighty creates such and such qualities in these Khulaf a ’; they are a bounty of the Divine.In this situation the objection amounts to saying that the ummah has the right to dismiss a person who is an absolute monotheist, and the establishment of the religion through him is affirmed by Allah, the Almighty, Who has promised to remove all dangers, and through whom He wanted to exterminate polytheism, and wants to save Islam.It is evident that Ummat-e-Islamiyya cannot dismiss such a person.Only the disciples of Satan can do so.The second reply is that here the word is “promise” and it indicates a favour.This objection would mean that Allah, the Almighty has kept the election of the favour in the hands of ummah.Why

Page 237

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 221 does the ummah not have the right to revoke that favour? Every sensible person will agree that this inference is the worst one.Rejection of the favour which is available without demand makes a person more sinful, and leaves him no way to escape from the manifest blame.Allah, the Almighty will tell the people that He left it at their will to have favour in whatever they please.They desired favour in the form of such a person with whom He has attached His favour.When He honours their verdict, then how can they say that they are not satisfied with this favour? On this He will say, (Ibr a h i m, 14:8) “If you are ungrateful, My punishment is severe indeed.” It is therefore pointed out, (Al-N u r, 24:56) “Then whoso is ungrateful after that, they will be the rebellious.” In other words Allah, the Almighty is saying that at the time of election We gave the right to the ummah but as in this election We guide the ummah, and We make the person Our own, therefore the ummah has no right afterwards; and even then if a person insists upon exercising such a right, he should remember that

Page 238

222 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH he does not confront the Khalifah but he is unappreciative of Allah’s favour.Thus the verse, indicates that even if at the time of election such a person was included in the believers who do good works, due to his action his name will be recorded in Allah’s court in the list of rebels and will be deleted from the list of those who do good works.A Point to Ponder Look! What a wonderful thing Allah, the Almighty has mentioned in this verse.The heir of the award of Khilafat is that nation who: i) has faith, i.e.whose intents are noble.Hadrat Umar ra said, 47 The actions of believers are limited but his intents are very vast.Therefore, the intents of the believers are very noble.ii) They represent those who do good works (i.e.who are pious), but Allah, the Almighty adds that when they deny Khilafat they become rebels.It means the one who turns out of the circle of obedience is deprived of the companionship of the Prophet, even though they were pious and had good intentions.47 Al-Mu‘jamul Kab i r , Vol.6, pp.185,186, by Abul Q a sim Suleman bin Ahmad At- T abar a n i , publisher D a ru I h y a ’ittur a thil Arabi, Beirut.Second edition, AH 1405, AD 1985.

Page 239

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 223 This verse’s theme is that Khilafat is granted to the pious people whose plans are noble.But those who deny it, in spite of possessing noble plans and piety, are deprived of the companionship of the Prophet.Now place the words of this verse in the context of the dream of the Promised Messiah as , which he saw about Maulaw i Muhammad Ali, and in which he addressed him, “You were also righteous and meant well, come and sit down with us”.48 It reveals that it is exactly the same thing which is mentioned in the words, “those who believe and do good works”.And “then whoso is ungrateful after that, they will be the rebellious.” It is not mentioned in this dream whether this person accompanied the Promised Messiah as or not.But the Quranic words reveal that such a person does not receive the blessing of companionship.i.e.“To Allah we belong, and to Him shall we return”.48 Tadhkirah , English Edition, Translated by Muhammad Zafarullah Khan, p.296, published by Saffron Books, 1976.Tadhkirah, Urdu, Edition 4, p.435, published at Zia-ul-Islam Press, Rabwah, 2004.

Page 240

224 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Another Verse in Favour of Khilafat-e- R a shidah Another verse mentioned in the Holy Quran that is proof of Khilafat is: (Al-Baqrah, 2:125) “And remember when his Lord tried Abraham with certain commands which he fulfilled.He said, ‘I will make thee a leader of men.’ Abraham asked, ‘And from among my offspring?’ He said, ‘My covenant does not embrace the transgressors.’” In this verse a covenant was made with Hadrat Ibr a h i m as (Abraham) to make him the Leader.Hadrat Ibr a h i m as (Abraham) instantly and rightly felt that the task which was going to be assigned to him could not be accomplished in one generation, and people after him were needed to continue the task.He thus requested to make his offspring these leaders.Allah, the Almighty promised to do so but His covenant would not embrace the transgressors.In this verse the covenant is with the offspring and not with the transgressors.But who can say that only leaders and transgressors comprised the offspring of Hadrat Ibr a h i m as (Abraham)? In addition to the two he had

Page 241

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 225 offspring which did not belong to either category.How was the covenant of leadership fulfilled for them? Some of them received leadership and some were benefited through those leaders.This verse also replies to the objection of the verse of Succession that the covenant was made with all, then how can the Khilafat be personalized.I am, however, pointing to a different aspect of the verse that the covenant of leadership was made with the offspring of Hadrat Ibr a h i m as (Abraham).How was the covenant fulfilled? After him there were four Prophets from his offspring, i.e.Hadrat Ism a ‘ i l as (Ishmael), Hadrat Is ha q as (Isaac), Hadrat Ya‘q u b as (Jacob) and Hadrat Y u suf as (Joseph).These four Prophet Khulaf a ’ accomplished the mission of Hadrat Ibr a h i m as (Abraham).The four are mentioned at another place in the Holy Quran: (Al-Baqarah, 2:261) “And remember when Abraham said, ‘My Lord, show me how You give life to the dead.’ He said, ‘Have you not believed?’ He said, ‘Yes, but I ask this that my heart may be at

Page 242

226 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH rest.’ He answered, ‘Take four birds and make them attached to you.Then put each of them on a hill; then call them; they will come to you in haste.And know that Allah is Mighty, Wise.’” If this incident were taken literally there would have arisen many objections to it.First, what is the relation of taming birds with the restoration of the dead to life? Second, what is meant by the taking of four birds? That is, why was the taming of just one not enough proof? Third, what is the benefit of putting them on the hills? That is, why is putting them on any other place not workable.The fact is that it is not a statement to be taken literally, but has deeper implicit meanings.Hadrat Ibr a h i m as (Abraham) prayed, “O God! Show me the fulfilment of the obligation of the restoration of dead to life, which you have assigned to me, and reveal to me how national life will be created.I am old and the task is very heavy.” Allah, the Almighty said, “It will certainly happen as We have promised”.Hadrat Ibr a h i m as (Abraham) said, “No doubt, it will happen, but for the satisfaction of my heart I ask, when will these adverse circumstances change”? Allah, the Almighty commanded “tame four birds and put them on the hills one by one, then call them and look how swiftly they fly towards you”.That means, train four of your offspring.On your call they will accomplish the task of restoration to life.These four, as I have said, are Hadrat Ism a ’ i l as (Ishmael), Hadrat Is ha q as

Page 243

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 227 (Issac), Hadrat Ya‘q u b as (Jacob) and Hadrat Y u suf as (Joseph).Out of them two were directly trained by Hadrat Ibr a h i m as (Abraham) and the other two indirectly.To place them on the hills means to train them well because they destined to be great in their lifetimes.Therefore, to place them on hills means the elevation of their status.It indicates that they will be high in rank like the top of the hills.In this way the layout of the national revival, which was to occur swiftly in the age of Hadrat Ibr a h i m as (Abraham), was disclosed to him.Now observe that the Holy Prophet sa also possesses a likeness to Hadrat Ibr a h i m as (Abraham).The Muslims who offer Dur u d know that the Holy Prophet sa has taught the prayer “O Allah bestow Your blessings and generosity on Muhammad and his descendants, just as You bestowed blessings and generosity on Abraham and his descendants.Indeed only You are worthy of all praise being exalted in honour.O Allah, bestow Your bounties on Muhammad and his descendants, just as You bestowed bounties on Abraham and his descendants.Indeed You are worthy of all praise being exalted in honour.” But when the Holy Prophet sa is superior to Hadrat Ibr a h i m as (Abraham) then surely there can be an indication of a special characteristic in this Dur u d , (i.e.leadership and Prophethood in his offspring).Indeed Almighty Allah mentions,

Page 244

228 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH (Al-‘Ankab u t, 29:28) “We placed the gift of Prophethood and the Book among his descendants, and We gave him his reward in this life, and in the Hereafter he will surely be among the righteous.” The excellence that Hadrat Ibr a h i m as (Abraham) received was of Prophethood and after him offspring continuously received prophetic Khilafat which filled his house with honor.Once somebody asked the Holy Prophet sa : “O Messenger of Allah! Who is the most honoured one? He replied, ‘The person who is the most righteous.’ ‘O Messenger of Allah! That is not my question.’ He replied, ‘Then Y u suf as is greatly honoured.He himself was a prophet, and also a son of a Prophet.His grandfather was also a Prophet and his great grandfather Hadrat Abraham as was also a Prophet’.” 49 When we say, “just as You bestowed blessings and generosity” or just as You bestowed Your bounties we pray to Allah, the Almighty to give the same 49 Bukh a r i , Kit a b-ul-Anbiy a ’, B a bo Qaulill a hi Ta‘ a l a laqad k a na f i Y u sufa wa Ikhwatih i , by Muhammad bin Ism a ’ i l Abu Abdullah Al-Bukh a r i Al- Ju‘f i , publisher, D a r ibni Kath i r Al-Yam a mah, Beirut.

Page 245

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 229 excellence to the Holy Prophet sa which He gave to Hadrat Ibr a h i m as (Abraham) both in his person and to his offspring (i.e.He may become the father of Prophets and Prophethood be bestowed upon his spiritual descendants.Allah, the Almighty honoured this prayer.Just as there were four Prophets after Hadrat Ibr a h i m as (Abraham), so there were also four Khulaf a ’ after the Holy Prophet sa who excelled in religion.The Prophets were born in the race of Hadrat Ibr a h i m as (Abraham) and the glad tidings of the arrival of Prophets in the later period of the Holy Prophet sa was also given.The Holy Prophet sa was made superior in this matter too, i.e.Hadrat Ibr a h i m as (Abraham) educated two Khulaf a ’ directly and two indirectly, but the Holy Prophet sa trained his four Khulaf a ’ personally.If this is not resemblance, then what can be the meaning of “just as You bestowed blessings and generosity and just as You bestowed Your bounties”.Critics would then have to concede that status of Hadrat Ibr a h i m as (Abraham) might be higher than the Holy Prophet sa.In conclusion, the combination of the promise made to Hadrat Ibr a h i m as (Abraham) and the Dur u d clearly reveal that the same thing would also happen with the Holy Prophet sa , and the appointment of Khulaf a ’ for the honour of his religion is expected after him.If one objects that Hadrat Abraham’s as Khulaf a ’ were Prophets but the Holy Prophet’s sa were not, the reply is this that there were, in fact, two promises of leadership for the offspring of Hadrat Ibr a h i m as

Page 246

230 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH (Abraham).One was in the near period and the other in remote period in which M u sa as (Moses), Jesus as and Hadrat Muhammad sa , and Promised Messiah as were included.In His wisdom, Allah, the Almighty decreed that the leaders of the near period of the Holy Prophet’s ummah should be leader Khulaf a ’, and that of the remote period be Prophet Khalifah, so that Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n would bear great resemblance in light of the Holy Prophet’s sa statement that, 50 “The Ulema of my ummah will be like the Prophets of Ban i Isr a ’ i l,” even though they were not Prophets.The last Khalifah is an ummati in one respect and a Prophet in another respect, so that no deficiency may be left in order of resemblance.Observe how under the training of the Holy Prophet sa , these four Khulaf a ’ glorified their religion more than those Prophets (of Ban i Isr ai l); this is another great proof of the spiritual grace of the Holy Prophet sa.The words of the Promised Messiah as also remove any confusion.He mentions in Al-Wa s iyyat that: 50 Al-Mau du ‘ a tul Kab i r, p.82, by Nuruddin Ali bin Sultan Al-Haraw i known as Mulla Ali Al-Q a r i.Publisher, N u r Muhammad, A ss a h ul Mat a bi‘ wa K a rkh a nah Tij a rat Kutub, A r a m B a gh, Karachi.Published by Educational Press, Karachi.

Page 247

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 231 Allah, the Almighty showed His Divine Power by raising Abu Bakr ra and saved Islam from ruin, and fulfilled this promise that: “[He will surely establish for them their religion which He has chosen for them.He will surely give them in exchange security and peace after their fear…] The same thing happened at the time of Hadrat Moses as.” 51 It is evident from this quotation that the Promised Messiah as has accepted the resemblance of Abu Bakr ra with the successor Prophet of Hadrat M u sa as (Moses).A tradition of the Holy Prophet sa also illuminates this point.He says that “if there would have been any Prophet after me, it would have been Umar bin Al Khatab”.52 It means that Hadrat Umar ra would have been the Imam after him.If Almighty Allah were to carry out Prophethood right after him, then Hadrat Umar ra would have been the Prophet, but instead he is the Imam and not a Prophet.51 Al-Wa s iyyat , R uha n i Khaz a ‘in , Vol.20, pp.304-305, by Hadrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmad of Qadian as.52 Sunan Tirmidh i , Abw a bul Man a qib, b a bun Man a qibi Ali bin Abi- Ta lib, Hadith No.3724, by Muhammad bin ‘ I s a Abu ‘ I s a At-Tirmidh i , publisher D a ru I h y a ’ittur a thil Arabi, Beirut.

Page 248

232 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Another tradition also illuminates this point.Once the Holy Prophet sa went to war and made Hadrat Ali ra his deputy.All the hypocrites had been left behind with Hadrat Ali ra.He became embarrassed and met the Prophet sa to request him to take him too.He consoled him and said, “O Ali! You have the likeness of H a r u n as (Aron) and M u s a as (Moses) with me, but you are not the Prophet after me”.53 In other words, one day you will be my Khalifah.However, you will not be a Prophet, despite this resemblance.Just as Hadrat Ali ra can be like Hadrat Haroon as , so can all four Khulaf a ’ also be like four other Prophets.Besides this the evidence is also available that Khulaf a ’ can be described as similar to Prophets.This throws light on the disturbances during the Khilafat of Hadrat Ali ra.There is also a prophecy in the Holy Prophet’s sa consolation above that just as there was a disturbance in the time of Hadrat H a r u n as (Aron), this would also be so in the time of Hadrat Ali ra.The people would accuse Hadrat Ali ra but those allegations would be as false as those levied against Hadrat H a r u n as (Aron).It is such a false allegation that they committed apostasy.However, the act of Hadrat Ali ra was similar to that of Hadrat H a r u n as (Aron), and due to the apprehension of disruption he was somewhat 53 Bukh a r i , Kit a b-ul-Magh a z i , B a bo Ghazwatit-Tab u k , by Muhammad bin Ism a ’ i l Abu Abdullah Al-Bukh a r i Al-Ju‘f i , publisher, D a r ibni Kath i r Al- Yam a mah, Beirut.

Page 249

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 233 mild in behaviour.For example, at the time of the battle of S af i n, he accepted the arbitration.A Command of the Holy Prophet sa Related to Khilafat After this I quote one Hadith as an authority in support of Khilafat, because time does not permit more.The Holy Prophet sa said, 54 “There had not been any Prophethood which was not succeeded by Khilafat.” The denial of Khilafat after this general principle amounts to an attack on the Holy Prophet sa and the denial of the Prophethood of the Promised Messiah as because it is the general rule mentioned by the Holy Prophet sa.A Grave Objection on the Rights of Khulaf a ’ Now I take up an objection which is very common.It is related to the rights of a Khalifah.It is our belief; as proved from the verse of Succession and from the verse: “and those who are in authority among you” and also from: ( A l-e-‘Imr a n, 3:160) 54 Al-Kha sa ‘i s ul Kubr a , part II, p.115, by Abu Fa d l Jalaluddin Abdur Rehman bin Abu Bakr As-Suy uti Ash-Sh a fi‘ i , published by Al-Maktabatun N u riyyah Ar-Ri d wiyya, Lyallpur, Pakistan.

Page 250

234 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH “consult them in matters of administration; and when you are determined, then put your trust in Allah”.that though Khulaf a ’ are bound to make consultation in important matters of administration they are not bound to act upon them.Some people have questioned that it is against the teachings of Islam.The first Khalifah, Hadrat Abu Bakr ra , said, “If I show any crookedness then set me right”.55 It is argued that this shows that the public has the right to check the Khalifah.Dissentients always raise this objection that when Hadrat Abu Bakr ra said it, it is a proof that a Khalifah can be wrong, and so the public has the right to check him and put him on the right path forcibly.The answer is that the acts of Hadrat Abu Bakr ra is testimony to the fact that he never took the meaning of his words from these critics, nor did the Muslims ever take the theme of his speech to mean that whenever they found the opinion of Hadrat Abu Bakr ra against their own, that they could set him right forcibly.When the great Companions ra met Hadrat Abu Bakr ra to stop the departure of the army of Hadrat Usama ra , they did not address him by saying, “agree with our advice 55 Al-K a mil fit T a r i kh , Vol.2, p.332, by ‘Izzuddin Abul Hasan Ali bin Abul Karam Muhammad bin Muhammad bin Abdul Kar i m bin Abdul W ah id Ash-sh i b a n i , known as Ibnil Ath i r, publisher D a ru Sa dir, D a r Beirut, AH 1385, AD 1965.

Page 251

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 235 otherwise we’ll set you right.” Instead, when he rejected the advice of all of them and said, I cannot stop the army of Usama ra , they withdrew their suggestion.Similarly when the Companions ra requested him to be lenient with the rebels, he rejected their request and said, “I’ll treat them similarly to those others who have turned their backs.” Even on this occasion the Companions ra did not say, “If you do not accept our word we’ll set you right,” but they admitted their fault and yielded before the verdict of Hadrat Abu Bakr ra.Similarly, whenever he had to face the people he always affirmed that he was right, and they were wrong.It is not seen anywhere that the people have ever set him right, or he told the people, “O Muslims, I have become crooked, so set me right.” Therefore, the only meanings that can be taken from his words are those which corroborate with the commands of God and His Messenger sa ; and correspond to his own acts, and not with those of his opponents.Crookedness only means Open Infidelity It should be remembered that his crookedness means open infidelity, mentioned in A ha d i th.What Hadrat Abu Bakr ra told them was: “As long as I practice Islam, it is obligatory upon you to obey me, and if I abandon Islam and commit open infidelity, then it is obligatory upon you to check me”.

Page 252

236 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH Otherwise it did not condone criticism of his daily routine following whatever corresponded to their will.Could Hadrat Abu Bakr ra Commit Open Infidelity If anybody asks whether Hadrat Abu Bakr ra could commit open infidelity, the answer would begin by questioning whether Hadrat Abu Bakr ra could be crooked that the Muslims would feel the need to set him right.Such a condition could only be created when the Companions ra proved from the Holy Quran and A ha d i th that he had gone against the word of the Holy Quran and A ha d i th.Was it possible for Hadrat Abu Bakr ra to take a step against the Holy Quran and A ha d i th ? And for the Muslims to feel the need to set him right by force? Such type of crookedness and open infidelity was not possible for him.But to make it clear he stated that the eternal truth is the greatest of all things.It did not mean (God forbid) that he could commit the open infidelity.But it was his contention that being in the position of Khalifah, it was his job to spread the teachings of his Prophet sa and obedience in the real sense.Therefore, he pointed out to them that the eternal truth is above everything, and they should never leave the real teaching even if he himself spoke against it.

Page 253

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 237 Some Precedents of the Holy Quran Now I will tell you that such types of proverbial sayings are present in the Holy Quran.Hadrat Shuaib as said: (Al-A‘r a f, 7:90) “And it behoves us not to return thereto except that Allah, our Lord should so will.” When the infidels asked Hadrat Shuaib as to join them, he said that it was totally impossible to join their religion except that his God should so will.Now can anybody say that it was possible to make Hadrat Shuaib as an infidel? Surely it was not possible for him to be an infidel, because he was a Prophet of Allah, the Almighty.The purpose was to demonstrate the position and greatness of Allah, the Almighty.It was impossible for him to be an infidel.There is no greatness of his self, but this position he had achieved was only by the help of Allah, the Almighty.This virtue vanishes if He is not there.Similarly Allah, the Almighty made the Holy Prophet sa speak such words.The Holy Quran reveals: (Al-Zukhruf, 43:82) “ O Muhammad sa , tell the people that if there had been a son of God, you would have been the first of the worshipers.”

Page 254

238 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH The verse does not mean that there is a possibility of a son being born to Allah, the Almighty.It only means that there is surely no son to God.If there had been, then a person like the Holy Prophet sa , the most obedient, would have been the first to worship him.In short, it was totally impossible for Hadrat Abu Bakr ra to commit open infidelity.But just to impress upon the minds of the people the importance of the eternal truth, he said, “If I also go against it, then do not care of me.” An Event in the Life of the Promised Messiah as Similar is an event of the Promised Messiah as.There was a person named Miy a ń Nizam D i n in his age.When the Promised Messiah as claimed that ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) had died, it created uproar in the whole of India.In those days Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra was in Lahore taking leave for few days from Jammu.Maulaw i Muhammad Husain Batalwi also reached there and gave a challenge of debate to him on this issue in the light of A ha d i th.Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra made it clear that A ha d i th is not dominant over the Quran, so they should decide the matter in the light of the verses of the Holy Quran.The controversy continued for many days, and posters were also published by each side.Miy a ń Ni za m D i n was the friend of Maulaw i Muhammad Husain, and was also close to the Promised Messiah as.He decided to

Page 255

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 239 resolve this issue.He thought that Mirza Sahib, a pious man, could not say anything contrary to the Holy Quran.He must have told something to Maulaw i Muhammad Husain which he could not comprehend, and so Maulaw i Muhammad Husain had gotten ready to oppose it with passion; otherwise how could he possibly deny the physical life of ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) which is evident from the Holy Quran? A pious and righteous person like Mirza Sahib could not claim the death of ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) contrary to the Holy Quran.He came to Qadian with great fervour and asked the Promised Messiah as that he had heard his claim about the death of ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ).He affirmed his claim.He said that if it was proved from the Holy Quran that ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) was alive physically then he would abandon his belief.The Promised Messiah as replied, “If the physical life of ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) should be proved from the Holy Quran, then I will certainly believe him to be alive.” On hearing it he became very pleased and said that he already had in mind that as Mirza Sahib was very pious man, he could not say deliberately anything contrary to the Holy Quran.He must have misunderstood something, and if it is removed then it would not be difficult to get him to believe in the physical life of ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ).Thus he asked, “If I bring out hundred verses from the Holy Quran to prove the physical life of ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ), then will you believe it?” The Promised Messiah as said,

Page 256

240 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH “Leave the hundred, even one verse is sufficient for me.” He said, “If not one-hundred, I’ll surely bring fifty”.The Promised Messiah as said, “I have told you that for me only one verse is sufficient.There is no question of hundred or fifty.” He again asked, “If it is so, then I’ll surely bring ten such verses to prove the physical living of ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ).” He went straight to Lahore, and met Maulaw i Muhammad Husain.In the meanwhile the debate of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra and Maulaw i Muhammad Husain Batalwi became prolonged for a period.Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra admitted under pressure that supporting A ha d i th from Bukh a r i could be presented along with the Holy Quran.Maulaw i Muhammad Husain Batalwi was very pleased with this victory, and was boasting with great zeal that he had persuaded Nuruddin ra very much, and knocked him down in such a manner that he, at last, had to admit that A ha d i th could be presented along with the Holy Quran.It was just by chance that Miy a ń Nizam D i n encountered him when he was boasting.He asked him to leave the debate aside, and said that on his visit to Qadian he had got the consent of Mirza Sahib that if he brought out ten such verses to prove the physical living of ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ), he would abandon his belief, and he demanded to give him ten such verses hurriedly to resolve the dispute, so that he could get Mirza Sahib to believe in the physical life of ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) in the sky.

Page 257

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 241 When Maulaw i Muhammad Husain Batalwi, who was proudly saying that he persuaded Nuruddin ra so much that he had to accept his defeat, heard the words of Miy a ń Nizam D i n he flared up and said angrily, “Who was so foolish to ask you to go to Mirza Sahib.In two months I brought Nuruddin ra to A ha d i th with great struggle, and again you have turned the direction of the debate towards the Quran.” He [Miy a ń Nizam D i n] was a noble man, and when he heard this, he remained quiet for some time wonderstruck.Then he addressed him, “O Maulaw i Sahib, if there is no proof of the physical life of ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ), then where there is the Quran, there am I.” Saying this he went to the Promised Messiah as and took his Bai‘at.Now look how Allah, the Almighty clarified this fact to the Promised Messiah as that ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) had died, and while proving this with reason from the Quran and A ha d i th , he said, “If you bring even one verse against it, I am ready to abandon my belief.” Can anybody say that it means the Promised Messiah as (God forbid) did not have absolute certainty about it, and that he had any thought of any verse against his own beliefs? If anybody presumes it, he will be a great fool, because when he asked to bring even a single verse to show the physical living of ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) he would abandon his belief, it was said to keep in view the greatness and nobleness of the Holy Quran.It was his objective that he would abandon his belief if it were contrary to a single verse

Page 258

242 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH of the Quran.It was not his objective to mention that he had a belief against the Quran.Similarly the saying of Hadrat Abu Bakr ra did not mean that he could commit an open infidelity.But it means that truth should always be obeyed, and for this there is no question of any specific individual.“If I also commit such thing then you can disobey me.” It did not mean that he could ever act against the command of God and His Messenger, nor did it mean so in the presence of the command, “Obey Allah, and obey His Messenger and those who are in authority among you,” in the verse of Succession.Verse of Succession and the Second Khilafat Now, leaving the mention of Khilafat-e- Ahmadiyya under the verse of Succession, I take only my Khilafat.Allah, the Almighty has said: “Allah has promised to those among you who believe and do good works that He will surely make them Successors in the earth, as He made Successors from among those who were before them.” As long as there is a belief and acts of goodness in the majority of the people, the system of Khilafat

Page 259

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 243 continues among them.Therefore, it should be seen whether (1).The Jam a ‘at has belief and acts of goodness, i.e.whether our Jam a ‘at has noble reputation, and whether or not the majority of our Jam a ‘at do good works.For this there is no need for any argument.It is clear to everybody that the reputation of the Jam a ‘at is noble and the majority of Jam a ‘at members do good works.Since the conditions laid out for Khilafat (belief and acts of goodness) are satisfied, the promise of Khilafat must be fulfilled, as it says in the words, “Allah has promised to those among you who believe and do good works.” Allah, the Almighty has made this covenant with the believers, and the promise is definitely fulfilled.(2) Another thing Allah, the Almighty has mentioned in this verse is: i.e.“as He made Successors from among those who were before them.” Just as there have been Khulaf a ’ in the past, similarly there will be Khulaf a ’ in Ummat- e-Muhammadiyya.It means that as the previous Khulaf a ’ were appointed by the Divine power and nobody could face them.The same thing will happen now.This manifestation has also been proved through my Khilafat.At the time of the Khilafat of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra there was only a fear of external

Page 260

244 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH enemies, but at the time of my Khilafat there was also a fear of internal opponents along with the external enemies.Moreover Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra had the title of H ak i mul Ummat along with so many others, but for many years it was being propagated against me that if the reign of the Jam a ‘at came in the hands of this child, the Jam a ‘at would be ruined.I was neither a scholar of Arabic nor of English nor knew any art that might draw the attention of the people towards me, nor did I have any post and influence in the Jam a ‘at.All powers were with Maulaw i Muhammad Ali and he did whatever he liked.In such circumstances a person who was called a child by age; unaware of knowledge; who had no authority in Anjuman; no money in his hands; and people stood up against him had big degrees, all the wealth of the people in their hands, and been considered the masters of great honours for a long time.They claimed not to let this child be a Khalifah.But God failed them totally, and the same whom they called uneducated, intelligent, and about whom it was openly said that he would ruin the Jam a ‘at, Allah, the Almighty selected him for Khilafat.These people then became disappointed, and separated themselves by saying that the Jam a ‘at had committed a blunder by making an uneducated and immature child a Khalifah.In a few days they would see the wrong of their folly.They said that the Jam a ‘at would be ruined, and the recovery of money would stop.All honour and noble

Page 261

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 245 reputation would crumble to dust.And the ascension that the hierarchy had availed would be wasted by this uneducated child.But what has happened? The same child whom God made a Khalifah, like a lion who attacks the goats, invaded the world and brought the goats and sheeps from here and there.From east, west, north and south he has brought many to the altar of the Mas ih appointed by God.So much so that there are more people on this stage today than those who attended the last Jalsa Salana in the life of the Promised Messiah as.He whose eyes see and look, whose ears listen and hear, know that the grace of God has nullified all their objections which they made against me.He Who made this twenty-five years old youth, about whom they presumed that he would ruin the Jam a ‘at, by giving the Jam a ‘at amazing progress made it manifest that he is not made Khalifah by any person, but by Him, and there is nobody to challenge him.(3)The third manifestation that Allah, the Almighty has mentioned is: “that He will surely establish for them their religion which He has chosen for them.” The religious knowledge revealed to him by Allah, the Almighty will be spread in the world and nobody will have the power to destroy it.There is no doubt about it that the Companions ra acquired a special

Page 262

246 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH status through their companionship with the Holy Prophet sa.There is also no doubt about it that the Companions ra collected the A ha d i th which itself was a great work that raised their status to a great height which is beyond the perception of an ordinary man.Moreover, there is no doubt that Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra was an accomplished expert fond of the Holy Quran.There were also many great favours of him on Jam a ‘at Ahmadiyya.But against me, there was none who was charged of being uneducated.Therefore, the way the attribute of Al-‘Al i m (the All- Knowing) of Allah, the Almighty is displayed with great magnificence, through me, the precedent of it is not available in the class of Khulaf a ’.I was the same who was called a child of yesterday.I was the same who was called ignorant and unintelligent.But after taking the charge of Khilafat, Allah, the Almighty revealed the Quranic knowledge to me in such abundance that the Muslim ummah has to read my books for their benefit till the Day of Resurrection.Allah, the Almighty has enabled me to deal comprehensively with all issues facing Islam.There was no comprehensive discussion on the issue of Prophethood, issue of infidelity, Khilafat, fate, elaboration of the needed matters of Quran, Islamic Economy, Islamic Politics and Islamic policy etc.in the last thirteen hundred years.God enabled me to do this service of religion, and Allah, the Almighty has elucidated the doctrines of the Holy Quran through

Page 263

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 247 me which are being copied by all including friends and foes.Anyone may abuse me hundred thousand times, may reproach me, but the person who will spread the teachings of Islam in the world will have to partake from me, and he will always be under obligation to me whether he is Paighami or a Mi s r i.Whenever their offspring will plan to serve the religion, they will have to read my books for their benefit.I can say without pride that in this respect more material is collected through me than that of all other Khulaf a ’, and it is still going on.These people may abuse me, but the knowledge of the Quran will fall in their laps through me and the world will force them to say, “O silly persons, whatever is in your laps, you have taken it from that person, and for what do you oppose him?” (4) The fourth sign mentioned is: “that He will surely give them in exchange security and peace after their fear.” God will transform their fear into security.This sign has very clearly been shown by God in my age.When Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra became Khalifah, there was a fear of only external foes, mockery, and there was an attempt to hurt the unity of the Jam a ‘at.But at the beginning of my Khilafat there was not only the fear of external enemies but the Jam a ‘at was also inwardly damaged, and there was a danger that people would be adversely affected by this injury.In such circumstances God

Page 264

248 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH transformed their fear into security through me, and the danger of the deviation of Jam a ‘at from the true belief was totally diffused.Now see that Mi s r i Sahib, in spite of his hostility with me, is a believer of the Prophethood of the Promised Messiah as , and if he is honest and truthful he can admit that the Jam a ‘at’s firmness on this issue was achieved through me, and I resolved this issue.How did God get this issue resolved from a person, who according to Mi s r i Sahib, was to be dismissed? Similarly, the Jam a ‘at has to pass through great dangers but Allah, the Almighty helped me in every crisis, and transformed fear into security through me.When Ahrars were powerful, then the people thought of the ruin of the Jam a ‘at.But I said, ‘I see the ground slipping from the feet of Ahrar.’ After few days the ground slipped from the feet of Ahrar, and they were dishonoured and humiliated in the world.A short time ago a Sikh wrote a magazine 56 in which he addressed the people by mentioning my name and saying that however much they may call me a liar, one thing nobody can deny is that when the Ahrar were in their power, it was presumed that they would destroy Jam a ‘at Ahmadiyya.In those days the Imam Jam a ‘at Ahmadiyya said that he saw the ground slipping from the feet of Ahrar, and it is a fact that his saying proved true with great magnificence.Before it, whatever 56 Khal i fa-e-Qadian , pp.25-26, by Sardar Arjan Singh Amritsari, Edition Rangeen , Amritsar, First Edition.

Page 265

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 249 assignment the Ahrar took in their hands they succeeded in, but now it is their condition that whatever assignment they take in their hands, they fail in it.Similarly take the crisis of apostasy in Malkana, or the agitation on Rang i l a Ras u l , or many other political disturbances which arose in the meanwhile, you see that God helped me in every crisis, supported me in every trial, and transformed every fear into security for me.I never thought that Allah, the Almighty would get a great job done by me.I cannot hide this reality that God favoured me beyond my imagination.In the beginning of my Khilafat I did not know whether I would be able to do any service of religion.External circumstances were against me.There was no capability of doing some job.I was not a scholar nor learned nor had I wealth nor party, so God is my witness that when Khilafat was handed over to me, I at that time only considered that the flow of the stream of Divine recognition has been disturbed, and there is a danger of its wastage.Therefore, I was raised to put my lifeless body at that place to stop the flow of water from wastage.I poured my heart and soul for the protection of religion, and considered it the completion of my work.But three days had not yet passed on my Khilafat that the manifestations of Allah, the Almighty started descending like a rain.

Page 266

250 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH A Wonderful Manifestation of Allah, the Almighty A young man of Aligarh started collecting the prophecies of the Promised Messiah as related to me in the age of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra.He claimed that these prophecies were so great that nobody could deny them.He came to Qadian about twelve or thirteen days before the death of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra , and on seeing his critical condition he asked me to take his Bai‘at.I asked him “What a wrong thing you are doing? In the life of one Khalifah the talk about the next Khalifah is totally unlawful and forbidden by sharia.Why do you say it to me?” He went to Aligarh again.After twelve or thirteen days Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra died.As he had good relations with Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra , so at the time of differences on his death, some Paigamis wrote to him to manage and resolve these differences.On this he at once sent a telegraphic message to me to reconcile with them, otherwise the result would not be good.In reply I wrote to him that you had advised me to reconcile with them but my God has revealed to me, “Who can stop the works of God”.Therefore, I cannot reconcile with them.As far as your advice is concerned, remember that Allah, the Almighty has conclusively shown you the argument [supporting me].You have heard what Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra

Page 267

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 251 said about me, which was an indication that Allah, the Almighty would appoint me Khalifah after him.You yourself were writing a book in which you were collecting the prophecies of the Promised Messiah as about me.It you deny me now you would not escape from Atheism.I wrote this letter to him and a month had not yet passed that he became an Atheist.He is still so and openly denies the existence of Allah, the Almighty, whereas twelve or thirteen days before the death of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra he was ready to take my Bai‘at.And moreover, he was writing a book with the intention of collecting all the predictions of the Promised Messiah as related to me.But he denied the clear truth, and I wrote to him that the denying of me would lead to Atheism, and it happened within a month that he became an Atheist.After some time he came to me and started the debate on the predictions of the Promised Messiah as.I asked him to leave the predictions of Mirz a Sahib and tell me whether my prediction about him has been fulfilled or not.On this he became quiet.The Fulfillment of the Revelation “I Shall Break Them in Pieces” Related to Dissentients There was another great thing that the dissentients possessed—they were a large party.They were greatly proud that ninety-five percent of Jam a ‘at was

Page 268

252 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH with them.But Allah, the Almighty revealed to me in those days: that “He will surely break them in pieces”.So look at the Divine Power, the same Khawaja Kamaluddin who had very close relations with Maulaw i Muhammad Ali, so much so, that he agreed with everything that Khawaja Sahib said.Two years before the death of Khawaja Sahib they had serious disagreements.They accused each other beyond the limits.Then Dr.Sayyid Muhammad Husain and other members of Anjuman fought openly in Ahmadiyya Buildings.Someone told me that they shouted that: We are going to expel women from there.Yesterday one of them came to me and told me that some person had looted his property and asked me to pursue his case to recover it.So it happened as it was mentioned in the revelation, and their force was shattered.On the other side I was derisively called a young man of twenty-five.Allah, the Almighty gave me so much power that whenever there arises any crisis, I am able to crush it in such a way as if a fly or mosquito is crumbled, and nobody has the power to face me for a long time.Total Trust in Allah, the Almighty The fifth sign of a true Khalifah mentioned by Allah, the Almighty is:

Page 269

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 253 that “they will worship Me and will not associate anything with Me”.In accordance with this Divine promise I have never been afraid of anything by the grace of Allah, the Almighty.However, I am greatly cautious and I do not consider it a shortcoming, but a virtue.But when I am convinced of the correctness of a certain course of action, I do not care about the difficulties that may come in my way.This is the reason that in spite of great dangers Allah, the Almighty has always saved me from making compromises, and I have never been inclined to make an artificial reconciliation.A Dream about the Mischief of Mistries Once in a dream I saw myself while coming from Bahishti Maqbrah along with M i r Muhammad Is ha q ra.There was an ocean in the way.He and I both were sitting in the boat, and we sailed on.When the boat reached the place where there was the house of Mistries, it was entrapped in a whirlpool and started rotating.In the meanwhile a head appeared on the surface, who told us about the presence of the grave of a P i r there.He asked us to write a note to him so that the boat might come out of the whirlpool, and reach our destination safely.I said that it could not be so, as it was an act of faithlessness.After this the speed of rotation increased, and the danger of sinking of boat became evident.On this Mir Muhammad Is ha q ra said,

Page 270

254 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH “There is no harm in writing a note at this moment.When we are saved then we’ll repent”.I said, “It will not be so in any way”.Then he wrote a note secretly and desired to throw it in the rolled form in the sea, and by chance I saw it and said, “M i r Sahib, we may die but I’ll not permit such an act of idol worship”.I snatched the note from him and tore it into pieces, and after this I saw the boat came out of the whirlpool by itself.Many years after this dream, at the place where our boat was entrapped in a whirlpool in the dream, the mischief of Mistries emerged, and they put forth many allegations.Then one day, in fulfillment of my dream, M i r Muhammad Is ha q as came to me very embarrassed and said that there was no harm in giving some money to quiet them.I said, “M i r Sahib, if the allegations which they put are true then there is no sense in quietening them.If they are wrong then God Himself will destroy them.There is no need to give them money.” My Khilafat has an important distinction from the Khilafat of those Khulaf a ’ who have passed away.The discussion about the truthfulness of their Khilafat is a scholarly discussion, but in my case it is based on the miraculous signs of God in support of Khilafat.There is no point in debating whether any verse applies to my Khilafat or not.For me the fresh manifestations of God’s power and His live miracles are the proof of that God has made my Khilafat and

Page 271

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 255 there is no one to challenge it.If there is anyone who has the desire to challenge me, he can come forward to do so.Allah, the Almighty will humiliate and disgrace him.Not only he, but if all the powers of the world collectively want to destroy my Khilafat, God will crush them like a mosquito.And anyone who challenges me will fall, anyone who speaks against me will be quieted, and whoso tries to disgrace me will be disgraced and debased.O’ Jam a ‘at of the believers! O’ doers of good works, I tell you that Khilafat is a great blessing of Allah, the Almighty.Honour it.As long as the majority of you will remain believers and do good works, God will continue descending this blessing, but if your majority is deprived of faith and acts of goodness then it depends upon His will whether He continues it or not.Therefore, there is no question of any wrong with Khalifah.Khilafat will be taken at that time when you will be corrupted, so do not be ungrateful for this blessing, and see not the revelations of Allah, the Almighty contemptuously.Just as the Promised Messiah as said, “Keep on praying so that Second manifestation of Divine Power may continue blessing you.” Do not be like the unsuccessful, unfortunate and ignorant ones, who have rejected Khilafat, but keep yourself busy in praying that the manifestors of the Second Divine Power may always arise from you so that the religion may be established

Page 272

256 KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH on strong footings.That Satan may remain frustrated forever to break through it.Always Remain Engaged in Prayers for the Descending of Second Manifestation of Divine Power You should know that the Promised Messiah as has put the condition of prayers to ensure the descent of the Second Manifestation of Divine power.This promise is not for any age, but it is for all times.It was the meaning of this saying of the Promised Messiah as in this age that you should keep praying to have the first Khilafat.The prayers of the first Khilafat were meant so as to have the second Khilafat.After this the prayers in the second Khilafat were to continue to the third Khilafat; and in the third Khilafat, prayers are for the fourth Khilafat lest due to some adversity, your deeds close the door of this blessing on you.Always remain engaged in praying to Allah, the Almighty, and remember clearly that as long as Khilafat is with you, no nation of the world can dominate you, and you will remain victorious and successful in every field of life, because it is the covenant of God made in these words:

Page 273

KHILAFAT-E-R A SHIDAH 257 “Allah has promised to those among you who believe and do good works that He will surely make them Successors in the earth”.But also remember that: “whoso is ungrateful after that, they will be the rebellious”.May God be with you and may you remain His favourite Jam a ‘at till eternity.(Amen)

Page 274

Page 275

259 Index ‘ ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) Muhammad Husain Batalwi.....................................238 A Abu Bakr ra all people unanimously agreed for the Khilafat of,.........63 answer to why, nominated Umar ra..........................189 crookedness and open infidelity was not possible for him.........................236 his address at the death of Holy Prophet sa...............51 meaning of the statement of, ‘As long as I practice Islam, it is obligatory upon you to obey me, and if I abandon Islam and commit open infidelity, then it is obligatory upon you to check me.’...................235 resoluteness of, during the apostasy.......................169 Abu Hurairah ra during battle of S af i n, prayed at the side of Ali ra and dined at the side of Muawiyah....................182 spat in the scarf of Iranian King.............................174 Afghanistan after the martyrdom of some Ahmadis in, the protest from Jam a ‘at proved to be very effective...............187 Ali ra after the martyrdom of Usman ra the companions persuaded Ali ra to accept Bai‘at.............................68 martyrdom of,...................160 some miscreants argued that debate on Ali’s ra Khilafat was unnecessary because his Khilafat was based on prophecies of Holy Prophet sa and not on electoral decision...........73 Arabian Tribes reasons for mutiny of, after the death of the Holy Prophet sa........................45 Authorities separate commands for worldly authorities and Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n....124 the verse ‘ Those who are in authority among You’ is applicable to both worldly authorities and Khulaf a ’-e- R a shid i n.......................123 A yat-e-Istikhl a f and the second Khilafat, Khilafat of Hadrat Mu s le h Ma‘ u d..........................242 answer to the first objection made on, that the promise is made with the Muslim ummah, and not with some individuals...................179 answer to the fourth objection made on,......................212

Page 276

260 Index answer to the objection made on, that Khilafat only applies to the Khalifah immediately succeeding the Prophet..................216 answer to the second objection made on, is that the Khilafat of specific individuals is promised in this verse.....................197 answer to the third objection made on, is that Khilafat-e- Ahmadiyya does not satisfy this promise, because it does not have any political system under it..................................204 applies to both the Nubuwwat and Khilafat of the Promised Messiah as.....208 commentary of the Promised Messiah as on,................194 detailed discussion of,......131 four objections made on,..176 resemblance in, has been ascribed to Khilafat of prophethood and not the Khilafat of kingship.....146 summary of the subject matter of,................................138 B Battle of Jaml between Ali ra and Ayeshah ra.......................................69 Battle of S af i n between Ali ra and Muawiyah ra.......................................70 during, Abu Hurairah ra prayed at the side of Ali ra and dined at the side of Muawiyah....................182 C Christianity Khulaf a ’ of ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) had no connection with the management of the country...................209 reason why sharia is called a curse in,.........................14 Romans found excuse in Bible to declare sharia to be a curse..............................16 G Government essential features of,...........36 Holy Prophet's sa system of, 30 is the name of national boundaries and implimention of specific rules within it.................43 there are various forms of government....................42 H Hadith ‘if there would have been any Prophet after me, it would have been Umar bin Al Khatab’........................231 ‘the ulema of my ummah are like the Prophets of Ban i Isr a ’ i l’ refers only to the spiritual Khulaf a ’.........202 ‘There had not been any Prophethood which was not succeeded by Khilafat’.....................................233 explanation of ‘paradise is under the feet of mothers’.....................................106

Page 277

Index 261 Holy Prophet sa condition of companions ra on the death of,...................49 had all the powers required to run a government...........37 his followers had intense love with the Prophet............40 his vision of, golden bangles fulfilled after his death 162 organization developed by, had religious sanctity.......9 three groups of Companions ra after the demise of,........59 Hypocrites averted to go for Jihad........32 I Ibr a h i m as (Abraham) four Prophet Khulaf a ’ from his offspring accomplished his mission...................225 meaning of his ‘taming birds’.....................................226 resemblance between, and the Holy Prophet sa.............228 Infidels commandment to expel, from Arabia............................33 Islam an unfair objection of enemies of, on the phrase ‘pure spouses’.......................101 combination of organizations of state and religion in early period of,................7 defines all matters concerned with government............21 does not endorse any purely worldly organization...112 does not favour kingdoms..43 exerts authority over national matters...........................19 gives comprehensive guidance of, about all institutions of government....................23 Quran gives detailed instructions for implementation of law...24 Islamic Organization a detailed answer to the question raised about,......3 a mistake of Muslims not to establish a purely religious organization.................114 in case of disagreement with ‘authorities’ Allah says, ‘refer it to Allah and His Messenger’..................120 it is necessary to establish a purely religious organization.................113 principles of establishment of,.....................................118 Quranic principles of,.......111 second mistake of Muslims was failure to set up an electoral system for choosing the king........115 J Jam a ‘at Opponants blame Khilafat to damage the honour of Ahmadiyyat.....2 Judaism involvement of, in the institution of government.......................................18 Jum‘ah Hanfis believed that, could not be offered in India unless there was a Muslim Sultan...........................166 Maulaw i Ghulam Ali........167

Page 278

262 Index K Khalifah a truthfull Khalifah...........141 signs of true Khulaf a ’.......140 Khalifatul Masih I ra demise of,...........................87 Lahori people convinced, of their sincerity therefore sometimes he praised them.......................................93 the Will of, about the next Khalifah.......................218 whenever he was in need of money, Allah sent it from somewhere..................205 Khilafat ‘the ulema of my ummah are like the Prophets of Ban i Isr a ’ i l’ refers only to the spiritual Khulaf a ’........202 all people unanimously agreed for, of Abu Bakr ra..........63 Allah safeguards his Khulaf a ’ from ordinary fears......161 Allah transformed Ali’s ra fear into security.................160 appointment of Yazid as Khalifah by Hadrat Muawiyah ra cannot be called election..............189 deals with Islamic organization, whether it involves government or not.........................................6 denial of, would force us to admit that government of the Holy Prophet sa was not religious.........................12 details of issue of,..............46 dispute between Muh a jir i n and An sa r to appoint first Khalifah after the Holy Prophet sa........................60 earlier Khilafats were either Khilafats of prophethood or Khilafats of kingship144 fifth sign of true Khulaf a ’ is that their fearful condition is transformed into security.....................................154 fourth sign of true Khulaf a ’ is that their religious commands and ideas are spread in the world by Allah............................151 Holy Prophet sa said, ‘There is no Prophet after whom there has not been Khilafat’......................233 importance of, in Islam........2 is an Islamic organization, and not the outcome of an interim policy................44 is established through an electoral process in which the whole community is involved.......................188 it is against the sunnah of Companions ra that a father should propose his son for,.....................................191 it is unlawful to remove a Khalifah.......................220 Khilafat of previous Prophets—both in the form of Prophethood and kingship—was imperfect.....................................213 Khulaf a ’ of ‘ I sa as (Jesus Christ) had no connection with the management of the country...................209 loss of, is due to the shortcoming of a Jam a ‘at and not because of a shortcoming in the Khalifah.......................150

Page 279

Index 263 performance of prayer, in its true sense, is not possible without,.......................132 promise of, in A yat-e-Istikhl a f limited to the Khalifah immediately succeeding the Prophet..................216 promise of, is conditional upon faith and acts of goodness......................148 Quranic injunctions about,.95 resemblance in A yat-e- Istikhl a f has been ascribed to Khilafat of prophethood and not the Khilafat of kingship.......................146 rights of Khulaf a ’.............233 sixth sign of true Khulaf a ’ is that they worship Allah and do not associate any partners with Him........165 some miscreants argued that debate on Ali’s ra Khilafat was unnecessary because his Khilafat was based on prophecies of Holy Prophet sa and not on electoral decision...........73 surrender of throne by a son of Yazid.......................192 the promise of, is with those who believe and do good works...........................222 three groups of Muslims in reference to,...................74 true obedience to the Messenger is also not possible without,.........136 Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya a tract of Maulaw i Muhammad Ali that Khilafat should not be continued any longer.....90 advise of Promised Messiah to always remain engaged in prayers for the descending of second manifestation of Divine power...............256 after Khalifatul Masih I ra Maulaw i Muhammad Ali suggested to delay election of next Khalifah for 4 to 5 months...........................89 after the death of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra Maulaw i Muhammad Ali’s discussions with Mu s le h Ma‘ u d ra about Khilafat in Jam a ‘at..........................92 after the election of Khalifatul Masih I ra authority of Khalifah was questioned by Maulaw i Muhammad Ali..................................78 all arguments presented against Turkish Khilafat also affect,.......................7 assembly of representatives of outside Jam a ‘ats in Qadian to decide the successor of the Promised Massiah as..81 A yat-e-Istikhl a f applies to both the Nubuwwat and Khilafat of the Promised Messiah as.....................208 dissidents kept on scheming and tried to create disorder in the Jam a ‘at................85 establishment of the second Khilafat..........................93 Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra 82 Hadrat Mu s le h Ma‘ u d’s dream about the future of miscreants in the Jam a ‘at.......................................79 in an attempt to save Jam a ‘at from disunity Hadrat

Page 280

264 Index Mu s le h Ma‘ u d convinced his people to accept anyone from the opposite party as the next Khalifah...........87 Khawaja Kamaluddin and Maulaw i Muhammad Ali.......................................83 M i r Muhammad Is ha q ra presented some questions about the authority of Khalifah to Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra.......78 ninety percent of the members of, when the Jam a ‘at gave consent on Khilafat by election..........................91 proposal to publish an announcement during illness of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra........................85 relationship of Turkish Khilafat with,...................5 resemblance of the four Khulaf a ’ with the previous ones is not necessary in every matter.................197 should not be in charge of a political system because the Promised Messiah as himself was not in charge of any such system......204 the whole Jam a ‘at took Bai‘at at the hand of Hadrat Kha li fatul Mas ih I ra.......77 the Will of Khalifatul Masih I ra about the next Khalifah.....................................218 unanimous decision of the family of the Promised Messiah as.......................88 Khilafat-e-Nubuwwat cannot apply to the whole nation but only to some specific individuals......195 Khilafat-e-R a shidah A Hadith in regard of,..........1 after the deaths of Khulaf a ’-e- R a shid i n their fear continued to be transformed into security.....................................163 another verse in favour of, 224 other Khulaf a ’ were elected after the death of their predecessors, and Hadrat Umar ra was elected in the life of Hadrat Abu Bakr ra.....................................189 the awe of Khulaf a ’-e- R a shid i n on non-Muslim kings............................164 the only thing fearful for them was that Ummat-e- Muhammadiyya might go astray or be humiliated 161 Khulaf a ’-e-R a shid i n a model for the ummah....129 bold defences by Hadrat Usman ra and Hadrat Ali ra.....................................175 command to follow always sunnah of,....................127 resoluteness of Hadrat Abu Bakr ra during the apostasy.....................................169 Umar ra showed courage and sent an army to fight with Romans........................173 L Leader his job is not to do the work but get the work done..109 prefer competency during the election of a,................110 Quran commands to elect the leaders who are capable107

Page 281

Index 265 Quran commands, to render justice and equity.........108 M Maulaw i Muhammad Ali a tract of Maulaw i Muhammad Ali that Khilafat should not be continued any longer.....90 after Khalifatul Masih I ra Maulaw i Muhammad Ali suggested to delay election of next Khalifah for 4 to 5 months...........................89 renewed his Bai‘at at the hand of Hadrat Khalifatul Masih I ra...................................83 threatened to leave Qadian.84 Muawiyah ra appointment of Yazid as Khalifah by, cannot be called election..............189 Mu s le h Ma‘ u d ra a dream of, about the mischief of Mistries...................253 Divine signs in favour of the Khilafat of,..................242 fulfillment of the revelation ‘I shall break them in pieces’ related to dissentients..251 his dream fulfilled about dissidents in the Jam a ‘at 79 his dream was fulfilled about the death of Khalifatul Masih I ra........................87 P Paradise cooperation of man and woman is imperative for the creation of paradise of this world and of the hereafter.......................102 explanation of Hadith that ‘paradise is under the feet of mothers’..................106 paradise can be established by entrusting the trusts to the deserving.....................107 paradise cannot be established until men and women strive collectively........103 some enemies of Islam object the presence of women in paradise.......................101 Politics can exist with or without government......................6 Promised Messiah as in the last years of his life revelations about his demise increased manifold.......................................76 like the companions of the Holy Prophet sa Ahmadis did not think about the death of the Promised Messiah as.......................75 Prophet because of the intense love the followers never think that their Prophet will die in their lifetime..................46 both personal and national lives of, start with revelation.......................54 national life of a, starts with revelation.......................58 no consideration on succession of, in his lifetime..........................52 every Prophet has two lives 54 personal life of a, is first manifestation of Divine

Page 282

266 Index power and his national life is second........................54 Q Qir ta s [Folio] two answers to the objection of dispute of,..................55 R Religion two types of,.......................13 S S al a t and Fasting are necessary for the spiritual progress of a person............................44 Sunni Elder posed to be a Shia in presence of a Shia King..............168 U Umar ra after consultation Abu Bakr ra oppionted Umar ra as the next Khalifah.................65 election of, for Khilafat......65 he would pray for his martyrdom...................156 showed courage and sent an army to fight with Romans.....................................173 was not afraid of his martyrdom...................156 Usman ra he never entertained any fear.....................................157 murderers of, convinced Ayeshah ra to declare Jihad and get revenge for Usman’s blood...............69 on his deathbed Umar ra nominated six persons to be elected third Khalifah from among them..........66 Z Zakat commandment to collect,...31 despite opposition Abu Bakr ra took Zakat from Muslims.....................................172 three benefits of Zakat........31

Page 283

Khilafat-e-R a shidah , a remarkable speech made by Hadrat Khalifatul Masih II ra on the silver jubilee of his Khilafat—in 1939—addresses all relevant issues in regard to Khilafat, whether related to the past Khilafat-e-R a shidah or the present one.The Prophecy about Khilafat in the Muslim ummah—a long cherished belief held by the Muslims—has been corroborated by the Quran and Hadith and also by the writings of the Promised Messiah as.The issue of the authority and role of a Khalifah in the affairs of government has also been expounded by the writer.The Khilafat-e-Ahmadiyya, in the true sense, is in harmony with the prophecies of Khilafat in the footsteps of Prophethood.The writer also sheds light on the issues regarding Ahmadiyya Khilafat questioned by some dissidents and their ultimate failure.The book is a must for all those who harbour doubts and have misgivings about the veracity of Khilafat- e-R a shidah.

Page 283